ATAC‐seq exposes differences in chromatin accessibility leading to distinct leaf shapes in mulberry

Lei Wang, Yuming Feng, Jiangying Wang, Xin Jin, Qiaonan Zhang, Michael Ackah, Yuhua Wang, Dayong Xu, Weiguo ZhaoPlant 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses ATAC-seq to investigate the molecular basis of distinct leaf shapes in mulberry, revealing differences in chromatin accessibility that are linked to specific transcription factors, particularly the TCP family. These findings offer insights into the genetic regulation of leaf morphology, crucial for improving mulberry germplasm and agricultural yield.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Mulberry leaf shape is a key agronomic trait influencing yield and development, yet the regulatory mechanisms behind its variation, especially the development of heteromorphic leaves (like whole vs. lobed leaves) from the same genetic background, are not well understood. While previous research has explored leaf development and growth, the specific epigenetic factors controlling leaf shape differences in mulberry have remained largely unexamined. This paper aims to bridge this knowledge gap by identifying the transcription factors (TFs) responsible for these distinct leaf morphologies.

Methods

The core technique employed is ATAC-seq (Assay for Transposase Accessible Chromatin using sequencing). This method identifies regions of open chromatin, which are generally associated with active regulatory elements and gene transcription. The ATAC-seq libraries were prepared from two groups of mulberry leaves: whole leaves (CK) and lobed leaves (HL), each with two biological replicates.

Key analytical steps included:

  • Read alignment and peak calling: Standard bioinformatics pipelines were used to align sequencing reads to the reference genome and identify accessible chromatin regions (peaks).
  • Peak-related gene annotation: Genes located near these accessible regions were identified.
  • Gene Ontology (GO) and KEGG pathway enrichment analysis: To understand the biological functions and pathways associated with genes near open chromatin regions.
  • Motif analysis: Using MEME-suite, the researchers searched for transcription factor binding motifs within the identified open chromatin regions to predict regulatory elements.
  • Differential analysis: Comparing peaks and associated genes between the CK and HL groups to identify regions and TFs specifically associated with leaf shape differences.
  • Transcription factor validation: Key identified TFs were validated using quantitative Reverse Transcription Polymerase Chain Reaction (qRT-PCR).

Datasets

The study utilized two types of mulberry leaves:

  • Whole leaves (CK-1 and CK-2): Representing a standard leaf morphology.
  • Lobed leaves (HL-1 and HL-2): Representing a distinct, lobed leaf morphology.

These samples were collected from Morus alba Pendula. The ATAC-seq data generated from these samples forms the primary dataset for the study. No external benchmark datasets were explicitly mentioned for comparison beyond the internal comparisons between the CK and HL groups.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Chromatin accessibility as a driver of leaf shape: The study demonstrates that differences in chromatin accessibility, as revealed by ATAC-seq, are directly linked to the distinct leaf shapes observed in mulberry. This highlights the importance of epigenetic regulation in morphological variation.
  • TCP family TFs are key players: The research strongly implicates the TCP family of transcription factors as crucial regulators of leaf shape in mulberry. These TFs are known to be involved in plant development and growth, and their enrichment in specific leaf types suggests a direct role in shaping leaf morphology.
  • Differential TF binding sites reveal regulatory differences: By comparing accessible regions between whole and lobed leaves, the study identified specific TF binding sites that are differentially utilized, providing a molecular basis for the distinct leaf phenotypes.
  • ATAC-seq as a powerful tool for plant morphology studies: The successful application of ATAC-seq in this context showcases its utility for dissecting the genetic and epigenetic underpinnings of complex plant traits like leaf shape.

Key Results

  • The ATAC-seq analysis identified thousands of open chromatin regions in mulberry leaves.
  • Motif analysis revealed enrichment of specific transcription factor binding motifs, with a notable emphasis on the TCP family.
  • Differential analysis between whole (CK) and lobed (HL) leaves showed distinct patterns of chromatin accessibility, suggesting different regulatory landscapes.
  • qRT-PCR validation confirmed the differential expression of several key transcription factors, including members of the TCP family, between the CK and HL groups, supporting the ATAC-seq findings. For example, Figure 8 shows that several TFs, including TCP19, TCP20, TCP23, and TCP7, were more highly represented in the CK group (whole leaves) compared to the HL group (lobed leaves).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Correlation vs. Causation: While the study identifies correlations between chromatin accessibility, TF motifs, and leaf shape, it acknowledges the need for further functional studies to definitively establish causal relationships.
  • Limited sample size for validation: Although qRT-PCR was used for validation, the study could benefit from a broader validation across more replicates or different mulberry varieties.
  • Future directions: The authors suggest that ATAC-seq can be combined with other technologies like single-cell sequencing (scATAC-seq) or RNA-seq to gain a more comprehensive understanding of gene regulation and its impact on leaf development. Further research into the specific functions of the identified TFs and their downstream targets is also warranted. The study lays the groundwork for understanding the mechanisms underlying leaf shape changes, which can aid in breeding mulberry varieties with improved traits and contribute to the sustainable development of sericulture.

Summary updated

Abstract

Mulberry leaf shape is an important agronomic trait indicating yield, growth, development, and habitat variation. China was the earliest country in the world to grow mulberry for sericulture, and it is also one of the great contributions of the Chinese nation to human civilization. ATAC-seq (Assay for Transposase Accessible Chromatin using sequencing) is a recently developed technique for genome-wide analysis of chromatin accessibility. The samples used for ATAC sequencing in this study were divided into two groups of whole leaves (CK-1 and CK-2) and lobed leaves (HL-1 and HL-2), with two replicates in each group. The related motif analysis, differential expression motif screening, and functional annotation of mulberry leaf shape differences were performed by raw letter analysis to finally obtain the transcription factors (TFs) that lead to the production of heteromorphic leaves. These transcription factors are common in plants, especially the TCP family, shown to be associated with leaf development and growth in other woody plants and are a potential transcription factor responsible for leaf shape differences in mulberry. Dissecting the regulatory mechanisms of leaf shape of different forms of mulberry leaves by ATAC-seq is an important way to protect mulberry germplasm resources and improve mulberry yield. It is conducive to cultivating mulberry varieties with high resistance to adversity, promoting the sustainable development of sericulture, and protecting and improving the ecological environment.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2022atacseq,
  author = {Lei Wang and Yuming Feng and Jiangying Wang and Xin Jin and Qiaonan Zhang and Michael Ackah and Yuhua Wang and Dayong Xu and Weiguo Zhao},
  title = {{ATAC‐seq exposes differences in chromatin accessibility leading to distinct leaf shapes in mulberry}},
  booktitle = {Plant},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1002/pld3.464},
}
Figure