Abstract
We study the effects of phonons on the tunneling of an atom between two surfaces. In contrast to an atom tunneling in the bulk, the phonons couple very strongly and qualitatively change the tunneling behavior. This is the first example of Ohmic coupling from phonons for a two-state system. We propose an experiment in which an atom tunnels from the tip of an scanning-tunneling microscope, and show how its behavior would be similar to the macroscopic quantum coherence behavior predicted for SQUIDs. The ability to tune and calculate many parameters would lead to detailed tests of the standard theories.
Introduction
In quantum mechanics, no system is truly isolated; every particle interacts with its surrounding environment, often referred to as a "bath." This interaction typically leads to decoherence or dissipation, where the quantum properties of the system are dampened by its surroundings. While the physics of atoms tunneling through bulk solids is well-established, tunneling between surfaces—such as an atom moving from a scanning-tunneling microscope (STM) tip to a sample—presents a fundamentally different regime.
This paper addresses why the environment affects surface tunneling so much more drastically than bulk tunneling. In the bulk, phonons (lattice vibrations) usually only provide a minor renormalization of the tunneling rate. However, at a surface, the coupling becomes so intense that it can fundamentally alter the particle's motion, shifting it from coherent oscillation to total localization.
Theoretical Framework: Monopoles and Ohmic Dissipation
The authors utilize a two-state Hamiltonian coupled to a bath of harmonic oscillators to model the tunneling atom. The core physical insight lies in the nature of the force exerted by the tunneling atom on the substrate.
In a bulk material, a defect or tunneling atom exerts a dipole force, where the displacement of surrounding atoms ($q_k$) scales as $k^{-1}$. At a surface, however, the geometry dictates that the atom exerts a monopole force, causing the displacement to scale as $k^{-2}$. This $k^{-2}$ scaling leads to an infrared divergence in the calculation of the "Frank-Condon factor"—the overlap between the initial and final states of the lattice.
This divergence is the signature of Ohmic dissipation. In this regime, the environmental coupling is proportional to the frequency, a phenomenon previously thought to be the exclusive domain of electrons in metals or macroscopic systems like Superconducting Quantum Interference Devices (SQUIDs). This work represents the first identification of phonons causing an "overlap catastrophe" (Anderson’s overlap catastrophe), where the environment's state changes so significantly that the quantum transition is effectively blocked.
The STM as a Tunable Quantum Laboratory
A significant contribution of this work is the proposal of the STM/AFM setup as a highly controllable experimental platform. Unlike previous studies of Macroscopic Quantum Coherence (MQC), an STM allows researchers to physically manipulate the system in real-time. By varying the tip-sample distance and the bias voltage, experimentalists can "tune" both the tunneling amplitude ($\Delta$) and the coupling strength ($\alpha$).
The $\alpha = 1/2$ Crossover
The authors predict a qualitative shift in behavior based on the coupling strength $\alpha$:
- If $\alpha < 1/2$: The tunneling rate decreases as temperature rises.
- If $\alpha > 1/2$: The tunneling rate increases with temperature.
When $\alpha$ reaches 1, the tunneling is predicted to stop entirely at zero temperature, a state of total localization where the atom is "frozen" in place by its environment.
Key Results and Material Predictions
The paper provides concrete calculations for specific material systems to demonstrate experimental feasibility:
- Critical Force for Localization: To reach the critical coupling $\alpha = 1$, the force change ($\Delta F$) required is approximately 3 nN for Tungsten (W) and 0.3 nN for Lead (Pb). These values are well within the detection and manipulation limits of modern Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM).
- Renormalized Tunneling: The authors derive a formula for the renormalized tunneling element $\Delta_r$, which vanishes as $\alpha$ approaches 1.
- Power-Law Temperature Dependence: In the incoherent regime, the tunneling rate is predicted to follow a specific power law: $\tau^{-1} \propto T^{2\alpha-1}$.
- Xenon on Nickel: Using Xe on Ni(110) as a model, the authors suggest that an STM could measure these quantum oscillations if the tunneling rate is near 10 GHz, a speed achievable using advanced picosecond laser pulse techniques.
Limitations and Future Directions
While the model is robust, the authors acknowledge several areas for further refinement:
- Tip Phonons: The current model simplifies the system by ignoring phonons within the microscope tip itself, though these would likely increase the total coupling.
- Electron-Hole Pairs: In metallic substrates, electron-hole pairs contribute to dissipation alongside phonons. While this is avoided in insulators, it adds complexity to metallic experiments.
- Measurement Back-action: A perennial challenge in quantum mechanics is whether the act of measurement destroys the coherence being studied. The authors argue that a "sizable window" exists for non-invasive measurement in this setup, but this remains a primary experimental hurdle.
Ultimately, this microscopic system provides a unique opportunity to test the standard theories of dissipative quantum mechanics, potentially shedding light on the more complex problem of observing quantum coherence in macroscopic systems.
Summary updated