TL;DR
This paper argues that myths in Canadian foreign policy are not mere illusions but crucial tools for fostering national unity. By examining how these myths are constructed and perpetuated, the authors reveal their function in shaping a shared identity, particularly in distinguishing Canada from the United States and reinforcing liberal values.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The authors tackle the question of why certain narratives about Canadian foreign policy persist, even when they seem to contradict historical facts. They observe that common perceptions of Canada as a peaceful, peace-keeping, and mediating nation are often more myth than reality. The paper aims to understand the origins, articulation, and, most importantly, the functions of these myths, particularly their role in contributing to national unity. They frame this within a constructivist approach to International Relations, emphasizing the social construction of identity and interests.
Methods
The paper employs a constructivist framework to analyze the role of myths in Canadian foreign policy. This involves:
- Discursive Articulation: Examining how political elites construct narratives about Canada's role, status, and values on the international stage.
- Societal Legitimation: Analyzing how these narratives are accepted and reinforced by the domestic population.
- External Recognition: Considering how other states perceive and acknowledge these Canadian narratives.
The authors also draw on the concept of "role conceptions" from International Relations theory, viewing national identity as a primary driver of state behavior. They highlight the importance of "intersubjectivity" – shared understandings and agreements – in legitimizing these national narratives.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Myths as Identity Builders: Myths are not simply falsehoods but "sacred narratives" that provide a shared understanding of history and identity, crucial for community cohesion.
- Constructivist Lens: Understanding foreign policy myths requires looking beyond factual accuracy to how they are socially constructed and maintained through discourse and collective belief.
- National Unity as a Core Function: A primary role of these myths is to reinforce national unity by providing common historical referents and a shared sense of identity, especially in distinguishing Canada from the United States.
- Liberal-Canadian Identity: The paper links Canadian foreign policy myths to a broader liberal identity, emphasizing values like multiculturalism, tolerance, and compromise.
- "Peaceable Kingdom" Myth: This myth, portraying Canada as inherently non-militaristic, serves to downplay historical instances of conflict and reinforce a pacific national image.
- "Champion of Peacekeeping" Myth: This narrative, stemming from events like the Suez Crisis and Lester Pearson's Nobel Peace Prize, solidifies Canada's image as a dedicated peacekeeper, even as contemporary missions challenge this perception.
- "Mediator" Myth: This myth positions Canada as an impartial intermediary in international disputes, reinforcing its role as a facilitator of dialogue and compromise.
Key Results
The paper doesn't present quantitative results but offers a qualitative analysis of how three key myths – the "Peaceable Kingdom," the "Champion of Peacekeeping," and the "Mediator" – function to:
- Reinforce National Unity: By providing shared historical narratives and a sense of collective pride, these myths help bridge linguistic and regional divides within Canada.
- Legitimize Foreign Policy: They offer a framework for understanding and justifying Canada's international actions, particularly in areas of peace and diplomacy.
- Shape National Identity: These myths contribute to a distinct Canadian identity, often defined in contrast to the perceived militarism or unilateralism of the United States.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that due to space constraints, they could not fully explore the complexity of these myths or their role in differentiating Canada internationally, particularly in relation to the United States. They suggest future research should:
- Investigate the Silence on National Unity: Explore why national unity, despite being a stated priority, is often overlooked in academic research on Canadian foreign policy.
- Analyze International Differentiation: Further examine how myths contribute to Canada's international identity and its distinctiveness on the global stage, especially in its relationship with the US.
- Explore Elite Influence: Investigate how political elites use discourse and narrative to construct and perpetuate these myths, and how this interacts with power dynamics.
Summary updated