Atrophic rhinitis: a CFD study of air conditioning in the nasal cavity

Guilherme J. M. Garcia, Neil Bailie, Dominik Cristina Martins, Julia S. KimbellJournal of Applied Physiology 2007 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses computational fluid dynamics (CFD) to investigate how airflow and moisture transport differ in the nasal cavities of atrophic rhinitis patients compared to healthy individuals. The findings suggest that abnormally wide nasal passages in atrophic rhinitis lead to inefficient air conditioning and excessive mucus evaporation, potentially explaining the chronic nature of the disease and guiding surgical interventions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Atrophic rhinitis (AR) is a chronic and debilitating nasal disease characterized by mucosal atrophy, dryness, crusting, and a peculiar sensation of nasal congestion. Despite its significant impact on patients' quality of life, the exact cause of AR remains unknown. While previous hypotheses have pointed to factors like nutritional deficiencies or bacterial infections, this paper focuses on a less explored but potentially crucial aspect: the role of nasal airflow and its impact on the nasal mucosa's ability to condition inhaled air. Specifically, the authors aim to test the hypothesis that excessive evaporation of the nasal mucus layer, driven by abnormal airflow patterns in widened nasal cavities, is a primary driver of the disease's relentless progression. Understanding these airflow dynamics is critical for developing more effective treatments, particularly surgical interventions.

Methods

The researchers employed computational fluid dynamics (CFD) to simulate airflow, heat transfer, and water transport within nasal geometries. They reconstructed the 3D nasal passages of one patient with atrophic rhinitis (before and after surgery) and four healthy individuals using CT scans. The simulations modeled steady-state inspiratory airflow at a resting rate (250 ml/s). Key aspects of their methodology include:

  • Geometry Reconstruction: CT scans were used to create detailed 3D models of the nasal cavities.
  • Meshing: The geometries were meshed with tetrahedral elements for CFD analysis.
  • Governing Equations: Standard equations for conservation of mass, momentum (laminar flow), energy (heat transfer), and convection-diffusion (moisture transport) were solved.
  • Boundary Conditions: Pressure-inlet and pressure-outlet conditions mimicked natural breathing. Specific conditions were applied for air temperature, humidity, and wall properties (e.g., 100% relative humidity at the respiratory epithelium).
  • Custom User-Defined Function: A specific function was developed within the CFD software (Fluent) to calculate water flux, a crucial metric for assessing mucus evaporation.

This approach allows for a detailed, quantitative analysis of how air interacts with the nasal lining under different physiological conditions.

Datasets

The study utilized two primary types of datasets:

  • Patient-Specific CT Scans: Computed tomography (CT) scans of a single Caucasian male diagnosed with primary atrophic rhinitis were acquired before and 6 weeks after a nasal cavity-narrowing surgical procedure. These scans provided the detailed anatomical geometry for the atrophic nose models.
  • Healthy Human Nasal Geometries: Four healthy adult human nasal geometries were derived from coronal cross-sections of hexagonal meshes previously created from MRI scans. These were selected to represent a range of nasal surface area-to-volume ratios.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing patient and healthy subject anatomical data were used for simulation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Abnormal Airflow in Atrophic Noses: The excessively wide nasal cavities in atrophic rhinitis patients lead to significantly different airflow patterns compared to healthy noses. Instead of flowing along the floor and septum, air tends to bypass these areas and flow predominantly through the upper half of the cavity, creating low-velocity eddies in the lower regions.
  • Impaired Air Conditioning: The altered airflow in atrophic noses results in less efficient warming and humidification of inspired air. The air remains cooler and less humid as it travels through the nasal passage, particularly before surgery.
  • Excessive Mucus Evaporation: The study strongly suggests that abnormal water fluxes across the nasal wall, especially in the upper regions of the cavity and on the middle turbinate, are a key factor in atrophic rhinitis. This increased evaporation likely leads to mucus drying, crust formation, and subsequent mucosal damage.
  • Surface Area-to-Volume Ratio (SAVR) Matters: The atrophic nose has a significantly lower SAVR than healthy noses. This means less surface area is available for heat and water exchange, forcing higher fluxes per unit area and exacerbating drying.
  • Surgical Goals: The CFD simulations provide a strong rationale for surgical goals: restoring the original nasal surface area, normalizing airflow distribution, and creating symmetric cavities to improve air conditioning and reduce excessive mucus evaporation.

