AutoAI: Autonomous AI

Longbing CaoIEEE Intell. Syst 2022 · OpenReview

Abstract

In the ongoing evolution of artificial intelligence, a significant and lasting mission has been the design of truly autonomous systems (AutoAI). While often confused with automated machine learning (AutoML) or automated data science (AutoDS), AutoAI represents a fundamentally different paradigm. This paper clarifies the distinctions between these fields, addressing the current "terminology crisis" and outlining a conceptual framework for the future of autonomous systems that can adapt to uncertain, open-world environments.

The Terminology Crisis: Automation vs. Autonomy

The field of AI is currently grappling with a terminology crisis where terms like AutoML, AutoDS, and AutoAI are frequently used interchangeably by researchers and vendors. However, as Longbing Cao argues, they represent distinct goals.

The IEEE Intelligent Systems issue featuring advancements in autonomous and behavioral AI.

AutoML and AutoDS are primarily concerned with automation—the streamlining of design-time tasks such as data cleaning, feature selection, and hyperparameter optimization. While these tools improve efficiency and standardize production, they often result in "limited flexibility" and struggle with "adaptive problem-solving."

In contrast, AutoAI focuses on autonomy. It aims to build systems capable of evolving and making decisions in unanticipated or "open" environments. While automation optimizes known workflows, autonomy empowers systems to handle unknown scenarios.

The Conceptual Pillars of AutoAI

To move beyond simple automation, AutoAI incorporates several key conceptual pillars:

  • AI Mind and Mindfulness: This involves integrating human-like cognitive paradigms and self-awareness into AI systems, allowing them to "understand" their own processes and limitations.
  • AI Actionability: The goal is to move from theoretical predictions to actionable decision-support that provides flexible personalization and adaptive problem-solving in specific domains.
  • Cyber-Physical-Social Systems (CPSS): AutoAI must navigate the complex interplay between digital systems, physical environments, and human society.

The transition from automation to autonomy is supported by diverse methodologies. Recent research highlights several advancements:

  • Navigation in Unknown Environments: Using Continuous Actor-Critic Learning, drones have successfully implemented online local path planning in unknown indoor corridors.
  • Enhanced Machine Perception: Knowledge-based entity prediction uses cyclic knowledge completion to improve how machines perceive and categorize their surroundings.
  • Secure Autonomous Communication: To avoid the latency of standard encryption in time-sensitive autonomous systems, researchers have introduced graph-theoretic cryptography (e.g., "clique injection").
  • Safety-Critical Reliability: Logic Learning Machines are being used to tune rules around safety regions, ensuring reliability in environments like maritime or industrial settings (e.g., recognizing slanted deck scenes with constrained hardware).

Key Insights: The Wider Spectrum

AutoAI is not merely about better algorithms; it encompasses a broader body of knowledge including the human mind, emotion, and societal intelligence. Traditional automated systems rely on design-time decisions, but AutoAI requires "evolving AI capabilities" that learn and collaborate during runtime. This shift is essential for bridging the gap between a model's output and a human's ability to use that output effectively.

Future Directions: Mindful and Collaborative AI

The future of AutoAI lies in moving toward systems that simulate human emotion and social intelligence. This includes the development of "Mindful AI" and a shift toward complex Expert-Machine Collaboration. Rather than simple interaction, future systems will engage in competitive and collaborative game-theory-based decision-making with human experts.

IEEE Intelligent Systems' mission to provide peer-reviewed research on systems that perceive, reason, and learn.

By distinguishing autonomy from mere automation, the research community can better focus on the challenges of creating AI that truly perceives, reasons, learns, and acts intelligently in an unpredictable world.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the AI evolution, a significant and lasting vision and mission has been on designing autonomous AI systems (AutoAI). AutoAI differs significantly from another set of movements on automated machine learning (AutoML) and automated data science (AutoDS), which are often deemed interchangeable with automated AI. AutoML and AutoDS aim to automate some of the analytical and learning tasks, processes, and pipelines. This issue highlights the theme on AutoAI: Autonomous AI with six feature articles. My editorial further clarifies various misconceptions, myths, and pitfalls about the three related and often confused areas: AutoAI, AutoML, and AutoDS. This issue also includes an article on parallel population and human in the column AI Expert, expert–machine collaboration in the column AI Focus, and another article on intelligent mobile spaces and metaverses for the AI and Cyber-Physical-Social Systems (AI-CPSS) department.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cao2022autoai,
  author = {Longbing Cao},
  title = {{AutoAI: Autonomous AI}},
  booktitle = {IEEE Intell. Syst},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=aIXQ0o9Tb9x},
}
Figure