Ba Isotope Study on Arc Lavas and Mantle Peridotites with the Application of 1013 ohm Resistor

Fei Wu, Bruce F. Schaefer, Olivier Alard, Simon TurnerGoldschmidt 2020 · DOI

Here is a summary of the conference abstract.

TL;DR

Barium (Ba) isotopes are excellent tracers for tracking how Earth's crust is recycled into the mantle, but measuring them in depleted mantle rocks is incredibly difficult due to parts-per-billion concentrations. This study leverages state-of-the-art $10^{13}$ ohm resistors in mass spectrometry to achieve high-precision measurements from tiny (<10 ng) samples. This hardware leap allows researchers to accurately constrain the mantle's baseline isotopic composition and track subduction processes in island arcs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Barium is a "large ion lithophile element" that tends to concentrate in Earth's crust and marine sediments rather than the mantle. Because Ba isotopes fractionate (separate based on mass) at low temperatures near the Earth's surface, they act as a chemical fingerprint. When oceanic crust and sediments are shoved back into the Earth's interior at subduction zones, Ba isotopes can trace this recycling process.

However, to build accurate models of this recycling, geochemists need to know the starting baseline: the Ba isotopic composition of the mantle itself. The problem is that depleted mantle rocks (peridotites) have extremely low Ba concentrations—down to the parts-per-billion (ppb) level. Traditional mass spectrometry struggles to measure such tiny amounts accurately because the faint signal gets drowned out by the instrument's baseline electronic noise (Johnson noise).

Methods

To overcome the low-signal problem, the researchers utilized Thermal Ionization Mass Spectrometry (TIMS) (specifically, a Thermo Fisher Triton Plus) equipped with a crucial hardware upgrade: $10^{13}$ ohm resistors.

Standard TIMS setups typically use $10^{11}$ ohm resistors in their Faraday cup amplifiers. By upgrading to $10^{13}$ ohm resistors, the researchers achieved a tenfold improvement in the signal-to-Johnson-noise ratio. This allows the instrument to accurately read extremely low ion beam intensities without the data being corrupted by background electronic noise.

Datasets

While not a traditional machine learning dataset, the study relies on two primary sets of geological samples:

  • Tonga-Kermadec Arc Lavas: Samples from a well-known subduction zone to evaluate the transport of crustal components into magma.
  • Global Fresh Mantle Peridotites: A suite of mantle rocks with varying degrees of melt extraction, used to establish the baseline mantle reservoir composition.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hardware upgrades unlock new geochemistry: Simply swapping the amplifier resistors in the mass spectrometer drastically lowers the noise floor. This turns previously unmeasurable, ultra-low-concentration samples (like depleted peridotites) into viable data sources.
  • Ba isotopes are highly sensitive subduction tracers: The isotopic variations observed in the island arc lavas confirm that Ba can effectively fingerprint the specific contributions of sediments and fluids coming off a subducting oceanic plate, helping us map the deep-earth recycling system.

Key Results

  • High Precision on Tiny Samples: Using the $10^{13}$ ohm resistors, the team achieved a remarkably good precision of ~0.08‰ (2SD) on extremely low beam intensities (~0.1 pA for $^{134}$Ba).
  • High Efficiency: The new method requires consuming less than 10 nanograms (ng) of Barium per analysis.
  • Tracing Subduction: In the Tonga-Kermadec arc lavas, they observed a remarkable along-strike variation in $\delta^{138/134}$Ba values ranging from -0.06 to 0.16‰ (with a long-term precision of 0.04‰). This variation directly reflects the varying contributions of fluids and sediments from the subducting slab.

Limitations and Future Work

As this is a short conference abstract, the authors do not explicitly detail the limitations of the study. However, they outline clear next steps for their future work: utilizing this newly acquired, high-precision data to definitively constrain the Ba isotopic composition of global mantle reservoirs and to better model the behavior of Ba isotopes during complex mantle processes like melt extraction.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2020ba,
  author = {Fei Wu and Bruce F. Schaefer and Olivier Alard and Simon Turner},
  title = {{Ba Isotope Study on Arc Lavas and Mantle Peridotites with the Application of 1013 ohm Resistor}},
  booktitle = {Goldschmidt},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.46427/gold2020.2890},
}
Figure