Key Results

  • Temperature and Humidity Deficit: Before surgery, the air in the atrophic nose was 4.6-5.6°C colder than mucosal temperature at the mid-turbinate region, compared to only 1.5°C in healthy noses. Similarly, the atrophic nose achieved lower relative humidity and water content at the nasopharynx.
  • Water Flux Distribution: In healthy noses, water fluxes were concentrated in the anterior-inferior portion. In the atrophic nose, these fluxes were spread more widely, with "hot spots" in the superior cavity and on the middle turbinate.
  • Post-Surgery Improvement, Not Cure: While surgery improved the air-conditioning capacity of the atrophic nose (air was warmer and more humid at the nasopharynx), it did not fully restore normal airflow patterns or water flux distribution.
  • Left Cavity Dominance: Post-surgery, airflow became highly skewed to the left cavity (91%), leading to disproportionately high heat and water fluxes on that side, suggesting an ongoing imbalance.
  • Nasal Resistance: The atrophic nose showed lower nasal resistance pre-surgery compared to healthy noses, potentially explaining the paradoxical congestion sensation. Post-surgery, resistance increased, possibly due to surgical modifications.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Steady-State Assumption: The simulations were performed under steady-state conditions, approximating the average inspiratory cycle. The authors acknowledge that the full respiratory cycle, including exhalation's role in heat and humidity recovery, was not modeled. Future work should incorporate time-dependent simulations.
  • Laminar Flow Assumption: The study assumed laminar airflow, which is typical for resting breathing in healthy noses. However, the authors note that airflow in abnormally wide atrophic cavities might be more turbulent, which would further increase drying effects. Experimental validation of airflow patterns in physical models of atrophic noses is suggested.
  • Single Patient Study: The detailed CFD analysis was performed on a single patient with atrophic rhinitis. While this provides valuable patient-specific insights, generalizing these findings to all AR patients would require studies on larger cohorts.
  • Mucosal Temperature Dynamics: The dependence of mucosal temperature on airflow patterns was approximated. Further research is needed to fully understand these dynamics.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that future studies should investigate the full respiratory cycle, explore turbulent flow in atrophic noses, and conduct more extensive patient studies. They also highlight the importance of reconstructive nasal surgeries that aim to restore surface area, normalize airflow, and create symmetric cavities.

Summary updated

Abstract

Atrophic rhinitis is a chronic disease of the nasal mucosa. The disease is characterized by abnormally wide nasal cavities, and its main symptoms are dryness, crusting, atrophy, fetor, and a paradoxical sensation of nasal congestion. The etiology of the disease remains unknown. Here, we propose that excessive evaporation of the mucous layer is the basis for the relentless nature of this disease. Airflow and water and heat transport were simulated using computational fluid dynamics (CFD) techniques. The nasal geometry of an atrophic rhinitis patient was acquired from computed tomography scans before and after a procedure to narrow the nasal cavity. Simulations of air conditioning in the atrophic nose were compared with similar computations performed within the nasal geometries of four healthy humans. The excessively wide cavity of the patient generated abnormal flow patterns, which led to abnormal patterns of water fluxes across the wall. Geometrically, the atrophic nose had a much lower surface area than the healthy nasal passages, which increased water fluxes per unit area. Nevertheless, the simulations indicated that the atrophic nose did not condition inspired air as effectively as the healthy geometries. These simulations of water transport in the nasal cavity are consistent with the hypothesis that excessive evaporation of mucus plays a key role in the pathophysiology of atrophic rhinitis. We conclude that the main goals of a surgery to treat atrophic rhinitis should be 1) to restore the original surface area of the nose, 2) to restore the physiological airflow distribution, and 3) to create symmetric cavities.
BibTeX
@article{garcia2007atrophic,
  author = {Guilherme J. M. Garcia and Neil Bailie and DOMINIK CRISTINA MARTINS and Julia S. Kimbell},
  title = {{Atrophic rhinitis: a CFD study of air conditioning in the nasal cavity}},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Physiology},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1152/japplphysiol.01118.2006},
}
Figure