Base Station Antenna Uptilt Optimization for Cellular-Connected Drone Corridors

Sung Joon Maeng, Md Moin Uddin Chowdhury, Ismail Güvenç, Arupjyoti Bhuyan, Huaiyu DaiIEEE Trans. Aerosp. Electron. Syst 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of providing reliable cellular connectivity for drones flying in designated corridors. By optimizing the "uptilt" angle of cellular base station antennas, the authors demonstrate a method to minimize signal disruptions and improve overall drone communication quality, crucial for safe and efficient drone operations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As drones become increasingly prevalent for various applications like delivery and public safety, ensuring their reliable connectivity, especially for Beyond Visual Line of Sight (BVLOS) operations, is paramount. Cellular networks, with their widespread infrastructure, offer a promising solution for this. However, existing cellular base station (BS) antennas are typically "down-tilted" to optimize coverage for ground users. This configuration creates "coverage holes" in the airspace, making it difficult for drones flying in designated corridors to maintain a stable connection. This paper addresses this gap by proposing and analyzing a method to reconfigure BS antennas – specifically, by adding an "uptilt" to optimize their beams for aerial users within drone corridors.

Methods

The authors model a 2D drone corridor scenario with two adjacent cellular base stations. They introduce an additional set of uptilted antennas at these BSs and focus on optimizing the "uptilt angle" (denoted by $\alpha$) to minimize the Signal-to-Interference-plus-Noise Ratio (SINR) outage probability for drones.

Key methodological contributions include:

  • Rectangular Beampattern Model: A simplified yet effective model for directional antenna patterns is adopted, characterized by an uptilt angle ($\alpha$) and beamwidth ($\beta$). This model allows for tractable mathematical analysis.
  • Case-Based Analysis: The drone corridor is divided into three regions: "beam served region without interference" (S), "interference region" (I), and "beam outage region" (O). The paper analyzes five distinct scenarios based on how these regions are formed as the uptilt angle $\alpha$ increases, demonstrating that the optimal strategy is case-dependent.
  • Closed-Form Expressions: The authors derive closed-form expressions for both the SINR outage probability and the average SINR. This is a significant contribution, enabling direct analysis and optimization without relying solely on simulations.
  • Optimization Strategy: By analyzing the derived SINR outage probability, which is shown to be a convex function of the uptilt angle, the paper proposes finding the optimal uptilt angle that minimizes this probability.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation relies on simulated data generated based on the system model and parameters provided in Table I.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Antenna Reconfiguration is Key: The fundamental insight is that existing cellular infrastructure can be adapted for drone connectivity by adjusting antenna tilt angles, rather than requiring entirely new infrastructure.
  • Uptilt Angle is Crucial: The "uptilt" angle of the BS antennas is a critical parameter that directly impacts coverage quality for drones. There's an optimal uptilt angle that balances serving drones while managing interference.
  • Case-Dependent Optimization: The effectiveness of the uptilt strategy is not uniform; it depends on the relative heights of the drone corridor and the BS antenna beam characteristics (beamwidth and uptilt). This necessitates a case-by-case analysis.
  • Trade-off Between Outage and Average SINR: Wider beamwidths are beneficial for reducing outage probability, but narrower beamwidths are preferred for maximizing average SINR. This highlights a design trade-off.
  • Drone Corridor Height Matters: A lower maximum drone corridor height generally leads to better performance for both outage probability and average SINR.

Key Results

  • The paper successfully derives closed-form expressions for SINR outage probability and average SINR, validated against Monte Carlo simulations.
  • It is shown that the SINR outage probability is a convex function of the uptilt angle, allowing for efficient optimization to find the global minimum.
  • The optimal uptilt angle that minimizes outage probability varies based on beamwidth and the maximum drone corridor height.
  • Performance (both reduced outage and increased average SINR) improves with wider beamwidths and lower maximum drone corridor heights.
  • The study identifies specific uptilt angle ranges that lead to optimal coverage scenarios, particularly highlighting "Case 5" where the entire drone corridor is within the main beam of the serving BS.

Limitations and Future Work

  • 2D Simplification: The current analysis is limited to a 2D coordinate system. The authors acknowledge that extending this to a 3D drone corridor design is a crucial next step.
  • Uniform Drone Distribution: The assumption of uniformly distributed UAVs within the corridor might not reflect real-world traffic patterns.
  • Free-Space Pathloss: The analysis uses a free-space pathloss model, which may not fully capture the complexities of urban or varied environments.

Future work could involve extending the analysis to 3D, incorporating more realistic environmental models, and considering non-uniform drone distributions and mobility patterns.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{maeng2023base,
  author = {Sung Joon Maeng and Md Moin Uddin Chowdhury and Ismail Güvenç and Arupjyoti Bhuyan and Huaiyu Dai},
  title = {{Base Station Antenna Uptilt Optimization for Cellular-Connected Drone Corridors}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Aerosp. Electron. Syst.},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1109/taes.2023.3237994},
}
Figure