Behavioral training promotes multiple adaptive processes following acute hearing loss

Peter Keating, Onayomi Rosenior-Patten, Johannes C Dahmen, Olivia Bell, Andrew J. KingeLife 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

Adult humans, with targeted behavioral training, can adapt to temporary hearing loss in one ear by employing two distinct strategies: remapping altered binaural cues or reweighting intact spectral cues. This dual adaptability, previously observed in developing ferrets, highlights the brain's remarkable flexibility and suggests potential for new therapeutic approaches to sensory disorders.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The human brain is remarkably adept at maintaining accurate perception of the world despite sensory input changes. When hearing loss occurs in one ear (monaural deprivation), it disrupts the binaural cues (interaural time and level differences) that normally help us pinpoint sound locations. While developmental studies in animals have shown that the brain can adapt to this by either learning to interpret the altered binaural cues differently (cue remapping) or by relying more heavily on the remaining spectral cues (cue reweighting), it was unclear if adult humans could utilize both strategies, especially with only short-term deprivation. Previous research suggested adults might be less flexible, primarily relying on cue reweighting. This paper investigates whether adult humans can indeed employ both adaptive processes following acute, temporary monaural deprivation, and whether these processes are supported by distinct neural mechanisms.

Methods

The study involved two main components: human behavioral experiments and ferret neurophysiological recordings.

Human Behavioral Experiments: * Participants: 11 healthy adult humans. * Procedure: Participants wore an earplug in one ear for short training sessions spread over three weeks. They were trained to localize sounds from 12 loudspeakers arranged in a circle. * Stimuli: * Flat-spectrum broadband noise: Provided all available auditory spatial cues (binaural and spectral). * Random-spectrum broadband noise: Disrupted spectral cues, making it harder to rely on them. * Pure tones (low and high frequency): Primarily rely on binaural cues (ITDs for low, ILDs for high frequencies). * Training Protocol: Included feedback and "correction trials" for flat-spectrum stimuli to directly measure adaptation. Random-spectrum and pure tone trials were interleaved without feedback to assess specific cue contributions. * Analysis: Performance was measured by percentage correct and error magnitude. Adaptation rates were calculated using linear regression on session data. Cue reweighting was inferred from performance differences between flat and random spectrum stimuli. Cue remapping was assessed by changes in localization bias and error magnitude for pure tones, which rely more on binaural cues.

Ferret Neurophysiological Recordings: * Participants: Ferrets reared with intermittent monaural deprivation. * Procedure: Extracellular recordings were made from primary auditory cortex neurons. * Stimuli: Virtual acoustic space stimuli designed to manipulate individual spatial cues. * Analysis: Neuronal responses were analyzed to determine "cue weights" (how much a neuron relies on spectral cues) and "best ILDs" (indicating binaural cue processing). These measures were compared between deprived and control animals to assess neurophysiological plasticity related to cue reweighting and remapping.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed as distinct datasets. The study generated its own behavioral and neurophysiological data from human and ferret participants under controlled experimental conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Adult Brains are More Flexible Than Previously Thought: Contrary to some prior assumptions, adult humans can indeed learn to use both cue remapping and cue reweighting to adapt to temporary hearing loss, provided they receive appropriate training.
  • Dual Adaptation Strategies: The brain can adapt by either learning to interpret the altered binaural cues in a new way (remapping) or by shifting reliance to the intact spectral cues (reweighting).
  • Frequency-Specific Adaptation: The brain appears to utilize these strategies differently depending on the sound frequency. Cue reweighting is more prominent for higher frequencies where spectral cues are more informative, while cue remapping is more general across frequencies for binaural cues.
  • Distinct Neural Substrates: The neurophysiological data from ferrets suggest that cue remapping and cue reweighting are supported by different populations of neurons in the auditory cortex, indicating they are indeed distinct adaptive processes.
  • Training is Key: The study strongly emphasizes that targeted behavioral training is crucial for unlocking these adaptive capabilities in adults, suggesting that passive exposure to hearing loss might not be sufficient for full adaptation.

Key Results

  • Human Behavioral Adaptation: Adult humans showed significant improvement in sound localization accuracy after just a few weeks of training with an earplug.
  • Adaptation was significantly greater for flat-spectrum stimuli (which allow for both remapping and reweighting) compared to random-spectrum stimuli (which primarily test reweighting). This indicates that cue reweighting plays a role.
  • Localization of pure tones (which rely on binaural cues) also improved, showing a reduction in error magnitude and bias. This demonstrates cue remapping.
  • Ferret Neurophysiology: Neurons in the auditory cortex of ferrets with monaural deprivation showed evidence of both cue reweighting and cue remapping.
  • The degree of cue reweighting and cue remapping in individual neurons was not correlated, further supporting their independence.
  • The type of plasticity observed in neurons was frequency-dependent, aligning with the behavioral findings.
  • Independence of Processes: In both humans and ferrets, the amount of cue remapping and cue reweighting was largely independent, suggesting they are distinct processes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Episodic vs. Chronic Hearing Loss: The human study involved brief, episodic hearing loss, whereas ferret studies often involve more chronic deprivation. The paper notes that it's unclear if the rapid adaptation seen in humans is due to the same physiological changes as in ferrets.
  • Stage of Processing: It's unknown at which level of the auditory processing hierarchy these adaptive changes occur (e.g., brainstem, midbrain, cortex).
  • Individual Differences: The study observed individual differences in adaptation strategies. Future work could explore the reasons for these differences and how they might inform tailored rehabilitation strategies.
  • Therapeutic Potential: The findings highlight the importance of training for promoting adaptation and suggest that understanding these mechanisms could lead to novel therapeutic strategies for sensory disorders, particularly those involving partial sensory loss.

Summary updated

Abstract

The brain possesses a remarkable capacity to compensate for changes in inputs resulting from a range of sensory impairments. Developmental studies of sound localization have shown that adaptation to asymmetric hearing loss can be achieved either by reinterpreting altered spatial cues or by relying more on those cues that remain intact. Adaptation to monaural deprivation in adulthood is also possible, but appears to lack such flexibility. Here we show, however, that appropriate behavioral training enables monaurally-deprived adult humans to exploit both of these adaptive processes. Moreover, cortical recordings in ferrets reared with asymmetric hearing loss suggest that these forms of plasticity have distinct neural substrates. An ability to adapt to asymmetric hearing loss using multiple adaptive processes is therefore shared by different species and may persist throughout the lifespan. This highlights the fundamental flexibility of neural systems, and may also point toward novel therapeutic strategies for treating sensory disorders.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{keating2016behavioral,
  author = {Peter Keating and Onayomi Rosenior-Patten and Johannes C Dahmen and Olivia Bell and Andrew J. King},
  title = {{Behavioral training promotes multiple adaptive processes following acute hearing loss}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.12264},
}
Figure