Abstract
We survey observational constraints on the parameter space of inflation and axions and map out two allowed windows: the classic window and the inflationary anthropic window. The cosmology of the latter is particularly interesting; inflationary axion cosmology predicts the existence of isocurvature fluctuations in the cosmic microwave background, with an amplitude that grows with both the energy scale of inflation and the fraction of dark matter in axions. Statistical arguments favor a substantial value for the latter, and so current bounds on isocurvature fluctuations imply tight constraints on inflation. For example, an axion Peccei-Quinn scale of $10^{16}$ GeV excludes any inflation model with energy scale $> 3.8 \times 10^{14}$ GeV ($r > 2 \times 10^{-9}$) at 95% confidence, implying negligible gravitational waves from inflation but suggesting appreciable isocurvature fluctuations.
Introduction
Modern cosmology faces the challenge of reconciling two cornerstone theories: cosmic inflation and the existence of the QCD axion. Inflation provides a mechanism for the universe's large-scale uniformity and flatness, while the axion is a compelling candidate for dark matter and a solution to the strong CP problem in particle physics. In this study, Mark Hertzberg, Max Tegmark, and Nobel laureate Frank Wilczek demonstrate that these two theories are in significant tension when their respective energy scales are considered.
The primary conflict arises because axions are light scalar fields. During the inflationary epoch, they are subject to quantum fluctuations. If the Peccei-Quinn (PQ) symmetry, which gives rise to the axion, breaks before or during inflation, these fluctuations manifest as "isocurvature" perturbations—variations in the ratio of dark matter to radiation. Excessive isocurvature fluctuations are strictly constrained by observations of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB).
Methodology and Constraints
The study synthesizes theoretical models of axion production with a suite of observational datasets to map the allowed parameter space. Key data sources include:
- WMAP5: Provides upper limits on the tensor-to-scalar ratio ($r < 0.22$) and the isocurvature fraction ($\alpha_a < 0.072$).
- ADMX: Sets laboratory bounds on axion mass and coupling.
- Astrophysical Observations: Stellar cooling rates and data from Supernova 1987A exclude low values of the PQ scale ($f_a$).
The analysis identifies two primary "windows" for viable axion models:
- The Classic Window: The PQ symmetry breaks after inflation. Isocurvature fluctuations are naturally suppressed, but $f_a$ must remain within $10^{11}–10^{12}$ GeV to avoid overclosing the universe with dark matter.
- The Anthropic Window: The symmetry breaks before inflation. This allows for high $f_a$ values (e.g., $10^{16}$ GeV, as suggested by string theory), provided the initial misalignment angle is anthropically selected to be small.
Results: The Inflationary Ceiling
The most striking result is the "tight squeeze" on the energy scale of inflation ($E_I$) in the presence of high-scale axions. If axions constitute a significant fraction of dark matter, the non-detection of isocurvature fluctuations by WMAP5 forces $E_I$ to be remarkably low.
As shown in Figure 2, for a string-theory-motivated scale of $f_a \approx 10^{16}$ GeV, the energy scale of inflation is capped at $3.8 \times 10^{14}$ GeV. This low scale implies a tensor-to-scalar ratio $r \approx 2 \times 10^{-9}$, which is orders of magnitude below the sensitivity of planned primordial gravitational wave experiments. Consequently, the detection of B-mode polarization in the CMB would effectively rule out the high-scale axion scenario.
Conclusion
The interplay between axion dark matter and inflation creates a mutually exclusive landscape: one can have high-scale inflation with detectable gravitational waves, or high-scale axions consistent with string theory, but rarely both. This makes isocurvature fluctuations a uniquely sensitive probe of the early universe, potentially more informative than gravitational waves if the axion is indeed the dark matter particle. Future results from missions like Planck and advanced axion detectors will be critical in determining which of these windows describes our universe.
Summary updated