Abstract
Adaptive behavior usually requires accurate representations of body positions and ownership, which rely on integration of multiple sources of sensory information. The rubber hand illusion (RHI) presents a compelling example demonstrating that the combination of visual and tactile signals strongly influences the subjective experience of body ownership. However, it still remains unclear how the perception of body ownership in turn alters other aspects of sensory processing, such as pain perception. In the present study, we examined whether the RHI could modulate the subjective experience of pain. We set three conditions corresponding to different levels of ownership of the rubber hand: the synchronous condition in which the rubber and the real hand were simultaneously stroked; the asynchronous condition in which the two hands were asynchronously stroked; the own-hand-only condition in which only the real hand was stroked. Results from the screening experiment indicated that subjects experienced the stronger RHI in the synchronous condition, compared with the strength of RHI in the other two conditions. In the main experiment, subjects were requested to report the intensity and unpleasantness of pain evoked by laser stimuli under the three stroking conditions. Results showed that pain ratings were significantly lower under the synchronous condition than those under the other two conditions, suggesting the RHI could induce a significant analgesic effect. Furthermore, the correlation analysis showed that the degree of the analgesic effect was positively correlated with the RHI strength across individuals. Taken together, these results suggest an analgesic effect of the RHI and support the potential usage of visual illusions in future translational research on pain.
Introduction
How we perceive our own bodies is a complex integration of visual, tactile, and proprioceptive signals in the brain. The Rubber Hand Illusion (RHI) is a classic tool used to study this: by stroking a visible rubber hand and a participant's hidden real hand simultaneously, the brain eventually "claims" the rubber hand as its own. While it is known that the RHI can change skin temperature and touch sensitivity, its effect on pain perception has been historically controversial. Previous studies yielded inconsistent results, often due to experimental limitations like using slow-acting thermal heat pads or failing to account for individual susceptibility to the illusion. This study aims to clarify this relationship using an optimized experimental design.
Methods
The researchers employed several technical improvements to ensure high-quality data. First, they conducted a screening experiment with 33 volunteers, proceeding only with the 27 who reported a robust illusion. Second, they utilized a non-contact infrared laser for pain delivery. This allowed for near-instantaneous stimulation without the tactile "clutter" of a physical device, which can break the illusion.
Participants were tested under three experimental conditions:
- Synchronous: Real and rubber hands stroked at the same time (induces RHI).
- Asynchronous: Hands stroked out of sync (control; weakens RHI).
- Own-hand-only: Only the real hand is stroked (control; no RHI).
Participants rated both pain intensity (sensory magnitude) and pain unpleasantness (affective response) on a 0–100 scale, alongside a questionnaire to quantify RHI strength.
Results
Results from the screening experiment confirmed that subjects experienced a significantly stronger RHI in the synchronous condition compared to the other two controls, as evidenced by higher scores on ownership-related questions (Q1-Q3).
In the main experiment, the RHI induced a significant analgesic effect. Pain intensity ratings were significantly lower in the Synchronous condition (~42.8) compared to Asynchronous (~47.9) and Own-hand-only (~48.0) conditions ($p < 0.05$). Similarly, pain unpleasantness dropped from ~48.5 in control conditions to ~43.5 during the illusion. Crucially, a Spearman’s rank-order analysis showed a significant positive correlation ($r = 0.42, p = 0.040$) between the strength of the illusion and the degree of pain reduction; individuals who felt a more intense illusion experienced a larger drop in pain.
Discussion
The core finding is that when the brain adopts the rubber hand, it appears to "dial down" the sensory input coming from the real hand. This suggests that pain is deeply tied to our mental representation of the body. By using a laser at the exact site of the stroking, the researchers maximized the interaction between the illusory ownership and the real pain signal.
Future research is needed to determine if this effect stems from owning the rubber hand or disowning the real one. Furthermore, while this study focused on acute laser pain in healthy volunteers, these findings support the potential for visual illusions to be translated into clinical treatments for chronic pain conditions, such as complex regional pain syndrome or phantom limb pain.
Summary updated