TL;DR
This paper introduces a new "symmetry indicator" that simplifies the identification of topological superconductors, particularly those with higher-order topological properties. This indicator relies only on the normal-state electronic band structure and the symmetry of the superconducting order parameter, making it readily applicable to first-principles calculations.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Topological superconductors (TSCs) are fascinating materials that host exotic excitations like Majorana modes, which are crucial for fault-tolerant quantum computing. However, identifying these materials experimentally and theoretically has been challenging. While symmetry indicators have been successful in classifying topological insulators, extending this approach to superconductors is complicated by the nature of their electronic description (Bogoliubov-de-Gennes Hamiltonians) and the lack of a clear "atomic limit" analogous to insulators. This paper addresses this gap by defining a suitable atomic limit for superconductors and developing a robust symmetry indicator for inversion-symmetric TSCs in symmetry classes D and DIII, including higher-order topological phases.
Methods
The core of this work lies in defining a novel "atomic limit" for superconductors. Unlike insulators where an atomic limit corresponds to localized Wannier orbitals without overlap, for superconductors, it's defined by a Bogoliubov-de-Gennes (BdG) Hamiltonian where the superconducting gap parameter ($\Delta_k$) is vanishingly small, but the normal-state band structure is still well-defined and can be adiabatically connected to the original superconducting state without closing the bulk gap.
Using this atomic limit, the authors derive a $Z_{2^d}$-valued symmetry indicator, denoted as $\kappa_{\alpha,\xi}$, for $d$-dimensional inversion-symmetric superconductors in classes D and DIII. This indicator quantifies the difference in the number of irreducible representations of occupied BdG bands between the superconducting state at the Fermi energy and the defined atomic limit. The indicator can be further decomposed into $Z_2$ indices ($v_{d,n,\xi}$) that specifically identify higher-order topological phases characterized by hinge or corner Majorana modes. The paper also uses surface Dirac theories to elucidate the bulk-boundary correspondence of these higher-order phases.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The methodology is based on theoretical calculations and does not rely on specific experimental datasets for training or evaluation.
Key Insights and Ideas
- A Universal Atomic Limit for Superconductors: The paper successfully defines a physically meaningful "atomic limit" for superconductors, which is crucial for extending symmetry indicator approaches. This limit is based on the normal-state band structure and a vanishing superconducting gap.
- Higher-Order Topological Superconductors are Accessible: The derived symmetry indicator not only identifies first-order topological phases but also provides a clear way to detect higher-order topological superconductors (HOTSCs) with hinge and corner Majorana modes.
- First-Principles Ready: The indicator requires only the normal-state band structure and the symmetry of the order parameter, making it directly applicable to materials discovered through first-principles calculations (like Density Functional Theory). This significantly aids in the search for new TSC materials.
- Refined Topological Classification: The $Z_{2^d}$ nature of the indicator allows for a more refined classification of topological phases, going beyond simple $Z_2$ or $Z$ invariants.
Key Results
The paper introduces a $Z_{2^d}$-valued symmetry indicator $\kappa_{\alpha,\xi}$ for inversion-symmetric superconductors in classes D and DIII. This indicator is shown to correctly classify topological phases, including higher-order topological superconductors. The paper demonstrates how this indicator can be decomposed into indices $v_{d,n,\xi}$ that specifically identify:
- $v_{d,1,\xi}=1$: first-order topological phases.
- $v_{2,2,D}=1$: second-order TSCs with corner Majorana modes in class D.
- $v_{2,2,DIII}=1$: second-order TSCs with Kramers pairs of Majorana corner modes in class DIII.
- $v_{3,2,DIII}=1$: third-order TSCs with helical hinge Majoranas in class DIII.
- $v_{3,3,DIII}=1$: third-order TSCs with corner Majorana modes in class DIII.
The paper also provides theoretical constructions of surface Dirac theories to illustrate the bulk-boundary correspondence for these higher-order phases.
Limitations and Future Work
The paper focuses on inversion-symmetric superconductors and symmetry classes D and DIII. While the approach is generalizable to other spatial symmetries, this specific work is limited to inversion. The authors suggest that their framework can be extended to other spatial symmetries beyond inversion. Additionally, the paper acknowledges that cases where $d=n$ (e.g., 1D second-order TSC) are not fully captured by a pure BdG formulation, hinting at potential areas for further investigation. The application of this indicator to real materials using first-principles calculations is a natural next step.
Summary updated