Awareness, Barriers and Concerns of Adolescents Toward the COVID-19 Vaccine: A Cross-Sectional Study in Singapore

Prawira Oka, Benecia Wan Qing Thia, Shyna Gunalan, Janae Rae Yann Kwan, Ding Xuan Ng, Wai Keong Aau, Juan Dee Wee, Ngiap Chuan TanFrontiers in Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

While Singaporean adolescents (ages 16–17) demonstrate high literacy regarding COVID-19 vaccines, significant psychological barriers remain. This study reveals that despite widespread awareness, concerns over rare side effects like anaphylaxis and uncertainty about long-term health impacts create a "hesitancy gap," with only 58% expressing willingness for repeated (booster) vaccinations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Public health strategies for COVID-19 initially prioritized adults, leaving a data gap regarding the perspectives of adolescents as they became eligible for vaccination. In a highly educated and digitally connected society like Singapore, one might assume high vaccine uptake is a given. However, medical decision-making in this age group is complex; adolescents are transitioning from parental-led care to personal autonomy.

The authors sought to understand the specific barriers, concerns, and information sources for this demographic to help policymakers tailor communication strategies. They specifically looked at why a "well-informed" population might still harbor significant apprehension about vaccine efficacy and safety.

Methods

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional online survey between June and November 2021.

  • Participants: 460 students from post-secondary institutions (Junior Colleges, Polytechnics, and Institutes of Technical Education) in Singapore.
  • Instrument: A self-developed questionnaire covering six domains: demographics, medical history (allergies), vaccine knowledge/attitude, specific concerns, factors influencing uptake, and willingness for boosters.
  • Platform: They utilized "FormSG," a secure government-developed survey tool, and recruited participants via convenience and snowball sampling through digital channels like WhatsApp and Telegram.
  • Analysis: Descriptive statistics were used to characterize the sample, and associations between demographics and vaccine attitudes were analyzed.

Datasets

The study relies on a primary dataset generated from the 460 survey respondents.

  • Demographics: The cohort had a mean age of 16.99 years, was predominantly female (73%), and mostly of Chinese ethnicity (90%).
  • Institutional Split: The vast majority (92.2%) were from Junior Colleges, which represents a specific academic track in the Singaporean education system.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Awareness-Apprehension Paradox: There is a stark disconnect between factual knowledge and emotional concern. While 98% of participants knew the vaccine wasn't 100% effective and 97.6% knew about minor side effects, they remained disproportionately worried about extremely rare outcomes. For instance, 73.2% were concerned about anaphylactic shock, despite its rarity.
  • Long-term Uncertainty as a Primary Barrier: The "unknown" is the biggest deterrent. Uncertainty about long-term health risks (38.6%) and vaccine efficacy (37.3%) outweighed immediate concerns like fear of needles (16.1%) or the inconvenience of the procedure.
  • Information Source Mismatch: Despite spending the majority of their time in educational settings, only about 25% of adolescents cited teachers or school briefings as their source of information. Instead, they relied heavily on family (80%) and mainstream media (78.2%). This suggests a missed opportunity for schools to act as primary hubs for health literacy.
  • Waning Enthusiasm for Boosters: Perhaps the most critical finding for long-term public health is that only 58% were willing to undergo repeated vaccinations. This suggests that "vaccine fatigue" or unresolved concerns from the primary series could hinder booster campaigns.

Key Results

  • High Awareness: 91.5% of participants were aware of the available COVID-19 vaccines.
  • Specific Side-Effect Fears: Beyond anaphylaxis (73.2%), participants were highly concerned about low blood pressure (58.3%) and tachycardia/fast heartbeat (58.0%).
  • Deterring Factors: The top three factors preventing vaccination were long-term health risks (178 respondents), vaccine efficacy concerns (172 respondents), and the belief that the vaccine is unnecessary (78 respondents).
  • Social Influence: Family remains the most influential circle for health information (80%), followed by mainstream media and social media (68.3%).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sampling Bias: The use of convenience sampling led to a cohort that was skewed toward females and those of Chinese ethnicity, which may not perfectly represent the entire Singaporean adolescent population.
  • Institutional Bias: Over 90% of respondents were from Junior Colleges, potentially overlooking the perspectives of students in more vocational or technical tracks (ITE/Polytechnics).
  • Temporal Snapshot: As a cross-sectional study, it captures a specific moment in 2021. Attitudes may have shifted as the pandemic evolved and more real-world safety data became available.

Future Work: The authors suggest that future interventions should move beyond general "awareness" and specifically target the fear of rare side effects. They advocate for involving adolescents more directly in the medical decision-making process and leveraging school platforms more effectively to provide nuanced, evidence-based reassurance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Despite high COVID-19 vaccine awareness, the adolescents were concerned about the potentially severe but rare side-effects. The study identified apprehension regarding vaccine efficacy and the potential long-term health impact as the main barriers to vaccination. Future studies should address these concerns to scale vaccination programs among adolescents.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{oka2022awareness,
  author = {Prawira Oka and Benecia Wan Qing Thia and Shyna Gunalan and Janae Rae Yann Kwan and Ding Xuan Ng and Wai Keong Aau and Juan Dee Wee and Ngiap Chuan Tan},
  title = {{Awareness, Barriers and Concerns of Adolescents Toward the COVID-19 Vaccine: A Cross-Sectional Study in Singapore}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpubh.2022.903152},
}
Figure