Benchmarking som normaliserende styringsteknologi

Peter TriantafillouPolitica 2006 · DOI

Published in the journal politica in 2006, Peter Triantafillou’s research offers a critical sociological perspective on a tool often viewed as a neutral administrative necessity: benchmarking. While engineers and managers typically frame benchmarking as a objective method for optimizing performance, Triantafillou argues it is a sophisticated "technology of power" that fundamentally reshapes how public institutions—specifically Danish hospitals—govern themselves.

The Problem: Governance from a Distance

The paper addresses the gap between the administrative justification for benchmarking (efficiency and quality) and its actual political function. In the late 1990s and early 2000s, the Danish public sector experienced a massive surge in benchmarking initiatives. Triantafillou asks a fundamental question: How does benchmarking actually exercise power?

Traditional views of power, where one actor explicitly forces another to act, are insufficient to explain modern governance. Instead, Triantafillou employs Michel Foucault’s concept of "governmentality" to demonstrate how benchmarking steers organizations "from a distance." This is achieved by activating the organizations' own desire to be perceived as "normal" or "the best," effectively turning external metrics into internal motivations.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

This qualitative policy analysis utilizes Foucault’s theories on power, freedom, and normalization. Triantafillou distinguishes "Advanced Liberalism"—a mode of governing through the self-management of individuals and groups—from earlier forms of liberalism.

To ground this theory, the author examines two major benchmarking initiatives within the Danish hospital system:

  1. Productivity Measurements: Utilizing DRG (Diagnosis Related Groups) data to compare costs and output.
  2. Patient Satisfaction: The LUP (Landsdækkende Undersøgelse af Patientoplevelser), a national survey benchmarking hospitals based on user experience.

The analysis draws on policy documents from the Ministry of Finance and the National Board of Health, supplemented by interviews and case studies of specific hospitals (such as those in Viborg and Gentofte) to observe how they responded to their rankings.

Key Insights: The Mechanics of Normalization

Power through Freedom

Benchmarking rarely relies on "hard" power, such as legal bans or direct mandates. Instead, it utilizes "soft" power. By presenting a hospital with data showing they fall below the "norm," the system pressures the institution to use its own professional "freedom" to reorganize. The hospital is not forced to change by a central authority; it chooses to change to avoid being an outlier.

The Production of "The Normal"

Benchmarking creates a common yardstick that defines what is acceptable. However, this "normal" is not a static goal but a moving target. As underperforming institutions improve to meet the average, the average itself shifts upward. This creates a cycle of permanent self-improvement where the goal of being "good enough" is structurally impossible to reach.

Resistance as Integration

One of the paper’s most striking insights is that even resistance reinforces the system. When hospital staff criticize metrics—for example, arguing that their specific patient demographic is "sicker" than the average—they are forced to use the language and logic of the benchmark to make their case. By engaging with the data to contest it, they inadvertently validate the benchmark as the only legitimate framework for discussing performance.

Results and Institutional Impact

The study highlights several transformative effects on the Danish healthcare landscape:

  • Productivity Steering: DRG-based benchmarking in the 1990s successfully forced hospitals to prioritize "output per unit of input," leading to significant organizational restructuring even when the underlying data was contested by clinicians.
  • Quantifying the Qualitative: The LUP surveys transformed the subjective "patient experience" into a quantifiable norm. Hospitals that scored poorly felt an immediate compulsion to implement clinical changes—such as assigning specific contact persons—to align with national averages.
  • Identity Shift: Benchmarking has moved from a novel tool to an integrated pillar of health policy. This has fundamentally altered the professional identity of hospital managers, shifting their role from "medical experts" to "performance managers."

Conclusion: The Role of the Researcher

Triantafillou concludes by noting that benchmarking is a hallmark of advanced liberal governance, where the state shifts from direct service provision to "steering" autonomous actors through audits and competition. He suggests that researchers face a moral choice: act as "technicians" who help the state refine these management tools, or act as "critics" who highlight the underlying power dynamics. For Triantafillou, the latter is essential for maintaining a democratic dialogue regarding how public institutions are controlled.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{triantafillou2006benchmarking,
  author = {Peter Triantafillou},
  title = {{Benchmarking som normaliserende styringsteknologi}},
  booktitle = {Politica},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.7146/politica.v38i1.69847},
}

Loading related content...

Figure