Autism Caregiver Coaching in Africa (ACACIA): Protocol for a type 1-hybrid effectiveness-implementation trial

Lauren Franz, Marisa Viljoen, Sandy Askew, Musaddiqah Brown, Géraldine Dawson, J. Matías Di Martino, Guillermo Sapiro, Katlego Sebolai, Noleen Seris, Nokuthula Shabalala, Aubyn C. Stahmer, Elizabeth L. Turner, Petrus J. de VriesmedRxiv 2023 · DOI

This blog-style summary provides an overview of the ACACIA trial protocol, a significant study aimed at addressing the autism intervention gap in low-resource settings.

TL;DR

The ACACIA trial evaluates a "cascaded task-sharing" model in South Africa, where non-specialist educators coach caregivers of autistic children in evidence-based intervention strategies. By utilizing a type 1 hybrid effectiveness-implementation design, the study aims to prove both the clinical benefit for children and the feasibility of scaling this model within existing educational systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

There is a massive global disparity in access to early autism intervention. While evidence-based practices like Naturalistic Developmental Behavioral Interventions (NDBI) are effective, they are typically delivered by highly trained specialists (psychologists or speech therapists) who are scarce in low- and middle-income countries (LMIC).

This "specialist gap" is most acute in Africa, a continent projected to be home to 40% of the world’s children by 2050. Previous attempts to use Community Health Workers for task-sharing have faced challenges like burnout and lack of specialized training. The ACACIA trial addresses this by pivoting to Early Childhood Development (ECD) practitioners—a workforce already embedded in the education system—to coach caregivers, thereby creating a sustainable and scalable "cascaded" delivery model.

Methods

The study employs a type 1 hybrid effectiveness-implementation design. This means it simultaneously tests whether the intervention works (effectiveness) and identifies the factors that influence its success in the real world (implementation).

  • Cascaded Task-Sharing: The model flows from specialists to non-specialists (ECD practitioners) to caregivers, who then implement strategies with the child.
  • The Intervention: The team adapted the Early Start Denver Model (ESDM) into the ACACIA coaching program. It consists of 12 one-hour sessions.
  • Digital Adaptation: To bridge the "digital divide," intervention materials (videos and simple text) are delivered via WhatsApp, a low-cost, ubiquitous platform in the region.
  • Trial Design: A 1:1 parallel-arm, single-blinded, randomized controlled trial (RCT) with 150 caregiver-child dyads. The control group receives "usual care" but is offered the intervention after the primary study period (delayed-start design).
  • Implementation Framework: The researchers use the EPIS (Exploration, Preparation, Implementation, Sustainment) framework to systematically track barriers and facilitators.

Datasets

As this is a protocol paper for a clinical trial, it describes the planned data collection rather than a static training dataset. Key data points include:

  • Clinical Outcomes: The Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales (VABS-3) for communication and the Griffiths Scales of Child Development (Griffiths III) for developmental quotients.
  • Behavioral Coding: The Joint Engagement Rating Inventory (JERI) to measure the quality of caregiver-child interactions.
  • Implementation Metrics: The Implementation Leadership Scale (ILS) and Implementation Climate Scale (ICS) to assess the organizational "fit" within the Western Cape Department of Education.
  • Diagnostic Baseline: The Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule (ADOS-2) is used to confirm eligibility and characterize the cohort.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Education" Pivot: Unlike many global health initiatives that rely on the medical sector, ACACIA leverages the Education Department. ECD practitioners have dedicated time and existing supervision structures, making them a potentially more stable workforce for long-term scaling.
  • Cultural and Ecological Validity: The protocol emphasizes that the intervention was not just "translated" but "adapted." This included involving autistic self-advocates and local caregivers to ensure the strategies fit South African daily routines and interaction styles.
  • Union-Intersection Testing: The trial uses a rigorous statistical decision rule where the intervention is considered successful if there is a significant signal in at least one of the two co-primary communication outcomes.
  • Addressing the "Digital Divide": By using WhatsApp for material delivery, the study acknowledges the infrastructure realities of LMICs while still providing high-quality, video-based modeling for low-literacy settings.

Key Results

While the full trial results are expected in March 2027, the paper highlights promising data from a 10-dyad pilot study:

  • Fidelity: 10/10 caregivers successfully learned and implemented the NDBI strategies.
  • Child Progress: 9/10 children showed improvements in communication scores.
  • Enrollment: The main RCT began enrollment in April 2023, targeting 300 total participants (150 dyads).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several inherent challenges:

  • Blinding: It is impossible to blind caregivers or coaches to their treatment assignment, which introduces potential bias, though clinical assessors remain blinded.
  • Usual Care Variability: "Usual care" in South Africa is often minimal and inconsistent, making it a "moving target" for a control comparison.
  • Social Desirability: Caregiver-reported outcomes (like stress or competence) may be influenced by a desire to please the researchers.

Future Work: If successful, the ACACIA model could serve as a blueprint for "cascaded" mental health and developmental services across other LMICs, moving away from a reliance on rare specialists toward a community-powered model of care.

Summary updated

Abstract

The ACACIA trial will determine whether a cascaded task-sharing intervention delivered in an educational setting leads to meaningful improvements in communication abilities of autistic children, and identify implementation barriers and facilitators.
BibTeX
@misc{franz2023autism,
  author = {Lauren Franz and Marisa Viljoen and Sandy Askew and Musaddiqah Brown and Géraldine Dawson and J. Matías Di Martino and Guillermo Sapiro and Katlego Sebolai and Noleen Seris and Nokuthula Shabalala and Aubyn C. Stahmer and Elizabeth L. Turner and Petrus J. de Vries},
  title = {{Autism Caregiver Coaching in Africa (ACACIA): Protocol for a type 1-hybrid effectiveness-implementation trial}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.09.10.23295331},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure