TL;DR
This study investigates the drivers of runoff changes in China's Kuye River Basin, a critical area in the Yellow River Basin. By applying three Budyko-based methods, researchers found that changes in catchment surface characteristics, particularly land use and vegetation cover, have been the dominant factor in reducing runoff since 1997, outweighing the impacts of climate change.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The Yellow River Basin, a vital water source for China, is experiencing significant changes in its hydrological systems. Understanding the causes behind these changes, specifically the reduction in river runoff, is crucial for effective water resource management and mitigating soil erosion in the Loess Plateau region. While both climate change and human activities are known to influence runoff, disentangling their relative contributions is a complex challenge. This paper aims to address this by quantifying the impact of these two drivers on runoff variation in the Kuye River Basin, a representative tributary, using established hydrological frameworks.
Methods
The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach to attribute runoff changes:
- Trend and Change Point Analysis: They utilized the Mann-Kendall trend test to identify long-term trends in precipitation, potential evapotranspiration, and runoff depth. To pinpoint the exact moment when runoff patterns shifted, four different mutation point detection methods (Pettitt test, cumulative distance level method, moving t-test, and Yamamoto method) were used and synthesized.
- Budyko Hypothesis Framework: The core of the attribution analysis relied on the Budyko hypothesis, which links water balance to energy balance. Three commonly used Budyko-type equations (Wang and Tang, Fu, and Choudhury and Yang) were applied to estimate actual evapotranspiration. These equations incorporate parameters representing climate (precipitation, potential evapotranspiration) and catchment surface characteristics.
- Elasticity Coefficient Method: To quantify the sensitivity of runoff to changes in these factors, the elasticity coefficient method was used. This method measures the percentage change in runoff for a given percentage change in a specific influencing factor (e.g., precipitation, potential evapotranspiration, or the catchment surface parameter).
- Contribution Analysis: By combining the elasticity coefficients and the observed changes in the influencing factors between a "base period" (pre-1997, assumed natural conditions) and an "anthropogenic impact period" (post-1997), the study calculated the quantitative contribution of climate change and human activities to runoff variations.
Datasets
The study utilized the following datasets:
- Runoff Data: Daily runoff data from Wenjiachuan hydrological station for the period 1956–2018.
- Meteorological Data: Daily data including precipitation, temperature (mean, maximum, minimum), sunshine hours, and mean wind speed from five national meteorological stations for 1956–2018. These were interpolated to obtain watershed-scale data.
- Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI): Data from the "Long Time-Series Chinese Vegetation Index Dataset–GIMMS NDVI" (8 km resolution, 1981–2015) to analyze changes in vegetation cover.
- Land Use Data: Landsat remote sensing image data for 1980 and 2018 to analyze changes in land use.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The 1997 Turning Point: A significant finding is the identification of 1997 as a clear change point for runoff in the Kuye River Basin. This aligns with the timing of intensified coal mining and the implementation of China's "return of farmland to forest" policy, suggesting a strong human influence.
- Human Activities Dominate Runoff Reduction: While climate factors play a role, the study consistently shows that changes in catchment surface characteristics (largely driven by land use changes and vegetation cover) are the primary driver of the significant runoff decrease observed since 1997.
- Runoff is Highly Sensitive to Surface Changes: The elasticity coefficients reveal that runoff is increasingly sensitive to changes in the catchment surface characteristic parameter (represented by 'n' in the Budyko equations) during the anthropogenic impact period. This highlights the profound impact of human-induced land alterations.
- Budyko Methods Agree on Dominant Factor: Despite slight variations in the quantitative contributions, all three Budyko methods employed in the study converge on the conclusion that subsurface (catchment surface) components are the most influential factor in Kuye River runoff variations.
Key Results
- Runoff Decline: The Kuye River Basin experienced a significant decrease in annual runoff, with a rate of 1.159 mm/decade, particularly pronounced after 1996.
- Precipitation Trends: Precipitation showed a non-significant fluctuating upward trend (1.166 mm/decade), while potential evapotranspiration exhibited a decreasing trend (2.459 mm/decade).
- Dominant Contribution of Surface Characteristics: The contribution of catchment surface characteristic parameters to runoff reduction was substantial, ranging from -96.22% (Wang and Tang) to -97.64% (Fu) and -97.47% (Choudhury and Yang).
- Climate Change Impact: The contributions of climate change factors (precipitation and potential evapotranspiration) were relatively small, with precipitation showing a slight positive contribution (around 1.26-1.30%) and potential evapotranspiration a negative contribution (around -3.63% to -5.08%).
- Increased Sensitivity: The study period, especially the anthropogenic impact period, showed increased sensitivity of runoff to precipitation, potential evapotranspiration, and catchment surface characteristic parameters, indicating a more reactive hydrological system.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Observational Uncertainty: Meteorological station data may have inherent uncertainties, and interpolation of precipitation and potential evapotranspiration data might deviate from actual distributions.
- Unaccounted Factors: The presence of silt dams and man-made water extraction projects in the Kuye River Basin could introduce assessment errors. The authors suggest that these factors should be included in future studies.
- Model Simplifications: While Budyko methods are powerful, they are simplifications of complex hydrological processes. The study's reliance on these models means that the results are subject to their inherent assumptions.
Future work could focus on incorporating the impact of water extraction projects and silt dams into the attribution analysis. Further investigation into the specific land use changes and their detailed impact on hydrological processes would also be valuable.
Summary updated