Barycentric Interpolators for Continuous Space and Time Reinforcement Learning

Rémi Munos, Andrew W. MooreNeurIPS 1998 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper provides a rigorous theoretical foundation for Reinforcement Learning (RL) in continuous space and time. By using "barycentric interpolators"—a class of function approximators that includes piecewise linear and multi-linear functions—the authors prove that RL algorithms can converge to the true optimal value function, even when the underlying dynamics and rewards are learned through imperfect, noisy models.

The Discretization Gap in Continuous RL

In classical RL, we often deal with discrete states and actions. However, the real world is continuous. To solve continuous-time and continuous-space control problems, researchers typically use the Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman (HJB) equation. The challenge lies in the "discretization gap": how do we approximate the continuous value function (VF) using a finite set of points without losing the guarantee that our solution will actually converge to the true optimum?

Previous methods often struggled with stability or lacked formal convergence proofs when function approximation was introduced. Munos and Moore tackle this by identifying a specific class of "averager" functions that maintain the geometric properties necessary to ensure the RL agent eventually finds the best possible control strategy.

Methods: Barycentric Interpolators

The authors introduce Barycentric Interpolators as the primary tool for Value Function approximation.

State dynamics and simplex interpolation in continuous space
  1. Barycentric Coordinates: For any state $x$ within a simplex (e.g., a triangle in 2D, a tetrahedron in 3D), the value $V(x)$ is defined as a weighted average of the values at the vertices.
  2. Discretizing the HJB: The authors transform the continuous HJB differential equation into a discrete Dynamic Programming (DP) update rule.
  3. Model-Based Learning: Unlike some RL methods that require a perfect simulator, this approach allows for an approximate model of state dynamics ($f$) and reinforcements ($r$).
  4. The "Weak Contraction" Proof: Standard RL convergence proofs rely on "strong contraction" (the error shrinks at every step). Because the authors allow for approximate, evolving models, they utilize a "weak contraction" property to prove that the system still settles into the optimal solution as the grid resolution increases and the model improves.

Key Insights and Ideas

Variable resolution grids using simplices and hyperrectangles
  • Continuity is Optional: Surprisingly, the approximation function itself does not need to be continuous to guarantee convergence to the (usually continuous) optimal value function. This allows for "variable resolution" grids where some areas are more detailed than others, which is much more computationally efficient.
  • The Power of Averagers: Because barycentric interpolators are "averagers" (the weights sum to 1 and are non-negative), they prevent the value function from "exploding" during the learning process—a common failure mode in other types of function approximation (like polynomial regression).
  • Tolerance for Imperfection: The paper demonstrates that the learned model of the environment doesn't have to be perfect. As long as the error in the dynamics is small relative to the grid resolution ($O(\delta^2)$), the algorithm remains stable and convergent.

Key Results

  • Convergence Guarantee: The central result is a formal proof that the approximated value function $V_n^\delta$ converges uniformly to the true optimal value function $V$ as the number of iterations $n$ goes to infinity and the discretization resolution $\delta$ goes to zero.
  • Computational Efficiency: The authors note that linear interpolation within a simplex can be computed in $O(d \log d)$ time (where $d$ is the dimension of the state space). This is significantly faster than multi-linear interpolation, which scales exponentially ($2^d$).
  • Consistency: They prove that their discretization scheme is "consistent" with the HJB equation, meaning that as the grid becomes infinitely fine, the discrete math perfectly matches the continuous physics.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Rate of Convergence: While the paper proves the algorithm will converge, it does not specify how fast it will do so. Determining the error bounds for a specific number of samples remains an open question.
  • Deterministic Focus: The proofs in this paper primarily target deterministic systems. The authors mention that extending this framework to stochastic (random) environments is a key direction for future research.
  • Curse of Dimensionality: Although simplex-based interpolation is faster than grid-based methods, any method relying on a discretization of the state space still faces challenges as the number of dimensions increases.

Summary updated

Abstract

In order to find the optimal control of continuous state-space and time reinforcement learning (RL) problems, we approximate the value function (VF) with a particular class of functions called the barycentric interpolators. We establish sufficient conditions under which a RL algorithm converges to the optimal VF, even when we use approximate models of the state dynamics and the reinforce(cid:173) ment functions .
BibTeX
@inproceedings{munos1998barycentric,
  author = {Rémi Munos and Andrew W. Moore},
  title = {{Barycentric Interpolators for Continuous Space and Time Reinforcement Learning}},
  booktitle = {Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems},
  year = {1998},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=r1bAKdbuWH},
}
Figure