This document serves as an official Author Correction for a Perspective article previously published in Nature Physics. The correction addresses a critical graphical error in the representation of electronic states within kagome lattice models, specifically affecting the $AV_3Sb_5$ material family.
Correcting the Graphical Representation
The primary focus of this update is the revision of Figure 2f from the original publication. In the study of topological phases and frustrated electronic states, the precise mapping of "currents" (charge flow) and "fluxes" (effective magnetic fields) is essential for accurate theoretical modeling. The original figure contained a technical inaccuracy in the panel depicting charge order in $AV_3Sb_5$ ($A = K, Rb, Cs$).
The corrected figure ensures that the arrangement of light and dark grey arrows, alongside the red and blue flux regions, accurately reflects the intended charge order symmetry.
Clarification of Visual Symbols
To prevent further ambiguity, the authors have provided a more precise definition of the symbols used in these lattice maps:
- Arrows in the Left Panel (Haldane model): These represent the direction of complex hoppings with a positive imaginary part.
- Arrows in the Middle and Right Panels (Varma model and $AV_3Sb_5$): These represent actual physical electrical currents.
- Arrow Shading: Light grey indicates a small magnitude or strength of the current/hopping, while dark grey indicates a larger magnitude.
- Background Colors: Red and blue shading indicate positive and negative fluxes, respectively, passing through specific areas of the lattice.
Theoretical Implications
This correction highlights several vital distinctions in condensed matter theory:
- Hopping vs. Current: It is crucial to distinguish between "complex hopping" (a Hamiltonian parameter describing electron movement with a phase shift) and "current" (the physical flow of charge). Misrepresenting these patterns can lead to incorrect conclusions about the underlying symmetries of the material's electronic state.
- Symmetry in $AV_3Sb_5$: The $AV_3Sb_5$ family is known for exhibiting a "chiral" charge order. The corrected visual map is essential for researchers attempting to correlate theoretical models with experimental data from Scanning Tunneling Microscopy (STM) or Muon Spin Relaxation ($\mu$SR).
- The Role of Flux: By clarifying that background colors represent fluxes, the authors emphasize the "loop current" nature of these states, which are central to the Varma model and its application to kagome systems.
Conclusion
While this update does not change the fundamental conclusions of the original Perspective, it ensures the visual data is a reliable reference for the community. Accurately modeling and visualizing complex, broken-symmetry states in frustrated lattices remains a significant challenge, and this correction provides the necessary clarity for ongoing experimental verification of loop-current patterns in kagome materials.
Summary updated