Bayesian analysis of non-linear differential equation models with application to a gut microbial ecosystem

Daniel J. Lawson, Grietje Holtrop, Harry J. FlintBiometrical 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a hierarchical Bayesian approach to infer parameters in complex, non-linear differential equation models, particularly useful when data is scarce. By pooling information across multiple related experiments, this method allows for more robust and powerful inference than analyzing each experiment in isolation, offering a way to understand systems like the human gut microbiome that are difficult to study directly.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many biological and physical systems are described by complex non-linear differential equations, but inferring the parameters of these models is challenging, especially when experimental data is limited. Traditional approaches often involve measuring each parameter separately, which is impractical and ignores parameter interactions. Furthermore, systems like the human gut microbiome are largely inaccessible for direct measurement, making it difficult to obtain sufficient data for accurate parameter estimation. This paper tackles the problem of inferring parameters for such systems by leveraging data from multiple, related experiments, even when individual experiments provide sparse or noisy information.

Methods

The core of this paper is a hierarchical Bayesian approach for parameter inference in non-linear differential equation models. This method is structured in three levels:

  1. Observation Level: Models the observed data (e.g., bacterial or SCFA concentrations) as a function of the model's state and experiment-specific parameters, incorporating measurement error.
  2. Experiment-Specific Parameter Level: Assumes that the parameters for each individual experiment ($\theta_\alpha$) are drawn from a common distribution with a mean ($\mu$) and between-experiment variance ($\Sigma$). This is where the "pooling" of information happens.
  3. Global Parameter Level: Defines prior distributions for the global parameters ($\mu$ and $\Sigma$), which represent the overall characteristics of the system across all experiments.

The authors employ Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC), specifically a Metropolis-Hastings algorithm, to evaluate the posterior distribution of the model parameters. They also discuss strategies for assessing convergence and improving inference, such as using maximum a-posteriori (MAP) estimates. The novelty lies in the hierarchical structure that explicitly models the relationship between parameters across different experimental conditions, allowing for more powerful inference than treating experiments independently.

Datasets

The paper uses two types of datasets:

  1. Simulated Data: The authors generate synthetic data from their differential equation models to test the performance of their hierarchical Bayesian approach under controlled conditions. This includes simulations for a single bacterial type (Study 1) and for two bacterial types (Study 2), at different pH levels.
  2. Experimental Data: The primary real-world dataset used is from Walker et al. (2005), which describes bacterial populations and short-chain fatty acid (SCFA) concentrations in fermentor experiments mimicking aspects of the human gut microbiome. These experiments were conducted at two different pH levels (5.5 and 6.5).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hierarchical Bayesian modeling is powerful for sparse data: The core insight is that by explicitly modeling the relationships between parameters across related experiments, we can achieve much more robust parameter inference than by analyzing each experiment in isolation, especially when data is limited.
  • Identifiability issues are overcome by pooling: Individual experiments might suffer from parameter non-identifiability (where multiple parameter combinations yield similar model outputs). The hierarchical structure, by linking parameters across experiments, helps to resolve these identifiability issues.
  • Predictive power for "what-if" scenarios: The resulting predictive model, with quantified uncertainty, can be used to explore scenarios that are difficult or impossible to study experimentally, such as the effect of nutrient absorption in the gut.
  • pH significantly impacts microbial dynamics: The analysis of the gut microbiome data highlights how changes in pH (representing different regions of the colon) can drastically alter bacterial growth rates and community composition.
  • Prior knowledge is crucial but can be informed: While informative priors are beneficial, the paper demonstrates how the model can also reveal when prior expectations are significantly challenged by the data, suggesting a need for revision.

Key Results

  • Improved inference in simulation studies: Scenario A (simultaneous inference) in Study 1 showed converged MCMC chains and accurate parameter recovery, whereas Scenario B (separate inference with summary statistics) resulted in poor convergence and incorrect inference due to parameter non-identifiability.
  • Successful application to real gut microbiome data: The hierarchical approach was applied to experimental data, allowing for inference on 29 parameters. The results indicated that the AcProd group's growth rate on starch at acidic pH differed significantly from prior expectations, and the Bac group's acetate production was less efficient than anticipated.
  • Demonstration of predictive capabilities: The model's predictions for bacterial and SCFA concentrations were shown to align with observed data, and the paper illustrated how the model could predict long-term trends and the impact of factors like SCFA absorption.
  • Identifiability issues in complex scenarios: In more complex scenarios (Study 2, Scenario E), where some measurements were omitted, identifiability issues arose between certain parameters (e.g., Rrec SCFA inefficiency and Bac Acetate production), underscoring the importance of sufficient data diversity and informative priors.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplification: The authors acknowledge that their model is a simplification of the complex gut ecosystem, omitting factors like spatial structure and fluctuations in flow. Not all observed data points were perfectly matched by the model, suggesting potential omissions.
  • Data Sparsity: While the hierarchical approach helps, the inference is still constrained by the amount and diversity of available data. For more complex models or to infer variance components, more time samples and replicated fermentors might be needed.
  • Prior Sensitivity: The paper notes that the inference can be sensitive to the strength of prior distributions, especially in scenarios with limited data or identifiability issues.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their approach provides a powerful tool for microbiologists to explore "what-if" scenarios, such as the impact of metabolite absorption. They also highlight the need for more detailed modeling of metabolic pathways to generalize to different conditions and the potential for applying this black-box approach to other complex systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Process models specified by non-linear dynamic differential equations contain many parameters, which often must be inferred from a limited amount of data. We discuss a hierarchical Bayesian approach combining data from multiple related experiments in a meaningful way, which permits more powerful inference than treating each experiment as independent. The approach is illustrated with a simulation study and example data from experiments replicating the aspects of the human gut microbial ecosystem. A predictive model is obtained that contains prediction uncertainty caused by uncertainty in the parameters, and we extend the model to capture situations of interest that cannot easily be studied experimentally.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lawson2011bayesian,
  author = {Daniel J. Lawson and Grietje Holtrop and Harry J. Flint},
  title = {{Bayesian analysis of non-linear differential equation models with application to a gut microbial ecosystem}},
  booktitle = {Biometrical},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1002/bimj.201000250},
}
Figure