Atrazine Molecular Imprinted Polymers: Comparative Analysis by Far-Infrared and Ultraviolet Induced Polymerization

Jun Chen, Lianyang Bai, Kun‐Feng Liu, Runqiang Liu, Yuping ZhangInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper compares two methods for creating molecularly imprinted polymers (MIPs) for atrazine detection: far-infrared (FIR) and ultraviolet (UV) induced polymerization. The UV-initiated MIPs showed superior binding affinity and selectivity for atrazine, leading to higher recovery rates when used for solid-phase extraction from real water samples compared to FIR-MIPs and a commercial C18 sorbent.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Molecularly imprinted polymers (MIPs) are highly sought-after materials for selective recognition and separation due to their ability to mimic biological receptors. They are particularly useful in analytical chemistry for pre-concentrating and purifying target analytes from complex matrices like environmental water samples. However, the synthesis of MIPs can be time-consuming and energy-intensive, often relying on thermal initiation. This paper investigates whether alternative, potentially faster and more efficient, photo-initiation methods like UV radiation can produce MIPs with comparable or superior performance to traditional FIR thermal initiation for the specific application of atrazine detection. The goal is to understand how different polymerization initiation methods impact the structural and binding properties of the resulting MIPs and to identify the most effective method for atrazine extraction.

Methods

The researchers synthesized atrazine-imprinted polymers (MIPs) and non-imprinted polymers (NIPs) using two distinct polymerization initiation methods:

  • Far-Infrared (FIR) Radiation: This method involved heating the reaction mixture using an FIR heater at 65 °C for 18 hours.
  • Ultraviolet (UV) Induced Polymerization: This method utilized a UV lamp at 0 °C for 6 hours.

Both methods used the same polymer formulation: atrazine as the template molecule, methacrylic acid (MAA) as the functional monomer, ethylene glycol dimethacrylate (EDMA) as the crosslinker, and dichloromethane as the porogen. AIBN was used as the initiator for FIR, while Irgacure 1800 was used for UV.

After synthesis, the polymers were characterized using:

  • Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM): To visualize the surface morphology and pore structure.
  • Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FT-IR): To identify functional groups and potential hydrogen bonding.
  • Mercury Intrusion Porosimetry (MA): To analyze pore size distribution, total pore volume, surface area, and total porosity.

Binding experiments were conducted to evaluate the adsorption capacity and affinity of the MIPs and NIPs for atrazine. Scatchard analysis was employed to characterize the binding sites, distinguishing between high- and low-affinity sites. Selectivity was assessed by testing the MIPs against other common pesticides. Finally, the synthesized MIPs were packed into SPE cartridges and used to extract atrazine from spiked lake water samples, followed by High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC) analysis.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on the synthesis and characterization of novel materials and their application in sample preparation, rather than on training or evaluating models on existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • UV Polymerization is Faster and More Efficient: UV-induced polymerization achieved the imprinting in a significantly shorter time (6 hours) and at a lower temperature (0 °C) compared to FIR thermal initiation (18 hours at 65 °C).
  • Morphological Differences Matter: SEM images revealed distinct differences in the polymer structures produced by the two methods. MIPs generally had more pores than NIPs, but MIP$_{UV}$ exhibited smaller average pore diameters and more numerous holes compared to MIP$_{FIR}$.
  • MIP$_{UV}$ Shows Superior Binding: The UV-initiated MIPs (MIP$_{UV}$) demonstrated higher binding affinity and capacity for atrazine compared to FIR-initiated MIPs (MIP$_{FIR}$). This was evident in both equilibrium adsorption experiments and Scatchard analysis, which indicated larger dissociation constants ($K_a$) and maximum binding amounts ($Q_{max}$) for MIP$_{UV}$.
  • Heterogeneous Binding Sites: Scatchard analysis confirmed that the binding sites in both MIPs were heterogeneous, characterized by distinct high- and low-affinity populations. MIP$_{UV}$ showed better discrimination between these sites.
  • Selective Extraction Performance: When used as SPE sorbents, MIP$_{UV}$ provided higher recovery rates for atrazine from spiked lake water samples (94.4%-101.9%) compared to MIP$_{FIR}$ (90.1%-97.1%) and a commercial C18 sorbent (86.4%-94.8%). This highlights the effectiveness of UV-initiated MIPs for selective atrazine enrichment.
  • Imprinting Effect is Crucial: The imprinting factor (IF) and selectivity index (SI) values clearly demonstrated that the MIPs, regardless of the polymerization method, were significantly more selective for atrazine than their corresponding NIPs, underscoring the success of the imprinting process.

