Bacterial Water Quality in Personal Reusable Water Bottles of Undergraduate Medical Students at a Malaysian University

Eric Wong, C Lee, Chan Yu, Zi Shan Ooi, Hien Fuh Ng, Victoria Wong, Kang Wh, Hooi Tin OngJournal of Environmental Health 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Even medical students—who arguably know the most about hygiene—are carrying around "microbial reservoirs." A study at a Malaysian university found that 78% of students' reusable water bottles exceeded safe bacterial limits, with nearly half testing positive for coliform bacteria, largely driven by bottle design and material choices.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While reusable water bottles are a win for sustainability, they present a hidden public health challenge: biofilm formation and bacterial proliferation. If not cleaned properly, these bottles can become vehicles for waterborne illnesses.

The authors identified a specific gap in the literature regarding "health-literate" populations. They hypothesized that medical students, given their clinical training, would maintain higher hygiene standards. By investigating the bacterial load in these bottles and correlating it with cleaning habits and bottle design, the researchers aimed to identify which factors most significantly contribute to poor water quality.

Methods

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional study involving 37 undergraduate medical students at Universiti Tunku Abdul Rahman (UTAR). The methodology combined qualitative survey data with quantitative laboratory analysis:

  • Surveying: Participants completed a digital questionnaire covering demographics, bottle material, cleaning frequency, and "bottleneck design" (defined operationally as a neck too narrow for a hand to fit inside for cleaning).
  • Heterotrophic Plate Count (HPC): This standard method measures a broad range of bacteria. 100 µl of water was plated onto agar and incubated to count colony-forming units (CFU/ml).
  • Coliform Screening: To detect potential fecal contamination, 100 ml of water was filtered, and the membrane was cultured on MacConkey agar.
  • Statistical Analysis: The team used Fisher’s exact test to find associations with coliform presence and non-parametric tests (Mann–Whitney U and Kruskal–Wallis) to analyze differences in median HPC levels.

Datasets

The primary "dataset" consists of 37 water samples and corresponding survey responses from the MBBS (Bachelor of Medicine, Bachelor of Surgery) student population. While the sample size is small (17% of the eligible population), the results were compared against established international benchmarks:

  • WHO Limit: Safe drinking water should have an HPC of $\leq$ 100 CFU/ml.
  • CDC/WHO Limit: Safe drinking water should have zero coliforms per 100 ml.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Awareness Gap: Perhaps the most striking finding was that while 95% of participants were aware that bottles could harbor microbes, 78% were still drinking water that failed safety standards. Awareness does not automatically translate to effective hygiene.
  • Design as a Risk Factor: The "bottleneck" effect was significant. Bottles with narrow openings had an Odds Ratio (OR) of 13.09 for coliform detection. If you can't get a brush or hand inside to scrub the internal surfaces, biofilms persist regardless of how often you rinse.
  • Material Science Matters: There was a statistically significant difference ($p = .046$) between materials. Stainless steel bottles had a median HPC of just 40 CFU/ml (within safe limits), while plastic bottles averaged 4,000 CFU/ml. The authors suggest this might be due to stainless steel users being more likely to use hot water, which naturally lowers bacterial counts.
  • The "Clean" Illusion: Many students reported cleaning their bottles "daily" or "within the last week," yet their bottles still showed high contamination. This suggests that the method of cleaning (e.g., rinsing with water only vs. scrubbing with soap and a brush) is more critical than the frequency.

Key Results

  • Contamination Rates: 46% of samples were coliform-positive, and 78% exceeded the HPC limit of 100 CFU/ml.
  • Bacterial Load: The median HPC across all samples was 3,100 CFU/ml—31 times higher than the WHO safety limit. The highest recorded count was a staggering 167,100 CFU/ml.
  • Statistical Significance: Bottleneck design was the only independent variable with a significant association with coliform detection ($p = .010$).
  • Material Comparison: Plastic bottles showed a median HPC 100 times higher than stainless steel bottles (4,000 vs. 40 CFU/ml).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several constraints:

  • Sample Size: With only 37 participants, the study may lack the power to generalize across all university students.
  • Bias: Self-reported cleaning habits are subject to "social desirability bias," where students might over-report hygiene to avoid looking "unclean" to researchers.
  • Detection Interference: High HPC levels can actually mask the detection of coliforms on certain media, meaning the 46% coliform rate might actually be an undercount.

Future Work: The researchers suggest follow-up studies to measure the effectiveness of targeted hygiene interventions (like the health promotion campaign they launched post-study) and investigating the specific types of pathogenic bacteria present beyond general coliforms.

Summary updated

Abstract

Reusable water bottles are popular nowadays due to the conveniences that they bring. Poor bacterial water quality in these bottles, however, can present risks to consumer health, as the drinking water can become a vehicle for waterborne illnesses. In this study, we aimed to investigate the bacterial water quality and its associated factors in the personal reusable bottles of medical students at our university. A survey, heterotrophic plate count (HPC), and coliform screening were used in this study. Among the 37 water samples, 46% were coliform-positive and 78% had a high HPC of >100 CFU/ml. These results are surprising considering that medical students should generally have a high level of health awareness. In addition, both bottleneck design and bottle material appeared to contribute to poor bacterial water quality, which should warrant further investigation.
BibTeX
@article{wong2025bacterial,
  author = {Eric Wong and C Lee and Chan Yu and Zi Shan Ooi and Hien Fuh Ng and Victoria Wong and Kang Wh and Hooi Tin Ong},
  title = {{Bacterial Water Quality in Personal Reusable Water Bottles of Undergraduate Medical Students at a Malaysian University}},
  journal = {Journal of Environmental Health},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.70387/001c.145236},
}
Figure