Author Correction: Population genomics of the Viking world
Ashot Margaryan, Daniel J. Lawson, Martin Sikora, Fernando Racimo, Simon Rasmussen, Ida Moltke, Lara M. Cassidy, Emil Jørsboe, Andrés Ingason, Mikkel Winther Pedersen, Thorfinn Sand Korneliussen, Helene Wilhelmson, Magdalena M. Buś, Peter de Barros Damgaard, Rui Martiniano, Gabriel Renaud, Claude Bhérer, J. Víctor Moreno-Mayar, Anna K. Fotakis, Marie Allen, Raili Allmäe, Martyna Molak, Enrico Cappellini, Gabriele Scorrano, Hugh McColl, Alexandra Buzhilova, Allison Fox, Anders Albrechtsen, Berit Schütz, Birgitte Skår, Caroline Arcini, Ceri Falys, Charlotte Hedenstierna Jonson, Dariusz Błaszczyk, Denis V. Pezhemsky, Gordon Turner‐Walker, Hildur Gestsdóttir, Inge Lundstrøm, Ingrid Gustin, Ingrid Mainland, Inna Potekhina, Italo Maria Muntoni, Jade Yu Cheng, Jesper Stenderup, Jilong Ma, Julie Gibson, Jüri Peets, Jörgen Gustafsson, Katrine Iversen, Linzi Simpson, Lisa Strand, Louise Loe, Maeve Sikora, Marek Florek, Maria Vretemark, Mark Redknap, Monika Bajka, Tamara Pushkina, Morten Søvsø, Natalia Grigorieva, Tom Christensen, Ole Thirup Kastholm, Otto Uldum, Pasquale Favia, Per Holck, Sabine Sten, Símun V. Arge, Sturla Ellingvåg, Vayacheslav Moiseyev, Wiesław Bogdanowicz, Yvonne Magnusson, Ludovic Orlando, Peter Pentz, Mads Dengsø Jessen, Anne Pedersen, Mark Collard, Daniel G. Bradley, Marie Louise Schjellerup Jørkov, Jette Arneborg, Niels Lynnerup, Neil Price, M. Thomas P. Gilbert, Morten E. Allentoft, Jan Bill, Søren Michael Sindbæk, Lotte Hedeager, Kristian Kristiansen, Rasmus Nielsen, Thomas Werge, Eske WillerslevNature2021 · DOI
In 2020, the study "Population genomics of the Viking world" provided an unprecedented look into the genetic history of Scandinavia and its neighbors during the Viking Age. However, as with many large-scale genomic surveys involving hundreds of samples and international collaborations, data refinement is an ongoing process. This formal correction addresses critical metadata errors regarding the chronological placement of two specific archaeological samples, ensuring the continued accuracy of this foundational dataset.
The Correction: Refining the Timeline
The primary focus of this update is the reclassification of two ancient DNA samples, VK201 and VK203, which were originally listed in Supplementary Table 1. In the initial publication, these individuals were categorized as belonging to the 10th century CE, placing them firmly within the Viking Age.
Upon further review, the dating estimates for these samples have been corrected to reflect an earlier historical period:
Sample VK201: Originally designated as 10th-century Viking; now reclassified as Iron Age, specifically dating to the 5th–6th century CE.
Sample VK203: Originally designated as 10th-century Viking; now reclassified as Iron Age, dating to the 1st–7th century CE.
The Significance of Temporal Resolution
In the field of paleogenomics, the utility of a DNA sample is entirely dependent on its context—specifically, where it was found and when the individual lived. The "when" is just as important as the "where." By moving these samples from the 10th century back to the 1st–7th centuries, they are shifted from the height of the Viking expansion to the preceding Migration Period and Iron Age.
This distinction is vital for researchers attempting to map the arrival of specific genetic ancestries. For instance, identifying when "Southern European" or "British-like" genetic components first appeared in Scandinavian populations requires a precise temporal baseline. Misdating samples can lead to incorrect conclusions about the timing of migrations or the speed of genetic turnover. By reassigning VK201 and VK203 to the Iron Age, the authors clarify that these individuals represent the genetic landscape prior to the traditional Viking expansion, rather than the result of it.
Data Integrity in Large-Scale Genomics
The original 2020 study involved the sequencing of 442 ancient genomes and a vast network of researchers. The necessity of this correction highlights the complexities of managing "Big Data" in archaeology and genomics. Maintaining the "cleanliness" of open-access datasets is a collaborative and iterative process that continues long after the initial publication.
While the reclassification of two samples out of hundreds is a minor adjustment to the overall model and is unlikely to alter the study's broad statistical conclusions—such as PCA clusters or overall admixture proportions—it is a necessary step for ensuring the integrity of secondary analyses. It underscores the importance of the peer and author review process in maintaining the accuracy of the historical record.
Conclusion
This correction serves as a vital update for the scientific community. For future researchers utilizing the "Viking world" dataset, it is essential to use the updated Supplementary Table 1 to avoid chronological errors in their own secondary analyses. The refinement of these dates ensures that the study remains a reliable cornerstone for understanding the complex history of the Viking Age and the periods that preceded it.
Summary updated
BibTeX
@inproceedings{margaryan2021author,
author = {Ashot Margaryan and Daniel J. Lawson and Martin Sikora and Fernando Racimo and Simon Rasmussen and Ida Moltke and Lara M. Cassidy and Emil Jørsboe and Andrés Ingason and Mikkel Winther Pedersen and Thorfinn Sand Korneliussen and Helene Wilhelmson and Magdalena M. Buś and Peter de Barros Damgaard and Rui Martiniano and Gabriel Renaud and Claude Bhérer and J. Víctor Moreno-Mayar and Anna K. Fotakis and Marie Allen and Raili Allmäe and Martyna Molak and Enrico Cappellini and Gabriele Scorrano and Hugh McColl and Alexandra Buzhilova and Allison Fox and Anders Albrechtsen and Berit Schütz and Birgitte Skår and Caroline Arcini and Ceri Falys and Charlotte Hedenstierna Jonson and Dariusz Błaszczyk and Denis V. Pezhemsky and Gordon Turner‐Walker and Hildur Gestsdóttir and Inge Lundstrøm and Ingrid Gustin and Ingrid Mainland and Inna Potekhina and Italo Maria Muntoni and Jade Yu Cheng and Jesper Stenderup and Jilong Ma and Julie Gibson and Jüri Peets and Jörgen Gustafsson and Katrine Iversen and Linzi Simpson and Lisa Strand and Louise Loe and Maeve Sikora and Marek Florek and Maria Vretemark and Mark Redknap and Monika Bajka and Tamara Pushkina and Morten Søvsø and Natalia Grigorieva and Tom Christensen and Ole Thirup Kastholm and Otto Uldum and Pasquale Favia and Per Holck and Sabine Sten and Símun V. Arge and Sturla Ellingvåg and Vayacheslav Moiseyev and Wiesław Bogdanowicz and Yvonne Magnusson and Ludovic Orlando and Peter Pentz and Mads Dengsø Jessen and Anne Pedersen and Mark Collard and Daniel G. Bradley and Marie Louise Schjellerup Jørkov and Jette Arneborg and Niels Lynnerup and Neil Price and M. Thomas P. Gilbert and Morten E. Allentoft and Jan Bill and Søren Michael Sindbæk and Lotte Hedeager and Kristian Kristiansen and Rasmus Nielsen and Thomas Werge and Eske Willerslev},
title = {{Author Correction: Population genomics of the Viking world}},
booktitle = {Nature},
year = {2021},
doi = {10.1038/s41586-021-03328-2},
}