Augmented reality-guided periacetabular osteotomy—proof of concept

Pascal Kiarostami, Cyrill Dennler, Simon Roner, Reto Sutter, Philipp Fürnstahl, Mazda Farshad, Stefan Rahm, Patrick O. ZinggJournal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a proof-of-concept study demonstrating the feasibility of using augmented reality (AR) to guide surgeons performing periacetabular osteotomies (PAOs), a complex hip surgery. The AR system showed potential to improve surgical accuracy, particularly for less experienced surgeons, by overlaying pre-operative plans directly into the surgeon's field of view.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Periacetabular osteotomy (PAO) is a crucial surgical procedure for treating hip dysplasia and femoroacetabular impingement. However, it involves four technically demanding osteotomies that require precise execution to achieve the correct physiological reorientation of the acetabulum. Traditional methods rely on anatomical landmarks and intraoperative fluoroscopy, which can be time-consuming, expose patients and staff to radiation, and are limited in their ability to control certain osteotomies due to their 2D nature. Existing advanced navigation techniques often require expensive equipment and extensive surgical exposure, and may not fully address the challenges of specific osteotomies like the ischial cut. This paper addresses the need for a simpler, radiation-free system that can enhance the accuracy of PAO, particularly for the most challenging osteotomies.

Methods

The researchers developed a proof-of-concept AR guidance system for PAO. A 3D preoperative plan of the PAO was created from CT scans of an anatomical plastic pelvis model. This plan was then embedded into a custom-made AR application for a Microsoft HoloLens head-mounted display (HMD). To simulate the surgical environment, the sawbone pelvis and femur were covered with foam rubber to mimic skin and soft tissue.

The AR system required a registration process to align the 3D holographic plan with the actual sawbone model. This was achieved by marking specific pelvic landmarks with a pointing device. During the simulated surgeries, surgeons could view the holographic osteotomy planes superimposed on the sawbone model, guiding their cuts with either an oscillating saw or chisels.

Two surgeons, one experienced in PAO (>100 cases) and one novice (<50 cases), each performed 15 freehand (FH) PAOs and 15 AR-guided PAOs on sawbone models. The study compared the accuracy of the osteotomies by measuring the differences between the planned and executed starting points and the angular deviation of the retroacetabular osteotomy (raOT).

Datasets

The study utilized sawbone models of the femur and pelvis manufactured by Sawbones. These models were scanned using a CT scanner to create 3D surface models. No patient data was used in this proof-of-concept study.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • AR as a Visual Overlay: The core innovation is the real-time overlay of complex 3D surgical plans directly into the surgeon's line of sight, eliminating the need to look away at separate monitors.
  • Addressing the Ischial Osteotomy Challenge: The AR guidance system showed particular promise in guiding the technically difficult ischial osteotomy, which is often performed with limited visual control in vivo.
  • Experience Matters: The benefits of AR guidance appear to be more pronounced for surgeons with less experience, suggesting it could significantly shorten the learning curve for complex procedures.
  • Feasibility Demonstrated: The study successfully demonstrates that AR guidance for PAO is not only feasible but can be implemented with existing HMD technology.

Key Results

  • Expert Surgeon: For the experienced PAO surgeon, AR guidance did not significantly alter the accuracy of osteotomy starting points compared to freehand techniques. However, the AR-guided retroacetabular osteotomy (raOT) angle showed a significantly better correlation with the pre-operative plan (7.8° vs. 11.7°, p=0.0027). No intraarticular osteotomies or posterior column interruptions occurred with this surgeon.
  • Novice Surgeon: The novice surgeon showed improved accuracy with AR guidance for the ischial osteotomy (iOT), with a statistically significant difference in mean distance between planned and executed starting points (p=0.03). Notably, the novice surgeon performed one intraarticular osteotomy during freehand procedures, which was avoided with AR guidance.
  • Overall: The study concluded that AR guidance for PAO is feasible and appears to increase accuracy, with a more pronounced effect observed in less-experienced surgeons.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sawbone Model vs. In Vivo: The use of sawbone models covered with foam does not perfectly replicate the complexities of a live surgical environment.
  • Potential Memory Effect: The alternating performance of FH and AR-guided procedures within the same setting might have introduced a memory effect, potentially benefiting the FH group.
  • Limited Scope: Only the osteotomies were AR-guided; the reorientation and fixation of the acetabulum were not investigated.

Future work should include:

  • Cadaver Studies: The next logical step is to validate these findings in cadaver studies to better approximate in vivo conditions.
  • Clinical Trials: Further research is essential to elaborate on the potential merits of AR guidance for increasing the accuracy of complex surgical procedures in actual clinical practice.
  • Full Procedure Guidance: Investigating AR guidance for the entire PAO procedure, including acetabular reorientation and fixation, is warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

This is the first proof of concept study documenting the feasibility of AR guidance for PAO. Based on these findings, further studies are essential for elaborating on the potential merits of AR guidance to increase the accuracy of complex surgical procedures.
BibTeX
@article{kiarostami2020augmented,
  author = {Pascal Kiarostami and Cyrill Dennler and Simon Roner and Reto Sutter and Philipp Fürnstahl and Mazda Farshad and Stefan Rahm and Patrick O. Zingg},
  title = {{Augmented reality-guided periacetabular osteotomy—proof of concept}},
  journal = {Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1186/s13018-020-02066-x},
}
Figure