Audience Engagement with Political Messaging on YouTube Shorts (Student Abstract)

Omkar Narkar, Aman Vohra, Ashiqur R. KhudaBukhshAAAI 2025 · DOI

Abstract

This research investigates how the transition to short-form video content on YouTube influences political discourse. By comparing YouTube Shorts with traditional long-form videos across 100 prominent political channels, the study identifies a significant shift in audience behavior. While Shorts achieve higher engagement through likes and views, they simultaneously foster shorter, more emoji-reliant, and notably more toxic interactions. Furthermore, the discourse on Shorts is found to be more polarized, suggesting that the format's emphasis on virality may deepen partisan divides.

Introduction

The rise of short-form video platforms like TikTok and Instagram Reels has fundamentally altered digital consumption. YouTube Shorts, launched in 2021, has quickly become a major player in this space. However, the implications of this "bite-sized" format for political communication remain under-explored compared to traditional long-form content or text-based social media. This study addresses whether the format itself changes the nature of political conversation, potentially prioritizing outrage over nuance.

Methodology

The researchers utilized a matched-pair approach to compare 19,496 Shorts with 19,342 Longs from the same 100 channels (50 liberal, 50 conservative) within similar upload windows. Engagement was measured via likes, views, and comment counts. Content analysis involved Google’s Perspective API for toxicity detection and a machine-translation-based framework to quantify linguistic polarization between partisan groups.

Results: The Engagement Paradox

YouTube Shorts function as high-velocity engagement engines. They consistently garner more likes and views than traditional long-form videos. However, this increased visibility does not translate to deeper discourse. Comments on Shorts are significantly shorter and utilize 25–30% more emojis, indicating a shift toward more superficial interaction.

Comparison of average likes between Shorts and Longs for Liberal and Conservative channels.

Results: Toxicity and Polarization

A critical finding of the study is the increased toxicity associated with the Shorts format. User discussions on Shorts are measurably more toxic than those on Long-form videos. Conservative Shorts, in particular, were identified as a flashpoint for the most toxic interactions, showing the highest fraction of toxic comments among the categories studied.

Fraction of toxic comments across video formats and political leanings.

Beyond toxicity, the study found a stark difference in polarization. Using a scale where higher scores indicate less polarization, Longs scored 80.1% while Shorts scored 71.4%. This suggests that the rapid-fire nature of Shorts leaves less room for cross-partisan understanding, potentially exacerbating the "echo chamber" effect.

Conclusion and Limitations

The findings highlight a trade-off: while short-form video increases reach and immediate engagement, it degrades the quality of political discourse. Limitations include the focus on the US context and the inability to distinguish between algorithmic influence and creator intent. Future research should investigate the role of recommendation systems in driving these observed patterns of toxicity and polarization.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{narkar2025audience,
  author = {Omkar Narkar and Aman Vohra and Ashiqur R. KhudaBukhsh},
  title = {{Audience Engagement with Political Messaging on YouTube Shorts (Student Abstract)}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1609/aaai.v39i28.35280},
}
Figure