TL;DR
This paper introduces BatNet, a novel system for transmitting data between smartphones using ultrasound, enabling communication even when traditional wireless networks are jammed. BatNet achieves over 600 bit/s at up to 6 meters using phase-shift keying, offering a potential fallback for censorship-resistant mesh networks.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
In an era of increasing reliance on wireless communication, the vulnerability of these networks to jamming, whether for political protest or natural disasters, poses a significant challenge. Traditional methods like Wi-Fi and cellular can be easily disrupted. This paper explores the use of ultrasound, a less conventional and harder-to-jam medium, as a resilient communication channel between everyday smartphones. The goal is to provide a fallback communication method that leverages existing hardware, making it accessible and practical for situations where conventional networks fail.
Methods
BatNet utilizes the built-in speakers and microphones of smartphones to transmit data via ultrasound. The core of the system is a phase-shift keying (PSK) modulation scheme with an 8-point constellation, operating in the near-ultrasound range of 20-24 kHz. This allows for encoding three bits per symbol. The system includes a signal generator for transmitting the modulated data and a signal processor for demodulating and decoding the received ultrasound signals. Key to its operation is a preamble for synchronization and error correction mechanisms, specifically a cyclic redundancy check (CRC), to mitigate transmission errors. The receiver implementation involves correlating the incoming signal with a reference signal, filtering out high frequencies, and then identifying symbols.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation was performed using four specific smartphone models (Samsung Ace 3, LG/Google Nexus 4, LG/Google Nexus 5, and Nokia 5.1) in various real-world scenarios.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Ultrasound as a Viable Fallback: The research demonstrates that standard smartphone speakers and microphones can effectively transmit and receive data using ultrasound, offering a practical alternative to vulnerable radio-based networks.
- Jamming Resistance Trade-offs: While ultrasound can be jammed, doing so over a large area requires significant infrastructure (large loudspeakers) and poses health risks, making it a less attractive option for authorities compared to jamming radio frequencies.
- Doppler Shift Challenge: The inherent movement of smartphones (in hands or pockets) introduces significant Doppler shifts, which are a major challenge for ultrasound communication. BatNet addresses this through carrier phase correction and careful signal processing.
- Directionality Matters: The transmission quality of BatNet is highly dependent on the orientation of the devices, with signals carrying best when the speaker is directly facing the microphone.
- Limited Utility for Contact Tracing: Despite the potential of ultrasound, the paper concludes it offers no significant advantage over Bluetooth Low Energy (BLE) for COVID contact tracing due to range limitations and orientation dependency.
Key Results
- Data Rate: BatNet can achieve a raw throughput of over 600 bit/s, with some configurations reaching up to 900 bit/s.
- Transmission Range: The system can reliably transmit data up to 6-8 meters when the speaker is facing the receiver. In other directions, the range is significantly reduced, potentially to less than 1 meter.
- Transmission Quality: For static devices, transmission quality remains high at symbol lengths above 96 samples. For moving devices, a symbol length of 160 samples is recommended, yielding a raw throughput of 900 bit/s.
- Battery Consumption: BatNet increases battery usage, consuming approximately 1W on a Nexus 5, comparable to classic Bluetooth.
- Comparison to Similar Products: BatNet outperforms Google Nearby in terms of bandwidth and range, and is comparable to Lisnr.
Limitations and Future Work
- Range and Orientation Dependency: The limited range and strong dependence on device orientation are significant limitations, especially for applications requiring broad coverage or less precise alignment.
- Movement Sensitivity: While addressed, rapid device movement can still lead to lost messages. Future work could involve using phone sensors to detect stillness for improved reliability.
- iPhone Compatibility: The paper notes potential issues with iPhones due to API restrictions, suggesting further investigation is needed.
- Noise Sensitivity: While ultrasound is less affected by ambient noise than audible sound, noisy environments can still impact reliability.
- Future Work: The authors suggest exploring optimizations for battery life, investigating the impact of police helicopters on jamming, and further refining error correction and synchronization mechanisms. They also propose exploring BatNet's viability in complex multi-channel tracing apps as a secondary mechanism.
Summary updated