Avoiding Failure via Pre-Planned Responses and Time-Bounded Planning

AAAI 1997

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of autonomous systems operating in dynamic environments where unexpected situations can arise. They propose a hybrid approach that combines pre-computed responses with time-bounded online planning to prioritize avoiding catastrophic failure, even at the cost of achieving secondary goals. This method aims to balance the thoroughness of offline planning with the adaptability of online planning.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Autonomous systems, like robots or aircraft, need to operate reliably in environments that can change unpredictably. Ideally, we'd pre-plan every possible reaction to every conceivable situation. However, this is often impossible due to the sheer complexity and potential for novel events. When an unexpected situation occurs, the system needs to react quickly. Online planning can generate new responses, but it takes time. If this reaction time exceeds the system's "time to failure" (e.g., the time before an aircraft crashes), the system will fail regardless of the plan. This paper addresses the critical need to ensure system safety by avoiding failure, even when faced with unforeseen circumstances and strict time constraints. It seeks to find a balance between the completeness of pre-planned responses and the flexibility of online planning.

Methods

The authors propose a hybrid approach integrated into their Cooperative Intelligent Real-time Control Architecture (CIRCA). This architecture combines a planner, scheduler, and a real-time execution subsystem (RTS). Their key innovation is augmenting CIRCA with:

  • Pre-planned Responses Cache: A small, quickly accessible cache within the RTS stores pre-computed responses for critical situations.
  • Contingency Plan Storage: A Plan Dispatcher module can store additional, less immediately accessible plans.

When an unplanned-for situation arises, CIRCA first determines the "time to failure" (TTF).

  • If the TTF is "fast," CIRCA immediately executes a pre-planned response from the RTS cache.
  • If the TTF is "slow" or non-existent, CIRCA can afford to engage in online replanning. This replanning is time-bounded by the TTF, employing an "anytime" approach where it produces the best possible plan within the allotted time.

This strategy prioritizes avoiding failure by using fast, pre-computed responses for urgent threats and allowing more deliberative, but still time-constrained, online planning for less immediate issues.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The authors mention performing tests using a fully-automated aircraft simulator.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Failure Avoidance as Primary Goal: The paper strongly advocates for prioritizing the avoidance of catastrophic failure (like system destruction) over achieving secondary goals in dynamic, time-critical environments. This is a crucial shift in perspective for many planning systems.
  • The "Time to Failure" (TTF) as a Critical Metric: Accurately estimating the TTF is central to their strategy. It dictates whether a system can afford to replan or must resort to a pre-computed, guaranteed response.
  • Hybrid Planning is Essential: Neither purely offline nor purely online planning is sufficient. Offline planning provides guaranteed responses but lacks adaptability, while online planning is adaptable but can be too slow for critical situations. The combination offers the best of both worlds.
  • Anytime Planning for Time-Bounded Replanning: The use of anytime planning algorithms is key to ensuring that even when online replanning is necessary, it produces a useful plan within the strict time limits imposed by the TTF.

Key Results

The paper is an abstract and focuses on the proposed methodology rather than detailed quantitative results. The authors state that their approach is designed to:

  • Ensure guaranteed performance for critical responses by using cached plans.
  • Allow for adaptive planning in less time-critical situations.
  • Balance the trade-off between plan quality and response time.

They are performing tests using an aircraft simulator to evaluate their approach, where TTF is defined by the minimum time before the aircraft crashes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • TTF Estimation Accuracy: The effectiveness of the proposed method heavily relies on the accurate estimation of the "time to failure." The paper doesn't detail how this estimation is performed or its potential inaccuracies.
  • Exhaustive Offline Plans: While the hybrid approach reduces the need for completely exhaustive offline plans, the RTS cache still requires a set of pre-computed responses for fast TTF scenarios. The completeness and optimality of these cached plans are important considerations.
  • Future Work: The authors are actively testing their approach in a simulated aircraft environment. Further work would likely involve empirical validation of the TTF estimation, the performance of the anytime replanning within bounds, and the overall robustness of the hybrid strategy across a wider range of dynamic scenarios.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{1997avoiding,
  title = {{Avoiding Failure via Pre-Planned Responses and Time-Bounded Planning}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {1997},
}

Loading related content...

Figure