Behavior Drift Detection Based on Anomalies Identification in Home Living Quantitative Indicators

Fabio Veronese, Andrea Masciadri, Sara Comai, Matteo Matteucci, Fabio SaliceTechnologies 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel system for detecting behavioral drift in elderly individuals living independently, using quantitative indicators derived from home automation data. By employing Complex Event Processing (CEP) and a two-stage statistical anomaly detection method, the system aims to provide early warnings of potential health issues, enabling proactive care.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing aging population and the desire for individuals to age in place present a significant challenge for monitoring their well-being and detecting potential health declines or emergencies. Traditional methods often rely on reactive responses or intrusive monitoring. This paper addresses the need for a non-intrusive, automated system that can identify subtle, long-term changes in behavior (behavioral drift) that might indicate conditions like dementia or other health issues, allowing for timely intervention. The core problem is to translate raw sensor data from a smart home into meaningful indicators of an individual's daily routine and to detect deviations from that routine.

Methods

The authors propose a system that leverages Complex Event Processing (CEP), specifically using the Esper engine, to analyze live streams of home automation data. The core of their approach lies in developing quantitative indicators that capture different aspects of a person's behavior. These indicators are categorized into four main groups:

  • Sensor Activation Time (SAT): Measures the duration a specific sensor is active within a given time window (e.g., bed sensor activity to track sleep patterns).
  • Resource Consumption (RC): Infers behavior by tracking the usage of resources like water, which can indicate hygiene or housekeeping habits.
  • Activity Daily Time (ADT): Focuses on recognizing specific sequences of sensor activations to identify and quantify the duration of particular activities (e.g., watching TV).
  • Entropy Based (EB): Utilizes information theory concepts to measure the information content or randomness in sensor data, providing a broader view of overall activity levels and routine changes.

To automatically detect anomalies in these indicators, they developed a novel σQ-test method. This method combines two statistical tests: a t-test to identify "warnings" (mild deviations) and a Dixon's Q-test to flag "alarms" (significant outliers). This two-stage approach allows for a graded response and aims to adapt to normal routine modifications while still detecting abrupt changes. The tests are applied to a moving time window (28 days) to account for weekly cyclical patterns.

Datasets

The paper utilized two types of datasets:

  • Real-world datasets: Specifically, the ARAS dataset was used for initial testing and development of the quantitative indicators.
  • Simulated datasets: To specifically introduce and study behavioral drift, two simulated datasets were generated using the SHARON simulator. These datasets, each approximately three months long, were designed to mimic the conditions of Alzheimer's Disease (AD), including erratic sleep patterns, increased duration of complex activities, and augmented passive activities. The simulated drift was introduced in the second 90 days of the 180-day experimental period.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the gap between raw sensor data and meaningful behavior: The paper demonstrates that simple sensor activations can be transformed into robust indicators of daily living patterns.
  • Multi-faceted behavioral monitoring: The four distinct indicator types (SAT, RC, ADT, EB) provide a comprehensive view of an individual's routine, capturing different aspects from sleep to resource usage and specific activities.
  • The power of CEP for real-time analysis: Using Esper allows for continuous monitoring and immediate processing of home automation data, crucial for timely anomaly detection.
  • A two-stage anomaly detection for nuanced alerts: The σQ-test offers a more sophisticated approach than simple thresholding, distinguishing between minor deviations and significant outliers, which is vital for avoiding alert fatigue.
  • Simulated drift as a valuable tool: The use of a simulator to introduce AD-like symptoms proved effective in validating the system's ability to detect behavioral changes, even subtle ones.

Key Results

  • The developed quantitative indicators (SAT, RC, ADT, EB) were shown to be effective in evidencing behavioral changes, particularly when tested on simulated data exhibiting AD-like symptoms.
  • The ADT indicator for "watching TV" achieved a precision of 0.95 and a recall of 0.92 in detecting the activity.
  • The SAT indicator on the bed sensor clearly showed spikes corresponding to the induced behavioral drift, reflecting changes in sleep patterns.
  • The RC indicator for water consumption became more irregular due to changes in sleeping patterns and increased duration of activities like showering.
  • The EB indicator on the bed sensor captured the irregularity of the sleeping pattern, with its value decreasing as the pattern became more erratic.
  • The σQ-test successfully flagged unexpected events as warnings or alarms, with markers appearing more frequently after the induced change in routine. The system demonstrated the ability to detect both abrupt changes and the gradual onset of behavioral drift.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Validation on simulated data: A primary limitation acknowledged is that the system's validation was primarily conducted using simulated data. The authors emphasize the need to integrate the system into real-world smart home environments (like the BRIDGe system) to collect and validate with actual data.
  • "Smooth" changes interpretation: While the system can detect abrupt changes, the authors note that identifying and interpreting "smooth" or gradual behavioral changes, which are common due to aging and other life factors, remains a further challenge for future work.
  • Publishing datasets: The authors plan to publish datasets for open usage and validation in future work.
  • Notification module: The system is intended to be equipped with a notification module to provide customized warnings and alarms to caregivers, which is a planned future enhancement.

Summary updated

Abstract

Home Automation and Smart Homes diffusion are providing an interesting opportunity to implement elderly monitoring. This is a new valid technological support to allow in-place aging of seniors by means of a detection system to notify potential anomalies. Monitoring has been implemented by means of Complex Event Processing on live streams of home automation data: this allows the analysis of the behavior of the house inhabitant through quantitative indicators. Different kinds of quantitative indicators for monitoring and behavior drift detection have been identified and implemented using the Esper complex event processing engine. The chosen solution permits us not only to exploit the queries when run “online”, but enables also “offline” (re-)execution for testing and a posteriori analysis. Indicators were developed on both real world data and on realistic simulations. Tests were made on a dataset of 180 days: the obtained results prove that it is possible to evidence behavior changes for an evaluation of a person’s condition.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{veronese2018behavior,
  author = {Fabio Veronese and Andrea Masciadri and Sara Comai and Matteo Matteucci and Fabio Salice},
  title = {{Behavior Drift Detection Based on Anomalies Identification in Home Living Quantitative Indicators}},
  booktitle = {Technologies},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/technologies6010016},
}
Figure