Abstract
Around 5% of anthropogenic radiative forcing (RF) is attributed to aviation $CO_2$ and non-$CO_2$ impacts. This paper quantifies aviation emissions and contrail climate forcing in the North Atlantic, one of the world’s busiest air traffic corridors, over 5 years. Between 2016 and 2019, growth in $CO_2$ (+3.13% per annum, p.a.) and nitrogen oxide emissions (+4.5% p.a.) outpaced increases in flight distance (+3.05% p.a.). Over the same period, the annual mean contrail cirrus net RF (204–280 mW m⁻²) showed significant interannual variability caused by variations in meteorology. Responses to COVID-19 caused significant reductions in flight distance travelled (-66%), $CO_2$ emissions (-71%), and the contrail net RF (-66%) compared to the prior one-year period. Around 12% of all flights in this region cause 80% of the annual contrail energy forcing, and the factors associated with strongly warming/cooling contrails include seasonal changes in meteorology and radiation, time of day, background cloud fields, and engine-specific non-volatile particulate matter (nvPM) emissions. Strongly warming contrails in this region are generally formed in wintertime, close to the tropopause, between 15:00 and 04:00 UTC, and above low-level clouds. The most strongly cooling contrails occur in the spring, in the upper troposphere, between 06:00 and 15:00 UTC, and without lower-level clouds. Uncertainty in the contrail cirrus net RF (216–238 mW m⁻²) arising from meteorology in 2019, is smaller than the interannual variability. The contrail RF estimates are most sensitive to the humidity fields, followed by nvPM emissions and aircraft mass assumptions. This longitudinal evaluation of aviation contrail impacts contributes a quantified understanding of inter-annual variability and informs strategies for contrail mitigation.
Introduction
While aviation’s $CO_2$ emissions are well-documented, its "non-$CO_2$" impacts—specifically contrails—remain a significant source of uncertainty in climate modeling. Contrails can evolve into cirrus clouds that either trap outgoing longwave radiation (warming) or reflect incoming solar radiation (cooling). Globally, contrail cirrus is estimated to be the largest single contributor to aviation's radiative forcing, yet its impact varies wildly based on local weather, time of day, and engine technology. This study provides a high-resolution, five-year audit of aviation's climate impact in the North Atlantic corridor, identifying the specific factors that turn routine flights into major climate heaters.
Methodology and Data
The researchers employed a sophisticated modeling chain to simulate 2.1 million individual flights traversing the Shanwick Oceanic Control Area between 2016 and 2021.
Modeling Framework
- Contrail Simulation: The Contrail Cirrus Prediction model (CoCiP) was used to track the full lifecycle of contrail segments from formation to sublimation.
- Aircraft Performance: Fuel burn and emissions were calculated using BADA (Base of Aircraft Data) Family 3 and 4 models.
- Meteorology: Data was sourced from ERA5 reanalysis. A novel humidity correction was applied to the ERA5 data, as standard weather models often underestimate the "ice supersaturation" required for contrails to persist. This was validated using in-situ moisture measurements from the IAGOS program.
- Emissions Modeling: The study utilized the ICAO engine databank to estimate non-volatile particulate matter (nvPM)—soot—which acts as the nucleus for contrail ice crystals.
Key Insights
The 80/20 Rule
A critical finding of the study is that a mere 12% of flights are responsible for 80% of the annual contrail energy forcing. This suggests that contrail mitigation does not require grounding entire fleets; rather, it requires surgical, tactical adjustments to a small subset of "big hitter" flights.
Meteorology vs. Traffic Volume
Between 2016 and 2019, flight distance grew steadily, but the net radiative forcing (RF) fluctuated significantly. This indicates that year-to-year changes in weather patterns, such as the position of the jet stream, are more influential on contrail climate impact than the volume of traffic itself. The COVID-19 pandemic provided a "natural experiment," showing that while a 66% reduction in flight distance occurred, the resulting 66% drop in net contrail RF was heavily modulated by the prevailing meteorology of that period.
Anatomy of Warming and Cooling Contrails
- Strongly Warming Contrails: Typically form in winter, near the tropopause, during late afternoon or night (15:00–04:00 UTC), and above existing low-level clouds which prevent the contrail from "seeing" the cool ocean surface.
- Strongly Cooling Contrails: Occur most frequently in the spring, in the upper troposphere, during daylight hours (06:00–15:00 UTC), and in the absence of lower-level clouds.
The Role of Soot (nvPM)
Flights powered by engines with higher nvPM emissions produce contrails with more, smaller ice crystals. These contrails tend to be more persistent and have a higher optical depth, significantly increasing their warming potential. This highlights engine technology as a key lever for climate mitigation.
Results and Sensitivity
The annual mean contrail net RF in the North Atlantic ranged from 204 to 280 mW m⁻². Sensitivity analysis revealed that these estimates are most sensitive to humidity fields, followed by nvPM emissions and aircraft mass assumptions. Prior to the pandemic, $CO_2$ emissions in the region grew by 3.13% per year, while $NO_x$ grew by 4.5%, both outpacing the growth in flight distance (+3.05%).
Limitations and Future Outlook
While the study provides a robust longitudinal evaluation, some limitations remain. The CoCiP model does not currently account for humidity exchange between the contrail and the background air, which could potentially reduce RF estimates by 10-20%. Additionally, while ERA5 is high-resolution, it may still struggle to capture fine-scale vertical structures of ice-supersaturated regions.
Future work is needed to develop decision-making frameworks for "tactical trajectory adjustments." These frameworks must balance the $CO_2$ penalty of flying longer or lower routes against the significant non-$CO_2$ benefit of avoiding high-impact contrail formation.
Summary updated