B-fields And dust in interstelLar fiLAments using Dust POLarization (BALLAD-POL): I. The massive filament G11.11-0.12 observed by SOFIA/HAWC+

Nguyen Bich Ngoc, Pham Ngoc Diep, Thiem Hoang, Le Ngoc Tram, Nguyen Chau Giang, Ngan Le, D. Hoang, Nguyễn Thị Phương, Dieu D. Nguyen, Nguyen Minh Khang, Bao TruongarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We report the first measurement of polarized thermal dust emission toward the entire early and massive Infrared Dark Cloud G11.11$-$0.12 taken by the polarimeter SOFIA/HAWC+ at 214 $μm$ wavelength. Magnetic fields (B-fields) obtained from the polarized emission tend to be perpendicular to the filament's spine. We produce a map of B-field strengths for the center region of the filament. The strengths vary in the range of 100-600 $μ\rm{G}$ and are strongest along the filament's spine. The central region is sub-Alfvénic and mostly sub-critical meaning that B-fields dominate over turbulence and are strong enough to resist gravitational collapse. The alignment and properties of dust grains are studied in the filament using the RAdiative Torque (RAT) theory. We find the decrease of polarization degree $P$ with emission intensity $I$, i.e., depolarization effect, of the form $P\propto I^{-α}$ with $α\sim$0.8-0.9, implying a significant loss of grain alignment in the filament's spine. The depolarization can be explained by the decrease in RAT alignment efficiency toward the denser regions with lower dust temperature, and cannot be explained by the B-field tangling. We study the effect of the enhanced magnetic relaxation by embedded iron inclusions on RAT alignment and find that the high polarization fraction $P\sim$20-30% in the outer layer of the filament is potential evidence for the enhanced RAT alignment by magnetic relaxation. This is the first time this effect is evaluated in a filament. Based on the polarization fraction and RAT alignment theory, we find evidence for grain growth in the filament.

Introduction

Stars emerge from dense, thread-like structures in the interstellar medium (ISM) known as filaments. A fundamental question in star formation is the relative importance of gravity, turbulence, and magnetic fields (B-fields) in governing the evolution of these structures. While gravity drives collapse and turbulence provides internal pressure, magnetic fields can either guide gas flow or provide structural support against collapse. Mapping these fields across entire massive filaments at high resolution is a significant technical challenge. This study presents the first full-scale magnetic field map of the massive "Snake" filament (G11.11−0.12), investigating both its structural dynamics and the underlying physics of dust grain alignment.

Methods and Observations

The research utilizes 214 μm polarimetric data from the SOFIA/HAWC+ instrument. This wavelength traces thermal emission from dust grains, which align their short axes with the local magnetic field. By rotating the observed polarization angles by 90°, the team inferred the magnetic field orientation.

To estimate B-field strengths, the team employed the Davis-Chandrasekhar-Fermi (DCF) method, which relates the dispersion in polarization angles to the gas velocity dispersion (measured via JCMT $^{13}$CO spectral lines). The study also applied RAdiative Torque (RAT) theory and its magnetically enhanced variant (MRAT) to model grain alignment, specifically testing the role of iron inclusions in enhancing magnetic relaxation.

Structural Dynamics and Magnetic Support

The observations reveal that magnetic fields are predominantly perpendicular to the filament's long axis, or "spine." This orientation suggests that the filament likely formed by gas contracting along magnetic field lines, which now provide a "stiff" backbone resisting further collapse.

SOFIA/HAWC+ 214 μm intensity map of the G11.11-0.12 filament overlaid with inferred magnetic field vectors (blue lines).

Analysis of the B-field strengths (ranging from 100 to 600 μG) shows that the region is sub-Alfvénic ($M_A < 1$) and sub-critical ($\lambda < 1$). This indicates that magnetic forces dominate over both turbulence and gravity, effectively supporting the filament against immediate gravitational collapse.

Spatial distribution of the angle difference $|\Delta\theta|$ between the magnetic field and the filament spine, highlighting the perpendicular orientation (red) along the spine.

Grain Physics and the "Polarization Hole"

A key finding is the sharp drop in polarization fraction ($P$) toward the dense, cold center of the filament, following a power-law relationship $P \propto I^{-0.8}$. This "polarization hole" is attributed to a loss of grain alignment efficiency. According to RAT theory, the lack of sufficient radiation in the dark interior prevents grains from spinning up and aligning with the B-field.

Conversely, the outer layers exhibit high polarization (20-30%). The authors propose this as evidence for MRAT, where iron inclusions in dust grains enhance their magnetic sensitivity, allowing for efficient alignment even under modest radiation fields. Furthermore, the data suggests that dust grains are significantly larger within the filament than in the surrounding ISM, providing evidence for grain growth in these dense environments.

Conclusions

This study provides a comprehensive view of the magnetic environment within a massive infrared dark cloud. The dominance of magnetic fields in G11.11−0.12 highlights their critical role in the early stages of high-mass star formation. As the first entry in the BALLAD-POL series, this work sets a benchmark for future multi-wavelength polarimetric studies of interstellar filaments.

Summary updated

Abstract

We report the first measurement of polarized thermal dust emission toward the entire early and massive Infrared Dark Cloud G11.11$-$0.12 taken by the polarimeter SOFIA/HAWC+ at 214 $μm$ wavelength. Magnetic fields (B-fields) obtained from the polarized emission tend to be perpendicular to the filament's spine. We produce a map of B-field strengths for the center region of the filament. The strengths vary in the range of 100-600 $μ\rm{G}$ and are strongest along the filament's spine. The central region is sub-Alfvénic and mostly sub-critical meaning that B-fields dominate over turbulence and are strong enough to resist gravitational collapse. The alignment and properties of dust grains are studied in the filament using the RAdiative Torque (RAT) theory. We find the decrease of polarization degree $P$ with emission intensity $I$, i.e., depolarization effect, of the form $P\propto I^{-α}$ with $α\sim$0.8-0.9, implying a significant loss of grain alignment in the filament's spine. The depolarization can be explained by the decrease in RAT alignment efficiency toward the denser regions with lower dust temperature, and cannot be explained by the B-field tangling. We study the effect of the enhanced magnetic relaxation by embedded iron inclusions on RAT alignment and find that the high polarization fraction $P\sim$20-30\% in the outer layer of the filament is potential evidence for the enhanced RAT alignment by magnetic relaxation. This is the first time this effect is evaluated in a filament. Based on the polarization fraction and RAT alignment theory, we find evidence for grain growth in the filament.
BibTeX
@misc{ngoc2023b,
  author = {Nguyen Bich Ngoc and Pham Ngoc Diep and Thiem Hoang and Le Ngoc Tram and Nguyen Chau Giang and Ngan Le and D. Hoang and Nguyễn Thị Phương and Dieu D. Nguyen and Nguyen Minh Khang and Bao Truong},
  title = {{B-fields And dust in interstelLar fiLAments using Dust POLarization (BALLAD-POL): I. The massive filament G11.11-0.12 observed by SOFIA/HAWC+}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2302.10543},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2302.10543},
}
Figure