Available Simplified Semi-empirical Correlation to Predict Hollow Spray Cone Angle for Practical Pressure Swirl Atomizers with Viscous liquid

Lei Sun, Tian Deng, Yong Huang, Shaolin Wang, Zhilin Liu, Bin Chen, Xiao Wei, Xiang FengInternational Conference on Liquid Atomization and Spray Systems (ICLASS) 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Pressure swirl atomizers are critical components in engineering, agriculture, and medical fields. The spray cone angle is a primary parameter determining the spatial distribution of droplets. This study proposes a simplified semi-empirical correlation to predict the hollow spray cone angle, accounting for geometry, operating conditions, and liquid viscosity. Derived from rotational kinetic energy loss principles and validated through extensive experimentation, the correlation offers a practical tool for rapid engineering design with a prediction uncertainty within 15%.

Introduction

In applications ranging from jet engine fuel injection to medical aerosol delivery, the spray cone angle is a decisive factor in performance. While predicting this angle for low-viscosity fluids like water is relatively straightforward, viscous liquids present a significant challenge. Existing predictive tools often fall into two extremes: overly simplistic empirical correlations that lack versatility, or complex analytical models that are mathematically cumbersome for rapid design.

Researchers have addressed this gap by developing a "Goldilocks" solution: a simplified semi-empirical correlation. This model retains the physical essence of fluid dynamics—specifically the loss of rotational kinetic energy due to friction—while remaining accessible for practical engineering use.

Methodology and Physical Principles

The core of the new model is based on the principle that friction within the atomizer saps rotational kinetic energy. As the swirl chamber length ($L_s$) increases or the liquid viscosity rises, more energy is lost, resulting in a narrower spray cone.

Schematic of the pressure swirl atomizer geometry and internal parameters.

To simplify the complex physics-based equations, two primary assumptions were made:

  1. Geometric Simplification: Most practical atomizers utilize convergent duct angles ($\alpha$) near 90°. This allows energy loss in the convergent section to be treated as a linear addition to the swirl chamber losses.
  2. Liquid Sheet Thickness: For hollow cone sprays, the liquid sheet thickness within the discharge orifice is assumed to be approximately half the orifice diameter ($r_o$).

These assumptions allowed the researchers to reduce a complex boundary layer equation into a manageable form that accounts for geometry, injection pressure, and fluid viscosity through three scaling factors determined via regression analysis.

Experimental Validation

To validate the correlation, a custom experimental rig was constructed. It featured transparent plexiglass atomizers with varying swirl chamber lengths and used water-glycerol mixtures to test a wide range of viscosities (1.005 to 35.289 mPa·s).

High-speed imaging sequence showing the measurement of the spray cone angle (2θ).

Data was collected using high-speed cameras, capturing 500 successive images per test. These images were averaged to determine the "true" spray angle ($2\theta$) with high precision (uncertainty < ±0.4º). The experiments confirmed that while higher injection pressures increase the spray angle, increased viscosity and longer swirl chambers significantly reduce it.

Key Results and Benchmarking

The simplified correlation demonstrated superior accuracy, maintaining a prediction uncertainty within ±15% across all experimental cases. When compared to industry-standard models:

  • Giffen and Massey Model: Failed to account for geometric or pressure variations, often providing static, inaccurate predictions.
  • Rizk and Lefebvre Model: Showed significantly higher uncertainties, reaching approximately ±40%.

The new model successfully quantifies the dominant influence of swirl chamber length ($L_s$) on the final spray shape, a factor often overlooked in older correlations that focused primarily on the exit orifice.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The proposed correlation provides a robust and practical tool for engineers to quickly predict spray characteristics without sacrificing physical accuracy. However, its application is limited to regimes where a stable hollow cone spray is formed; extremely high-viscosity fluids or excessively long swirl chambers may cause the spray physics to break down. Future work may extend this methodology to predict other critical parameters, such as Sauter Mean Diameter (SMD), providing a comprehensive suite for atomizer design.

Summary updated

Abstract

Pressure swirl atomizers are widely utilized in engineering, agriculture and medical treatment. The spray cone angle is one of the most important parameters for pressure swirl atomizers. The spatial distribution of sprays and droplets is closely dependent on the spray cone angle. In our previous study, an improved semi-empirical correlation is derived based on the rotational kinetic energy loss caused by the friction to predict the viscous spray cone angles. However, this correlation is relatively complicated and not convenient for the quick prediction of the hollow spray cone angle. In order to achieve quick prediction of the hollow spray cone angle with acceptable prediction accuracy, a simplified semi-empirical correlation is proposed in the present study. This simplified semi-empirical correlation is obtained by simplifying our previous correlation based on proper assumptions. Further, this simplified semi-empirical correlation could accommodate the effects of geometrical parameters, operating conditions and liquid properties on the spray cone angle. Besides, a series of experiments with variations of geometrical parameters, operating conditions and liquid properties have been done to validate the simplified semi-empirical correlation. The hollow spray cone angles predicted by this simplified semi-empirical correlation agree well with the experimental results. The prediction uncertainties could be within 15% for all cases.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sun2021available,
  author = {Lei Sun and Tian Deng and Yong Huang and Shaolin Wang and Zhilin Liu and Bin Chen and Xiao Wei and Xiang Feng},
  title = {{Available Simplified Semi-empirical Correlation to Predict Hollow Spray Cone Angle for Practical Pressure Swirl Atomizers with Viscous liquid}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Liquid Atomization and Spray Systems (ICLASS)},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.2218/iclass.2021.5948},
}
Figure