Benchmark models, planes, lines and points for future SUSY searches at the LHC

Shehu AbdusSalam, B. C. Allanach, Herbi K. Dreiner, J. Ellis, Ulrich Ellwanger, John F. Gunion, S. Heinemeyer, Michael Krämer, M. Mangano, Keith A. Olive, S. Rogerson, Leszek Roszkowski, M. Schlaffer, G. WeigleinThe European Physical Journal C 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper addresses the challenge of interpreting experimental results from searches for Supersymmetry (SUSY) at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). The authors propose a comprehensive set of benchmark models, parameter planes, lines, and specific points to standardize the presentation and comparison of these search results across different theoretical scenarios, aiding both experimentalists and theorists.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Searches for new physics, particularly Supersymmetry (SUSY), at the LHC are complex. The Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM), a leading theoretical framework for SUSY, has a vast parameter space, making it difficult to present experimental results in a model-independent way. While "simplified models" offer a more model-independent approach, they can miss crucial theoretical constraints and features. To bridge this gap, the authors aim to define a standardized set of "benchmark models" and associated parameter subspaces (planes, lines, and points) that represent a diverse range of physically motivated SUSY scenarios. These benchmarks are intended to facilitate the interpretation of experimental data, guide future searches, and enable detailed detector performance tests by providing concrete, well-defined theoretical targets.

Methods

The paper defines several benchmark models, building upon existing well-studied scenarios like the Constrained MSSM (CMSSM) and Minimal Supergravity (mSUGRA). They also introduce or adapt models such as the Non-Universal Higgs Mass (NUHM), Minimal Gauge-Mediated SUSY Breaking (mGMSB), Anomaly-Mediated SUSY Breaking (AMSB), Mixed Modulus-AMSB (MM-AMSB), a phenomenological 19-parameter MSSM (p19MSSM), R-parity violating MSSM (RPV-CMSSM), and the Next-to-Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (NMSSM). For each model, they propose specific parameter subspaces:

  • Planes: Two-dimensional slices of the parameter space, often chosen to highlight the impact of specific constraints (e.g., from Higgs properties or dark matter relic density).
  • Lines: One-dimensional paths within these planes, designed to illustrate how experimental signatures evolve as a particular parameter is varied.
  • Points: Specific points along these lines, chosen to represent distinct phenomenological scenarios or to align with current experimental constraints and theoretical fits.

The authors also describe algorithms for selecting points along these lines and provide a few points motivated by recent experimental data fits. They utilize established tools like SOFTSUSY and Sdecay for spectrum generation and decay calculations.

Datasets

The paper does not use experimental datasets for training or evaluation in the traditional machine learning sense. Instead, it proposes a set of theoretical benchmarks that can be used by experimental collaborations (like ATLAS and CMS) to interpret their data. These benchmarks are informed by:

  • Existing theoretical models: CMSSM, mSUGRA, mGMSB, mAMSB, etc.
  • Experimental constraints: Limits from previous LHC searches and other low-energy measurements (e.g., (g-2)μ, b→sγ).
  • Cosmological constraints: Dark matter relic density requirements.
  • Recent global fits: Theoretical fits to available experimental data.

The paper references existing benchmark points like the Snowmass Points and Slopes (SPS) and updates them or proposes new ones.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Standardization is Crucial: The sheer complexity of SUSY models necessitates a standardized set of benchmarks for meaningful comparison of experimental results and for guiding future searches.
  • Diversity of Signatures: Different SUSY breaking scenarios and parameter choices lead to vastly different experimental signatures, ranging from multi-lepton events to signatures with many jets and missing energy.
  • Interplay of Constraints: The choice of benchmark points is heavily influenced by the interplay of various constraints, including direct SUSY searches, electroweak precision measurements, and cosmological dark matter requirements.
  • Evolution of Benchmarks: The proposed lines allow for a continuous exploration of parameter space, enabling researchers to adapt to evolving experimental limits by moving to new points along a line.
  • Beyond CMSSM: While CMSSM remains a central focus, the paper emphasizes the growing importance of exploring alternative SUSY models (like mGMSB, mAMSB, NMSSM, and RPV) due to increasing pressure on CMSSM parameter space from LHC data.

Key Results

The paper defines a comprehensive set of benchmark models, planes, lines, and points for future SUSY searches. This includes:

  • 10 benchmark models: CMSSM, NUHM, mGMSB, mAMSB, MM-AMSB, p19MSSM, RPV-CMSSM, and NMSSM.
  • Numerous planes and lines: Detailed parameter spaces are explored for CMSSM, NUHM, mGMSB, mAMSB, MM-AMSB, p19MSSM, and RPV-CMSSM.
  • Specific benchmark points: A selection of points are provided along these lines, with detailed spectral information and branching ratios, designed to illustrate distinct phenomenological signatures.
  • Algorithms for point selection: Methods are described for choosing points along lines that are relevant for experimental searches.
  • Motivation from fits: Several benchmark points are motivated by recent fits to experimental data, aiming to represent currently favored regions of parameter space.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Dependence: While aiming for broad applicability, the benchmarks are still tied to specific theoretical models. The authors acknowledge that the phenomenology of these models can differ significantly from other, less explored scenarios.
  • Experimental Evolution: The "active point" along a line is defined as the lightest one not ruled out by current LHC searches. As experimental limits advance, this "active point" will shift, requiring ongoing updates.
  • Computational Cost: Generating spectra and event simulations for all proposed benchmarks can be computationally intensive.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that additional work is needed to clarify the distinguishability of models like CNMSSM and CMSSM at the LHC, and to explore the full range of scenarios within models like the sNMSSM. They also note that Higgs signals could play a more significant role in distinguishing models, especially if a light Higgs boson is discovered. The paper also mentions that input files for Monte Carlo event generation are available upon request, facilitating further studies.

Summary updated

Abstract

We define benchmark models for SUSY searches at the LHC, including the CMSSM, NUHM, mGMSB, mAMSB, MM-AMSB and p19MSSM, as well as models with R-parity violation and the NMSSM. Within the parameter spaces of these models, we propose benchmark subspaces, including planes, lines and points along them. The planes may be useful for presenting results of the experimental searches in different SUSY scenarios, while the specific benchmark points may serve for more detailed detector performance tests and comparisons. We also describe algorithms for defining suitable benchmark points along the proposed lines in the parameter spaces, and we define a few benchmark points motivated by recent fits to existing experimental data.
BibTeX
@article{abdussalam2011benchmark,
  author = {Shehu AbdusSalam and B. C. Allanach and Herbi K. Dreiner and J. Ellis and Ulrich Ellwanger and John F. Gunion and S. Heinemeyer and Michael Krämer and M. Mangano and Keith A. Olive and S. Rogerson and Leszek Roszkowski and M. Schlaffer and G. Weiglein},
  title = {{Benchmark models, planes, lines and points for future SUSY searches at the LHC}},
  journal = {The European Physical Journal C},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1140/epjc/s10052-011-1835-7},
}
Figure