Auditor’s Education Background and Audit Fees Based on Audit Risk Level

Jie M. ZhangJournal of Economics and law 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how an auditor's educational level influences the fees they charge, specifically within the context of varying audit risks. The research reveals that more highly educated auditors command higher fees, and this pricing gap widens significantly when the audit risk—the likelihood of material misstatements—is high.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the world of corporate finance, auditing is often viewed through the lens of institutional standards and firm-wide reputations. However, the actual work is performed by individuals whose personal characteristics—gender, experience, and education—can influence their professional judgment.

The author identifies a gap in existing literature: while we know that firm size (e.g., "Big Four" vs. others) affects pricing, we have less data on how an individual auditor's "human capital" (specifically their education) interacts with environmental factors like audit risk. As the Chinese economy transitions into a "new normal" of slower growth, business complexities and financial fraud risks are rising. This paper explores whether highly educated auditors are better at identifying these risks and whether they adjust their pricing to account for the extra effort required to mitigate them.

Methods

The researcher employed a quantitative empirical approach using secondary data. The study is grounded in Attribution Theory, which suggests that an individual's behavior is a result of both internal factors (like education) and external elements (like the regulatory environment).

Key technical aspects include:

  • Regression Analysis: The author used Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) and logistic regression via Stata 15 to test two primary hypotheses.
  • Variable Modeling:
    • Independent Variable: Educational Background (EB), measured on a scale from 1 (junior college) to 5 (doctorate).
  • Dependent Variable: Audit Fees (AF), normalized using a natural logarithm.
  • Moderating Variable: Audit Risk Level (ARL), proxied by "audit delay"—the number of days between the balance sheet date and the audit report date. The logic is that higher risk requires more testing time, leading to longer delays.
  • Control Variables: To isolate the effect of education, the model controlled for company-specific factors like inventory levels, accounts receivable, leverage, liquidity, and Return on Assets (ROA).

Datasets

The study utilized the CSMAR (China Stock Market & Accounting Research) database, specifically the "Audit Opinion" and "Audit Research" subsets.

  • Scope: 10 years of financial report data (2013–2022).
  • Sample Size: 2,098 China-listed companies on the Shenzhen and Shanghai Stock Exchanges.
  • Exclusions: The researcher excluded "Special Treatment" (ST) companies and firms in the financial industry due to their unique regulatory and business structures.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Education as a Proxy for Competence and Caution: The paper argues that higher education isn't just a credential; it correlates with higher professional skepticism and a greater ability to use sophisticated auditing tools. Highly educated auditors are more likely to issue "non-standard" (cautious) audit opinions.
  • The Risk-Premium Interaction: The most interesting finding is the moderating effect. Education doesn't just increase fees linearly; it changes how auditors respond to danger. When risk is high, highly educated auditors appear to "up-skill" their effort—performing more thorough verifications and seeking outside counsel—which drives fees up substantially compared to their less-educated peers.
  • Information for Regulators: The study suggests that if regulators and investors can identify the specific educational backgrounds of the audit team, they might gain better insight into the "quality" and "risk-sensitivity" of the financial reports they are reading.

Key Results

  • Hypothesis 1 (Education vs. Fees): Confirmed. The coefficient for educational background (EB) was 0.0261, significant at the 1% level. This indicates a positive correlation between higher degrees and higher audit fees.
  • Hypothesis 2 (The Moderating Role of Risk): Confirmed. When testing the interaction between education and risk level, the "new" interaction variable showed a coefficient of 0.0274 (p < 0.01). This proves that as audit risk increases, the "education premium" on fees becomes even more pronounced.
  • Descriptive Stats: The mean education level was 3.97 (approaching a Master's degree level), suggesting that the Chinese audit market for listed companies is dominated by highly educated professionals.

Limitations and Future Work

The author acknowledges several constraints:

  • Geographic Specificity: The data is strictly from the Chinese stock market. Because capital market regulations and audit procedures vary wildly between the US, UK, and China, these results may not be globally generalizable.
  • Sample Size and Duration: While 10 years is a solid window, the author notes that 2,098 companies is a relatively small subset of the global market, and the duration is "rather short" for long-term behavioral trends.
  • Future Directions: The paper recommends that future research should incorporate data from other economies to see if the "education premium" holds true in different cultural and regulatory contexts. It also suggests that accounting firms should more intentionally allocate their most educated/experienced auditors to high-risk clients as a matter of quality control.

Summary updated

Abstract

To get a good audit report or make the auditing environment more fairly and orderly, we should focus on the auditors’ subjective factors like the personal characteristics such as gender, experience, position, educational background, major and so on. The goal of this study is to explore the relationship between auditors’ education background and audit fees based on audit risk level. Based on the attribution theory, the two hypotheses development are put forward between audit fees and auditors’ educational background based on audit risk level in this study. Collecting secondary data and analyzing it completely, all the data processing and calculation process of the empirical study were completed by excel and stata15. The results are that auditors with greater education tend to charge higher auditing fees. Moreover, highly educated auditors charge substantially higher audit fees when the audit risk is higher, indicating that audit risk level moderates the positive effect between auditors’ educational background and audit fees. According to the research, investors and regulators might be able to obtain more information if they can identify certain auditors. This study can provide a positive basis for the training of auditors’ talents and the construction of industry team.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2024auditors,
  author = {Jie M. Zhang},
  title = {{Auditor’s Education Background and Audit Fees Based on Audit Risk Level}},
  journal = {Journal of economics and law.},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.62517/jel.202414601},
}
Figure