Key Results

  • Synthesis Time: UV polymerization was 3 times faster than FIR polymerization.
  • Binding Capacity: MIP$_{UV}$ exhibited higher binding capacity for atrazine, with larger $K_a$ and $Q_{max}$ values for both high- and low-affinity sites compared to MIP$_{FIR}$. For example, the high-affinity $Q_{max1}$ for MIP$_{UV}$ was 49.25 µmol/g, while for MIP$_{FIR}$ it was 35.70 µmol/g.
  • Selectivity: While both MIPs showed good selectivity for atrazine, MIP$_{UV}$ generally yielded higher selectivity index (SI) values, indicating better discrimination against other tested pesticides.
  • SPE Recovery: Average recovery rates for atrazine from spiked lake water were: MIP$_{UV}$ (94.4%-101.9%), MIP$_{FIR}$ (90.1%-97.1%), and commercial C18 (86.4%-94.8%). MIP$_{UV}$-SPE achieved the highest and most consistent recoveries.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Template Range: The study focused solely on atrazine. While other triazines were tested for selectivity, the primary imprinting was for atrazine. Future work could explore MIPs for other related compounds or mixtures.
  • Real Sample Complexity: While lake water was used, the complexity of real-world environmental samples can vary. Further validation with a wider range of complex matrices might be beneficial.
  • Optimization of FIR: The FIR polymerization was conducted at 65°C for 18 hours. Further optimization of FIR parameters (temperature, time, power) might yield improved results, though UV polymerization already demonstrated superiority in this study.
  • Mechanism of Differences: While structural differences were observed via SEM and porosity analysis, a deeper mechanistic understanding of why UV polymerization leads to better binding and selectivity could be explored. This might involve more detailed spectroscopic analysis or computational modeling.
  • Scalability: The paper describes laboratory-scale synthesis. Investigating the scalability of the UV-initiated MIP synthesis for industrial or larger-scale applications would be a logical next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

Atrazine molecular imprinted polymers (MIPs) were comparatively synthesized using identical polymer formulation by far-infrared (FIR) radiation and ultraviolet (UV)-induced polymerization, respectively. Equilibrium binding experiments were carried out with the prepared MIPs; the results showed that MIP(uv) possessed specific binding to atrazine compared with their MIP(FIR) radiation counterparts. Scatchard plot's of both MIPs indicated that the affinities of the binding sites in MIPs are heterogeneous and can be approximated by two dissociation-constants corresponding to the high- and low-affinity binding sites. Moreover, several common pesticides including atrazine, cyromazine, metamitron, simazine, ametryn, terbutryn were tested to determine their specificity, similar imprinting factor (IF) and different selectivity index (SI) for both MIPs. Physical characterization of the polymers revealed that the different polymerization methods led to slight differences in polymer structures and performance by scanning electron microscope (SEM), Fourier transform infrared absorption (FT-IR), and mercury analyzer (MA). Finally, both MIPs were used as selective sorbents for solid phase extraction (SPE) of atrazine from lake water, followed by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) analysis. Compared with commercial C18 SPE sorbent (86.4%-94.8%), higher recoveries of atrazine in spiked lake water were obtained in the range of 90.1%-97.1% and 94.4%-101.9%, for both MIPs, respectively.
BibTeX
@article{chen2014atrazine,
  author = {Jun Chen and Lianyang Bai and Kun‐Feng Liu and Runqiang Liu and Yuping Zhang},
  title = {{Atrazine Molecular Imprinted Polymers: Comparative Analysis by Far-Infrared and Ultraviolet Induced Polymerization}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms15010574},
}
Figure