Baroclinic generation of potential vorticity in an embedded planet-disk system

Jianghui Ji, Shangli Ou, Lin LiuProceedings of the International Astronomical Union 2007 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how planets embedded in protoplanetary disks generate "potential vorticity" (PV), a key ingredient for disk turbulence and planet formation. They find that non-barotropic (locally isothermal) disks are much more efficient at generating PV through "baroclinic instability," especially near the planet. This enhanced PV can lead to the formation of density structures that influence planet migration and potentially aid in the formation of smaller, Earth-like planets.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The standard model for planet formation suggests that giant planets (like "hot Jupiters") must migrate inward to reach their observed close-in orbits. This inward migration is driven by gravitational interactions with the protoplanetary disk. However, the exact mechanisms that drive this migration and the resulting disk dynamics are complex. Specifically, the paper addresses how instabilities within the disk, particularly those related to the generation of potential vorticity (PV), influence planet migration and disk structure. Previous work has shown that non-axisymmetric Rossby-Wave Instabilities (RWIs) can arise in disks with uniform PV, leading to density blobs that exert fluctuating torques on the planet. This paper focuses on the generation of PV itself, particularly through baroclinic instability in non-barotropic disks, and how this initial PV generation then fuels RWIs and impacts planet-disk interactions.

Methods

The authors employ a multi-dimensional hydrodynamics code to simulate the gravitational interaction between an embedded planet and a protoplanetary disk. They use a vertically integrated, 2D approach, which is justified by the disk thickness being comparable to or smaller than the planet's Hill radius. The fluid motion is described by continuity and Navier-Stokes equations, with a locally isothermal equation of state (EOS) for the disk, making it non-barotropic. This contrasts with simpler barotropic (globally isothermal) models. They implement a legacy hydrodynamics code with features like Van Leer upwind schemes and artificial viscosity. The planet is either fixed in orbit or allowed to move to study migration effects. Simulations are performed with varying resolutions to check for convergence.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on numerical simulations rather than observational datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Baroclinic Instability is a Potent PV Generator: The paper strongly emphasizes that baroclinic instability is a highly effective mechanism for generating potential vorticity (PV) in non-barotropic disks, particularly in the co-orbital region around the planet. This is a key finding, suggesting that the "locally isothermal" nature of disks is crucial for this process.
  • Non-Barotropic Disks Fuel RWIs: The enhanced PV generated in non-barotropic disks provides the necessary conditions for the development of non-axisymmetric Rossby-Wave Instabilities (RWIs). This links the initial PV generation mechanism to the previously studied RWI phenomenon.
  • PV Generation Influences Disk Structure: The generation of PV and subsequent RWIs lead to the formation of non-axisymmetric density blobs and structures within the disk. These structures are not just passive byproducts but actively influence the planet.
  • Torque Oscillations and Non-Monotonic Migration: The density blobs, driven by RWIs, exert stronger, fluctuating torques on the planet as they pass by. This results in large amplitude oscillations in the total torque and a non-monotonic behavior in the planet's migration speed, even if the overall migration trend remains inward.
  • Potential for Earth-like Planet Formation: The paper speculates that the structures formed by RWIs could aid in the rapid formation of new planet cores, potentially leading to the creation of Earth-like planets in habitable zones or "hot Earths" closer to the star.

Key Results

  • PV generation is shown to be "very common and effective" in non-barotropic disks, especially within the co-orbital region.
  • The PV peaks in non-barotropic disks are significantly higher than in barotropic disks.
  • RWIs are observed to develop at local minima of PV, leading to non-axisymmetric density blobs.
  • These density blobs cause large amplitude oscillations in the total torque exerted on the planet.
  • While RWIs do not alter the overall inward migration trend, they introduce a non-monotonic behavior to the migration speed.
  • The simulations show the formation of interesting disk structures that could be relevant for planet formation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • 2D Simplification: The study is conducted in 2D, which simplifies the problem but neglects the vertical structure of the disk. The authors acknowledge that full 3D simulations are needed for a more complete picture.
  • Non-Self-Gravitating Systems: The simulations do not include the self-gravity of the fluid, which could be important in certain disk regimes.
  • Realistic Conditions: The authors note that realistic protoplanetary disks are more complex than the models used, and further investigations are needed to understand the interplay of temperature variations, disk self-gravity, and full 3D dynamics.
  • Future Work: The authors plan to conduct further investigations with full 3D simulations and disk self-gravity. They also intend to perform a detailed analysis of fluid dynamics and PV mixture around a Neptune-mass planet in a non-barotropic disk in a separate study.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract We use a multi-dimensional hydrodynamics code to study the gravitational interaction between an embedded planet and a protoplanetary disk with emphasis on the generation of vortensity (Potential Vorticity or PV) through a Baroclinic Instability. We show that the generation of PV is very common and effective in non-barotropic disks through the Baroclinic Instability, especially within the coorbital region. Our results also complement previous work that non-axisymmetric Rossby-Wave Instabilities (RWIs) are likely to develop at local minima of PV distribution that are generated by the interaction between a planet and an inviscid barotropic disk. The development of RWIs results in non-axisymmetric density blobs, which exert stronger torques onto the planet when they move to the vicinity of the planet. Hence, large amplitude oscillations are introduced to the time behavior of the total torque acted on the planet by the disk. In current simulations, RWIs do not change the overall picture of inward orbital migration but cause a non-monotonic behavior to the migration speed. As a side effect, RWIs also introduce interesting structures into the disk. These structures may help the formation of Earth-like planets in the Habitable Zone or Hot Earths interior to a close-in giant planet.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ji2007baroclinic,
  author = {Jianghui Ji and Shangli Ou and Lin Liu},
  title = {{Baroclinic generation of potential vorticity in an embedded planet-disk system}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the International Astronomical Union},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1017/s1743921308016918},
}
Figure