Atomic force microscopy study of the antigen‐antibody binding force on patient cancer cells based on ROR1 fluorescence recognition

Mi Li, Xiubin Xiao, Lianqing Liu, Ning Xi, Yuechao Wang, Zaili Dong, Weijing ZhangJournal of Molecular Recognition 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel approach using Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) to measure the binding force between the cancer drug rituximab and its target CD20 directly on patient lymphoma cells. By employing ROR1 fluorescence to specifically identify cancer cells, the researchers overcome the limitations of studying drug-target interactions on artificial cell lines, paving the way for personalized cancer treatment strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how drugs interact with their targets at a molecular level is crucial for developing effective treatments. However, traditional methods often rely on bulk measurements, obscuring the behavior of individual molecules and cells. While Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) has emerged as a powerful tool for single-molecule force spectroscopy (SMFS), most studies have been conducted on cell lines grown in vitro. This artificial environment can significantly alter cell behavior compared to their in vivo state. For personalized medicine, it's essential to study these interactions directly on patient-derived cells to understand individual responses and potential drug resistance. This paper addresses the challenge of accurately measuring drug-target binding forces on actual patient cancer cells, specifically focusing on rituximab's interaction with CD20 in lymphoma.

Methods

The core technique employed is Single-Molecule Force Spectroscopy (SMFS) using an Atomic Force Microscope (AFM). Here's a breakdown of their approach:

  • Tip Functionalization: Rituximab, the therapeutic antibody, was chemically attached to the tip of the AFM probe. This was achieved using linker molecules (NHS-PEG2000-MAL) to ensure stable and specific attachment.
  • ROR1 Fluorescence Labeling: To distinguish cancer cells from normal cells in patient samples, ROR1, a specific marker for B-cell lymphomas, was targeted. Cells were incubated with a primary antibody against ROR1, followed by a fluorescently labeled secondary antibody (FITC-conjugated). This allowed for visualization of cancer cells under fluorescence microscopy.
  • AFM Imaging and Force Measurement:
    • Cell Identification: The ROR1-labeled cancer cells were first identified using fluorescence microscopy.
  • AFM Imaging: Under the guidance of fluorescence, the AFM probe was used to image the morphology of the identified cancer cells in contact mode.
  • Force Curve Acquisition: The AFM was then switched to force measurement mode. The functionalized tip was brought into contact with the cell surface, and then retracted. The force required to break the bond between rituximab on the tip and CD20 on the cell surface was measured as a "force curve."
  • Control Experiments:
    • Cell Lines: Experiments were first validated on a B-cell lymphoma cell line (Raji) known to express ROR1.
  • Blocking Experiments: To confirm the specificity of the binding, free rituximab was added to block CD20 sites on the cell surface before performing force measurements.
  • Normal Cells: Force curves were also obtained on normal cells from the patient sample to measure non-specific binding.
  • Tip Functionalization Verification: The functionalization of the AFM tip with rituximab was confirmed using fluorescence labeling.

Datasets

The study utilized two types of biological samples:

  • Raji cells: A B-cell lymphoma cell line used for initial method validation.
  • Pathological samples: Bone marrow samples from a follicular lymphoma patient, containing both cancer cells and normal cells.

No new computational datasets or benchmarks were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the in vitro - in vivo Gap: The most significant contribution is the successful application of AFM-SMFS directly on patient cancer cells, moving beyond the limitations of cell line studies. This provides a more clinically relevant understanding of drug-target interactions.
  • ROR1 as a Reliable Cancer Cell Identifier: The use of ROR1 fluorescence labeling proved effective in specifically identifying and localizing cancer cells within mixed patient samples, enabling targeted force measurements.
  • Direct Measurement of Drug-Target Binding Force: The study demonstrates the feasibility of quantifying the precise binding force between rituximab and CD20 on patient cells, offering a potential biomarker for treatment response.
  • Specificity of Binding: Blocking experiments confirmed that the measured binding forces were indeed specific to the CD20-rituximab interaction, not due to non-specific adhesion.
  • Potential for Personalized Medicine: The ability to measure these forces on individual patient cells opens doors for predicting drug efficacy and tailoring treatment strategies, potentially avoiding unnecessary costs and ineffective therapies.

Key Results

  • ROR1 Expression Confirmed: Both Raji cells and patient lymphoma cells were confirmed to express ROR1 via fluorescence labeling.
  • CD20-Rituximab Binding Force Measured: The AFM-SMFS technique successfully measured the binding force between CD20 on patient cancer cells and rituximab.
  • Specific Binding Force: The average CD20-rituximab binding force on cancer cells was found to be 57 ± 28 pN.
  • Nonspecific Binding Force: The nonspecific binding force on normal cells was significantly lower, measured at 21 ± 7 pN.
  • Binding Probability: The specific molecular binding probability was approximately 30% (51 specific binding events out of 169 force curves).
  • Loading Rate Dependence: The binding force showed a linear relationship with the logarithm of the loading rate, consistent with the Bell-Evans model for molecular unbinding.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Sample Size: The study was performed on a single patient's bone marrow sample.
  • Variability in Binding Force: While a mean binding force was determined, there was significant variation (± 28 pN), which the authors attribute to the random orientation of binding partners.
  • Future Work: The authors propose to extend this methodology to measure CD20-rituximab binding forces on patient cancer cells from a larger cohort of B-cell lymphoma patients. The ultimate goal is to establish a relationship between this binding force and rituximab efficacy, potentially developing a biomarker to predict which patients will benefit from targeted therapy. This could lead to more personalized and cost-effective treatment strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Knowledge of drug-target interaction is critical to our understanding of drug action and can help design better drugs. Due to the lack of adequate single-molecule techniques, the information of individual interactions between ligand-receptors is scarce until the advent of atomic force microscopy (AFM) that can be used to directly measure the individual ligand-receptor forces under near-physiological conditions by linking ligands onto the surface of the AFM tip and then obtaining force curves on cells. Most of the current AFM single-molecule force spectroscopy experiments were performed on cells grown in vitro (cell lines) that are quite different from the human cells in vivo. From the view of clinical practice, investigating the drug-target interactions directly on the patient cancer cells will bring more valuable knowledge that may potentially serve as an important parameter in personalized treatment. Here, we demonstrate the capability of AFM to measure the binding force between target (CD20) and drug (rituximab, an anti-CD20 monoclonal antibody targeted drug) directly on lymphoma patient cancer cells under the assistance of ROR1 fluorescence recognition. ROR1 is a receptor expressed on some B-cell lymphomas but not on normal cells. First, B-cell lymphoma Raji cells (a cell line) were used for ROR1 fluorescence labeling and subsequent measurement of CD20-rituximab binding force. The results showed that Raji cells expressed ROR1, and the labeling of ROR1 did not influence the measurement of CD20-rituximab binding force. Then the established experimental procedures were performed on the pathological samples prepared from the bone marrow of a follicular lymphoma patient. Cancer cells were recognized by ROR1 fluorescence. Under the guidance of fluorescence, with the use of a rituximab-conjugated tip, the cellular topography was visualized by using AFM imaging and the CD20-Rituximab binding force was measured by single-molecule force spectroscopy.
BibTeX
@article{li2013atomic,
  author = {Mi Li and Xiubin Xiao and Lianqing Liu and Ning Xi and Yuechao Wang and Zaili Dong and Weijing Zhang},
  title = {{Atomic force microscopy study of the antigen‐antibody binding force on patient cancer cells based on ROR1 fluorescence recognition}},
  journal = {Journal of Molecular Recognition},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1002/jmr.2287},
}
Figure