Automatic intraluminal scanning with a steerable endoscopic optical coherence tomography catheter for gastroenterology applications

Oscar Caravaca-Mora, Philippe Zanne, Guiqiu Liao, Natalia Zulina, Lucile Héroin, Lucile Zorn, Michel de Mathelin, Benoît Rosa, Florent Nageotte, Michalina J. GoraJournal of Optical Microsystems 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a steerable endoscopic optical coherence tomography (OCT) catheter that can automatically scan large areas within the gastrointestinal tract. By integrating robotic control and a novel workspace model, the system significantly improves scanning accuracy and smoothness compared to manual or teleoperated methods, paving the way for more comprehensive and reliable endoscopic OCT imaging.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Optical Coherence Tomography (OCT) is a powerful tool for real-time optical biopsy, offering detailed cross-sectional imaging of tissues. However, endoscopic OCT probes typically have a limited field of view. In applications like gastrointestinal examinations, where large areas need to be surveyed, operators traditionally rely on manual scanning. This manual approach is prone to irregular patterns, potential missed lesions, and can be challenging to control precisely, especially during delicate procedures. The core problem this paper addresses is the need for a more accurate, consistent, and automated method to extend the scanning range of endoscopic OCT in the GI tract, allowing clinicians to focus on image interpretation rather than intricate probe manipulation.

Methods

The researchers developed a steerable OCT catheter with three degrees of freedom (DoF): bending, translation, and rotation. A key contribution is the creation of a geometrical model to define the catheter's accessible workspace. This model, adapted from robotic manipulator principles, allows for the estimation of the total volume the catheter can reach.

For experimental validation, they employed an electromagnetic (EM) tracker to precisely measure the catheter's tip position in real-time. They designed a specific reference trajectory simulating a sweep pattern for lesion detection. The performance of the automatic scanning system was then compared against two other modalities:

  1. Teleoperation: where a user controls the catheter remotely.
  2. Manual Scanning: using a conventional endoscope with a non-steerable OCT catheter.

To quantify performance, several metrics were used, including:

  • Spectral Arc Length (NSAL): A novel metric to measure the smoothness of motion, which is crucial for uniform OCT image acquisition and reconstruction.
  • Scanning area, spacing between trajectories, total translation, and time to complete the scan.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments involved scanning a printed target with known features to assess accuracy and reproducibility.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Steerable Catheter for Volumetric Workspace: The integration of bending as a third DoF, in addition to translation and rotation, significantly expands the accessible scanning volume compared to traditional OCT probes.
  • Workspace Modeling for Robotic Endoscopy: Adapting robotic workspace modeling techniques provides a robust framework for defining and predicting the capabilities of steerable endoscopic tools.
  • Spectral Arc Length for Motion Smoothness: This metric offers a more objective and reliable way to assess motion quality than subjective visual assessment, directly impacting the potential for high-quality OCT image reconstruction.
  • Automatic Scanning Outperforms Manual/Teleoperation: The automated system demonstrates superior accuracy, consistency, and speed, freeing up the clinician's attention.

Key Results

  • Workspace Volume: The experimentally validated scanning workspace of the steerable OCT catheter was estimated to be 255 cm³.
  • Automatic Scanning Performance:
    • Highest accuracy and smoothness of motion (NSAL of -3.18).
  • Largest covered area: 10.11 cm².
  • Most consistent spacing between sweeps: 1.54 mm (with a standard deviation of 0.57 mm).
  • Maximum translation: 27.99 mm.
  • Fastest completion time: 3.11 seconds per sweep.
  • Comparison: The automatic mode achieved a higher number of sweeps (15) compared to teleoperation (11) and manual (7), indicating a lower risk of missing smaller lesions. The manual mode, while having a tortuous pattern, showed good smoothness due to the operator's skill.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Flat Target: The experiments were conducted on a flat target with known features. Future work should involve testing on more complex and unknown tissue geometries.
  • Closed-Loop Control: For real-time adaptation to complex environments, incorporating closed-loop control based on OCT imaging feedback for probe repositioning is suggested.
  • Trade-offs in Scanning: Further research is needed to find an optimal balance between scanning smoothness, duration, and rotational speed for various applications.
  • Rotational Scanning: While functional, the circumferential scanning was noted as potentially not optimal, and future work could explore more efficient patterns.
  • Contact vs. Non-Contact: The paper highlights the importance of maintaining non-contact imaging for better control, but future work could explore strategies for controlled contact.

Summary updated

Abstract

SignificanceEndoscopic optical coherence tomography (OCT) enables real-time optical biopsy of human organs. Endoscopic probes require miniaturization of optics, which in turn limits field of view. When larger imaging areas are needed such as in the gastrointestinal tract, the operator must manually scan the probe over the tissue to extend the field of view, often resulting in an imperfect scanning pattern and increased risk of missing lesions. Automatic scanning has the potential to extend the field of view of OCT, allowing the user to focus on image interpretation during real-time observations.AimThis work proposes an automatic scanning using a steerable OCT catheter integrated with a robotized interventional flexible endoscope. The aim is to extend the field of view of a low-profile OCT probe while improving scanning accuracy and maintaining a stable endoscope’s position during minimally invasive treatment of colorectal lesions.ApproachA geometrical model of the steerable OCT catheter was developed for estimating the volume of the accessible workspace. Experimental validation was done using electromagnetic tracking of the catheter’s positions. An exemplary scanning path was then selected within the available workspace to evaluate motion performance with the robotized steerable OCT catheter. Automatic scanning is compared to a teleoperated one and a manual scanning with a nonrobotized flexible endoscope. Spectral arc length, scanning area, spacing between scan trajectories, and time are metrics used to quantify performance.ResultsThe available scanning workspace was experimentally estimated to be 255 cm3. The automatic scanning mode provided the highest accuracy and smoothness of motion with spectral arc length of −3.18, covered area of 10.11 cm2, 1.54 mm spacing between 15 sweep trajectories, maximum translation of 27.99 mm, and time to finish of 3.11s.ConclusionsAutomatic modality improved the accuracy of scanning within a large workspace. The robotic capability provided better control to the user to define spacing resolution of scanning patterns.
BibTeX
@article{caravacamora2023automatic,
  author = {Oscar Caravaca-Mora and Philippe Zanne and Guiqiu Liao and Natalia Zulina and Lucile Héroin and Lucile Zorn and Michel de Mathelin and Benoît Rosa and Florent Nageotte and Michalina J. Gora},
  title = {{Automatic intraluminal scanning with a steerable endoscopic optical coherence tomography catheter for gastroenterology applications}},
  journal = {Journal of Optical Microsystems},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1117/1.jom.3.1.011005},
}
Figure