Atomic-Scale Friction on Monovacancy-Defective Graphene and Single-Layer Molybdenum-Disulfide by Numerical Analysis

Haosheng Pang, Hongfa Wang, Minglin Li, Chenghui GaoNanomaterials 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses numerical simulations to investigate atomic-scale friction on defective 2D materials (graphene and MoS2 with missing atoms). They found that these "vacancy defects" significantly increase friction and that the spring constant of the simulated tip is the most crucial factor influencing stick-slip behavior, with softer tips being better for observing these phenomena.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding friction at the atomic scale is crucial for developing advanced nanomechanical devices and for fundamental science. While techniques like Lateral Force Microscopy (LFM) allow us to probe this, real-world surfaces are rarely perfect. Defects, such as missing atoms (vacancies), are common in 2D materials like graphene and MoS2 and can drastically alter their frictional properties. Previous studies often focused on ideal, defect-free surfaces or used molecular dynamics simulations with very high tip speeds, which don't reflect typical experimental conditions. Furthermore, the influence of key parameters in atomic-scale friction models, like the tip's spring constant, on these defective surfaces remained unclear. This paper aims to bridge this gap by numerically simulating friction on monovacancy-defective graphene and MoS2, exploring the impact of defects and model parameters under more realistic conditions.

Methods

The researchers employed a numerical simulation approach based on the classical Prandtl–Tomlinson (PT) model. This model simplifies atomic-scale friction by treating the tip as a point mass connected to a support by a spring, sliding over a corrugated surface potential.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Modified Interaction Potential: They developed a new tip-surface interaction potential that accounts for the Schwoebel–Ehrlich barrier. This barrier is known to influence friction at surface steps and is relevant near vacancy defects due to altered atomic coordination. This potential was derived by fitting a Lennard-Jones (LJ) potential and incorporating a long-range interaction term.
  • Classical PT Model: The core of the simulation uses the PT model equations to describe the tip's motion, including forces from the pulling spring, damping, and the tip-surface interaction potential.
  • Parameter Variation: A systematic analysis was performed by varying key PT model parameters: effective mass ($m_x$), damping ($\gamma_x$), sliding velocity ($V_m$), and the pulling spring constant ($c_x$). This allowed them to understand how each parameter affects frictional forces and stick-slip behavior.
  • Numerical Simulation Software: The simulations were carried out using Mathematica.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on numerical simulations based on established physical models and parameters derived from literature and experimental conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Defects Amplify Friction: The presence of a monovacancy defect significantly enhances both the tip-surface potential and the frictional forces, particularly in the immediate vicinity of the defect. This is attributed to the altered atomic structure and the Schwoebel-Ehrlich barrier effect.
  • Stick-Slip Sensitivity Varies: Monovacancy-defective MoS2 exhibits more pronounced stick-slip motion compared to monovacancy-defective graphene. This difference is linked to the MoS2's more complex three-layer-sandwiched atomic structure and a higher curvature of its tip-surface interaction potential at the defect site.
  • Spring Constant is King: The spring constant of the pulling spring ($c_x$) is identified as the most influential parameter governing stick-slip behavior near vacancy defects. This suggests that the stiffness of the tip itself plays a critical role in observing these phenomena.
  • Soft Tips for Stick-Slip: A soft tip (low spring constant) is ideal for observing stick-slip behaviors on monovacancy-defective surfaces. Conversely, stiff tips are more suited for studying low-dissipative or superlubricity regimes.
  • Damping and Velocity Have Less Impact: While damping and sliding velocity do affect the magnitude of frictional forces, they have a less pronounced impact on the stick-slip motion itself compared to the spring constant.

Key Results

  • Enhanced Frictional Forces: The simulations showed a clear increase in frictional forces around the monovacancy defect for both graphene and MoS2.
  • Stick-Slip in MoS2, Not Graphene: Stick-slip motion was observed in monovacancy-defective MoS2 but was largely absent in monovacancy-defective graphene. The tip in graphene showed a periodic acceleration-deceleration motion, similar to stick-slip but without the distinct "stick" phase.
  • Critical Spring Constants: The study identified critical spring constants for both materials. For graphene, the critical $c_x$ was 0.91 N/m, and for MoS2, it was 17.18 N/m. Stick-slip occurs when the pulling spring constant is less than or equal to these critical values.
  • Parameter Influence Ranking: The spring constant ($c_x$) was found to have the most significant impact on stick-slip behavior, followed by effective mass ($m_x$), damping ($\gamma_x$), and sliding velocity ($V_m$).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Temperature Ignored: The classical PT model used in this study does not account for temperature. The authors acknowledge that temperature can influence thermally activated jumps and suppress stick-slip, suggesting that future work should incorporate temperature effects.
  • MoS2 Charge State: The paper briefly mentions that MoS2 can be charged, which might affect stick-slip motions around vacancy defects. However, the interaction between an LFM tip and a charged MoS2 vacancy defect remains unclear and is proposed as a topic for future research.
  • Chirality: While the study explored friction along the zigzag (ZZ) and armchair (AC) orientations, the results for AC orientation were similar to ZZ and are presented in supplementary materials. A deeper dive into chirality's specific influence could be a future direction.
  • Experimental Validation: The study provides valuable theoretical insights that can complement experimental and MD simulations. Further experimental validation of these findings would be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

Using numerical simulations, we study the atomic-scale frictional behaviors of monovacancy-defective graphene and single-layer molybdenum-disulfide (SLMoS2) based on the classical Prandtl–Tomlinson (PT) model with a modified interaction potential considering the Schwoebel–Ehrlich barrier. Due to the presence of a monovacancy defect on the surface, the frictional forces were significantly enhanced. The effects of the PT model parameters on the frictional properties of monovacancy-defective graphene and SLMoS2 were analyzed, and it showed that the spring constant of the pulling spring cx is the most influential parameter on the stick–slip motion in the vicinity of the vacancy defect. Besides, monovacancy-defective SLMoS2 is found to be more sensitive to the stick–slip motion at the vacancy defect site than monovacancy-defective graphene, which can be attributed to the complicated three-layer-sandwiched atomic structure of SLMoS2. The result suggests that the soft tip with a small spring constant can be an ideal candidate for the observation of stick–slip behaviors of the monovacancy-defective surface. This study can fill the gap in atomic-scale friction experiments and molecular dynamics simulations of 2D materials with vacancy-related defects.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pang2020atomic,
  author = {Haosheng Pang and Hongfa Wang and Minglin Li and Chenghui Gao},
  title = {{Atomic-Scale Friction on Monovacancy-Defective Graphene and Single-Layer Molybdenum-Disulfide by Numerical Analysis}},
  booktitle = {Nanomaterials},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/nano10010087},
}

Loading related content...

Figure