Autonomous Tools for Attack Surface Reduction

Manimaran Govindarasu, Adam Hahn, Philip J. Hart, Aditya Ashok, Hye‐Kyung Kim, Gelli Ravikumar, Vivek Kumar, Pengyuan Wang, Bev Johnson, Paul Krukow, Jianzhe Liu, Adam Peterson2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents an autonomous cyberattack detection algorithm for Wide Area Monitoring Systems (WAMS) in power grids. It aims to reduce the attack surface by accurately distinguishing between physical faults and sophisticated cyberattacks, a critical task given the increasing threat landscape. The developed algorithm demonstrates high performance in detecting these events across various simulated and real-world scenarios.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern power grids are increasingly reliant on digital communication and control systems, expanding their "attack surface." This makes them vulnerable to sophisticated cyberattacks that can disrupt operations and compromise national security. Existing cybersecurity measures often struggle to keep pace with the evolving threat landscape and the dynamic nature of the infrastructure. Specifically, distinguishing between genuine physical faults (like short circuits) and malicious cyberattacks that mimic fault behavior (e.g., replay attacks) is a significant challenge. This paper addresses the need for an autonomous, accurate, and efficient system to detect and classify these events in real-time, thereby enhancing the resilience of the power grid.

Methods

The core of the proposed solution is an online cyberattack detection algorithm for synchrophasor data. Key techniques include:

  • Singular Value Decomposition (SVD): Used for dimensionality reduction of synchrophasor data, extracting key features and signatures.
  • Network Partitioning Analysis (e.g., Generalized Eigenvalue Perturbation - GEP): This physics-based approach helps in understanding the network structure and can be used to inform feature selection and algorithm training.
  • Data-Driven and Model-Based Training: The algorithm integrates both approaches for robust training, allowing for online adaptation and reducing reliance on extensive manual configuration.
  • Chebyshev's Inequality: Applied for anomaly detection, providing an adaptive confidence interval that adjusts to system behavior, unlike static thresholds. Two approaches are presented: an accumulative feature sample set (CI 1) and a fixed-size sliding window sample set (CI 2).
  • Feature Engineering (MVEE): Multidimensional Minimum Volume Enclosing Ellipsoid is used to extract features from PMU data within sliding windows.

The algorithm is designed to operate autonomously, minimizing interaction with the Energy Management System (EMS).

Datasets

  • Simulated Data: The primary datasets were generated using a physics-based model of the Kundur two-area, 4-machine power system and a reduced-order model of the Mini-WECC system within MATLAB/Simulink and PST (Power System Toolbox). These simulations included both physical events (faults, load changes) and various cyberattack scenarios (replay attacks, data integrity attacks).
  • Real-world Data: The algorithm was also tested using synchrophasor data from PNNL's testbed, which simulated the MinniWECC model.

The paper does not explicitly mention the creation of new benchmark datasets but rather utilizes simulated and existing testbed data for evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Adaptive Anomaly Detection is Crucial: Static thresholds are insufficient for dynamic power systems. Chebyshev's Inequality, with its adaptive confidence intervals, offers a more robust approach to anomaly detection, reducing false positives and negatives.
  • Distinguishing Faults from Cyberattacks is Hard: Sophisticated cyberattacks can mimic physical faults very closely, making detection challenging. The algorithm's ability to differentiate these is a key contribution.
  • Network Topology Matters: The performance of the algorithm is influenced by the physical characteristics of the power system, particularly the presence of long inter-area transmission lines, which can create dominant swing modes.
  • Data Volume is a Challenge: The sheer volume of PMU data necessitates efficient feature extraction and dimensionality reduction techniques like SVD.

Key Results

  • High True Positive Rates: The algorithm achieved high true positive rates (TPR) for both fault and cyberattack classification across various scenarios. For instance, with 11 PMUs and optimal parameters, TPRs for fault events reached up to 1.0, and for cyberattacks, up to 0.98.
  • Robustness to Compromised PMUs: The algorithm demonstrated satisfactory performance even when a significant number of PMUs were compromised (e.g., 10-15 out of 30-40 deployed).
  • Impact of System Conditions: Performance was notably better on systems with longer inter-area transmission lines. In scenarios with reduced transmission lines, more PMUs and historical events were needed for comparable performance.
  • Successful Integration: The prototype algorithm was successfully ported to Python and integrated into GE's commercial PhasorAnalytics platform, demonstrating its practical applicability.
  • Detection Time and Recall: CI-based approaches generally outperformed static thresholds in detection promptness and recall, especially for cyberattacks.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Performance Dependency on Network Topology: The paper acknowledges that the algorithm's performance can be weaker in systems lacking dominant inter-area transmission lines. Future work will focus on refining the algorithm to address this.
  • Need for Multiple Features: While the MVEE feature showed promise, the authors suggest that incorporating more features sensitive to cyberattacks would improve detection.
  • Further Validation: Future work includes exploring the impact of unmodeled components (like power system stabilizers) and validating the algorithm on even larger test systems with thousands of buses.
  • Adaptation to Transient Processes: While CI 2's ability to adapt to transient processes is beneficial for reducing alarms, it can lead to false negatives if the sample set is too small. Combining CI 1 and CI 2, or using multiple features, is suggested for better accuracy and adaptiveness.

Summary updated

Abstract

The electric power grid is a complex critical infrastructure that forms the lifeline of modern society, and its secure and reliable operation is of paramount importance to national security and economic well being. However, recent findings documented in authoritative sources indicate the threat of cyber-based attacks growing in numbers and sophistication. However, securing the grid against stealthy cyber attacks is a challenging task due to legacy nature of the infrastructure coupled with dynamic nature of threat landscape and ever growing sophistication of the adversaries. Additionally, the grid’s attack surface continues to grow with the increased dependence on digital communications and control that now extends to each consumer through smart meters and distributed energy resources. Unfortunately, this expansive surface increases the grid’s vulnerability and further exposes critical control systems in both substations and control centers. To respond to this emerging need, we had successfully assembled an interdisciplinary team with academic- industry partnership to successfully conduct research, development, evaluation, demonstration, and commercialization of attack surface reduction tools, whose goal is to significantly reduce the cyber attack surface in the North American power grid. Our proposed project was a synergistic collaborative effort leveraging the synergistic expertise of the team members across power systems, cyber security and CPS security, testbeds, field deployments and demonstration, and successful commercialization. The team consisted of leading experts from two major universities – Iowa State University, Washington State University – complemented by reputed researchers from two DOE national laboratories – Pacific Northwest National Lab, and Argonne National Lab, one major utility vendor GE Global Research, and one utility partner – Cedar Falls Utilities (CFU). The team members have proven track record of successful academic-industry collaboration in interdisciplinary R&D projects, and bring onboard some of the best state-of-the-art testbed resources, industry-grade SCADA/EMS/DMS environment for experimentation and field demonstration.
BibTeX
@misc{govindarasu2020autonomous,
  author = {Manimaran Govindarasu and Adam Hahn and Philip J. Hart and Aditya Ashok and Hye‐Kyung Kim and Gelli Ravikumar and Vivek Kumar and Pengyuan Wang and Bev Johnson and Paul Krukow and Jianzhe Liu and Adam Peterson},
  title = {{Autonomous Tools for Attack Surface Reduction}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.2172/1773387},
}
Figure