Automatic summarization of search engine hit lists

Dragomir R. Radev, Weiguo FanACL 2000

TL;DR

This paper introduces SNS, a system that automatically summarizes search engine results, helping users quickly grasp the essence of a large number of web pages. By integrating information retrieval with multi-document summarization, SNS aims to alleviate the information overload problem faced by web searchers, demonstrating that its summaries are both high-quality and improve user efficiency.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The internet's exponential growth has led to an overwhelming amount of information. Search engines, while powerful, often return hundreds or even thousands of results for a single query. Users, faced with this deluge, typically only examine a handful of the top results, missing potentially relevant information. This "information overload" problem makes it tedious and time-consuming for users to sift through numerous web pages to find what they need. The paper addresses the challenge of making these search results more digestible and actionable, enabling users to efficiently identify relevant information without having to read through every single document.

Methods

The core of the SNS system is its ability to process search engine results and generate concise summaries. The system operates in three modes:

  • Web Search Mode: Users enter a query, and SNS retrieves documents, allowing the user to select which ones to summarize.
  • Intranet Mode: Users can specify a collection of documents (not necessarily from the web) to be summarized.
  • Clustering Mode: SNS can cluster documents (either from search results or a standalone collection) and then generate summaries for each cluster.

The system's architecture involves:

  • MySearch: A personalized search engine that indexes URLs, parses HTML, stems keywords, removes stop words, and stores keyword frequency and position information. It supports weighted retrieval based on keyword location (Anchor, Title, Body), Boolean search, and Vector Space search (using a modified TF-IDF).
  • CIDR (Columbia Intelligent Document Relater): A clustering engine that groups documents into clusters, identifying "document centroids" which represent the most salient themes of a cluster.
  • MEAD: The multi-document summarization component. It employs a sentence extraction approach, scoring each sentence based on three factors:
  • Centroid Value (Cᵢ): The sum of the centroid values of words within the sentence.
  • Positional Value (Pᵢ): A score that favors sentences appearing earlier in a document.
  • First-Sentence Overlap (Fᵢ): The overlap between the current sentence and the first sentence of the document, represented as sentence vectors.

These scores are combined using weights (initially set to equal weights for all three parameters) to rank sentences, and the top-ranked sentences are selected to form the summary.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention specific datasets used for training the summarization or clustering models. However, for evaluation, they used three sets of documents on different topics:

  • S1: Global E-Commerce Framework (3 articles, 200k total length)
  • S2: Introduction to Data Mining (2 articles, 100k total length)
  • S3: Intelligent Agents and their application in Information retrieval (5 articles, 160k total length)

These sets were chosen to test the robustness of the summarization algorithms with varying document lengths and numbers of documents.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Information Overload" is Real: The paper strongly emphasizes that users often give up their search after examining only a small fraction of results, highlighting the critical need for tools that help manage this overload.
  • Summaries Improve Efficiency: The core idea is that providing summaries of search results significantly speeds up the process of identifying relevant information and judging the relevance of documents.
  • Multi-Document Summarization is Key: For search results, users are often interested in a topic that spans multiple documents. SNS's ability to create a cohesive summary from a cluster of related documents is a significant advantage.
  • Centroid-Based Summarization: The use of "document centroids" to identify salient themes within a cluster is a novel approach to guide the summarization process.
  • Task-Based Evaluation Matters: The paper advocates for extrinsic, task-based evaluations (like measuring reading speed and relevance judgment) to assess the true utility of summarization systems, rather than just intrinsic metrics.

Key Results

The task-based evaluation yielded promising results:

  • Speedup: Users experienced a significant speedup in reading time. For 10% summaries, the speedup over reading full articles was 6.87x, and for 20% summaries, it was 4.22x.
  • Readability: The generated summaries were rated as highly readable. The average readability score for 10% summaries was 7.92, and for 20% summaries, it was 8.42 (on a scale of 1-10).
  • Preference for Longer Summaries: The evaluation suggested that 20% summaries were generally favored over 10% summaries, achieving better readability scores. This indicates that while compression is important, users may benefit from slightly longer summaries to capture more nuance.
  • Document Length Influence: The summarizer seemed to favor longer documents, and the differences in readability scores between 10% and 20% summaries were more pronounced for longer documents.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and propose future directions:

  • Sentence Delimiting: The current system uses a basic sentence delimiting component, which they plan to improve by investigating more robust modules.
  • Anaphora Resolution: They aim to incorporate a limited form of anaphora resolution to improve summary coherence.
  • Personalization: Future work includes exploring techniques for personalized summaries, such as favoring sentences with query words or incorporating user interaction history and preferences.
  • Interaction Between Sentences: Investigating positive and negative reinforcement between sentences in a summary is a key area for future research, particularly for handling redundancy and ensuring logical flow.
  • Automatic Weight Learning: The current system uses empirically determined weights for combining scoring parameters. Future work will focus on automatically learning or deriving these weights from user profiles.
  • Availability: A demonstration version of SNS is available at the provided URL.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{radev2000automatic,
  author = {Dragomir R. Radev and Weiguo Fan},
  title = {{Automatic summarization of search engine hit lists}},
  booktitle = {Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2000},
}
Figure