At-level allodynia after mid-thoracic contusion in the rat

Gary H. Blumenthal, Bharadwaj Nandakumar, Ashley K. Schnider, Megan Ryan Detloff, J. Ricard, John R. Bethea, Karen A. MoxonbioRxiv 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Chronic neuropathic pain (CNP) affects over half of individuals with spinal cord injuries (SCI), yet its underlying mechanisms remain poorly understood due to the difficulty of separating pain-specific biological changes from general injury responses. This study utilizes a rat mid-thoracic contusion model to develop a refined behavioral "pain score" that distinguishes between animals experiencing at-level tactile allodynia and those that do not. By employing a standardized grid to map behavioral responses to specific thoracic dermatomes and prioritizing supraspinal indicators—such as vocalization and avoidance—over simple spinal reflexes, the researchers identified distinct phenotypes of pain and spasticity. The results demonstrate that at-level allodynia mirrors the "girdle of pain" seen in humans and is not predicted by the extent of spinal tissue damage, providing a robust framework for isolating the mechanisms of chronic pain.

Introduction

Chronic neuropathic pain is one of the most debilitating consequences of spinal cord injury. Often described as an excruciating "girdle" of sensation around the torso, this pain is largely resistant to current treatments. To develop better therapies, researchers rely on the rat mid-thoracic contusion model. However, a significant hurdle exists: not every animal (or human) with a spinal cord injury develops chronic pain.

In research, if the "pain" group cannot be reliably separated from the "no-pain" group, it is impossible to isolate the biological mechanisms specifically responsible for pain versus those caused by the injury itself. Furthermore, many existing tests confuse simple spinal reflexes (like a leg twitch) with actual pain perception, which requires brain involvement. This study seeks to create a standardized, reproducible method to identify true at-level allodynia—pain caused by a normally non-painful touch—by focusing on supraspinal behavioral responses.

Methodology

The researchers utilized a moderate mid-thoracic (T10) contusion injury in 159 adult female Sprague Dawley rats. Their approach combined several sophisticated techniques to ensure behavioral responses were accurately categorized:

  • Standardized Grid Mapping: A 128-square grid was drawn on the rats' backs to precisely localize stimuli.
  • Electrophysiological Dermatome Mapping: By recording from dorsal root ganglions (DRGs), the researchers mapped specific grid locations to thoracic dermatomes (T1–T13), ensuring behavioral responses could be linked to specific spinal levels.
  • Supraspinal vs. Spinal Reflexes: The core innovation of this study was the distinction between supraspinal responses (vocalization, biting, avoidance)—which require the brain to process a "pain" signal—and spinal reflexes (spasticity/hindlimb extension), which are automatic and can occur without brain involvement.
  • Refined Pain Score: The researchers narrowed the grid to 40 squares most likely to show pain and determined that tracking just two behaviors—audible vocalization and avoidance—was sufficient to identify animals with allodynia.

Key Insights

The "Girdle of Pain" and Localization

The study found that at-level allodynia was localized to dermatomes T4–T11, which are at and just above the lesion site. In contrast, spasticity (involuntary leg kicks) was triggered by touching areas below the lesion (T12 and down). These two phenomena rarely overlapped in the same skin location, mirroring the "girdle" distribution of pain often reported by human SCI patients.

Temporal Dynamics

Timing was a critical factor in identifying pain phenotypes. At-level (trunk) pain emerged early, typically within the first week post-injury. Conversely, below-level (hindpaw) pain developed much later, around weeks 4 or 5. This suggests that different underlying biological mechanisms drive pain depending on its location relative to the injury.

Anatomy vs. Function

Perhaps the most surprising finding was that the amount of spared white or grey matter in the spinal cord did not correlate with whether an animal developed pain. Two rats with identical-looking lesions could have completely different pain profiles. This suggests that chronic pain is driven by functional changes, such as neuronal hyperexcitability, rather than the physical size of the injury.

Results and Prevalence

Of the injured animals, 34.18% developed allodynia in at least one region, with 23.07% specifically developing trunk (at-level) pain. Vocalization (52.7%) and avoidance (28.9%) were the most frequent indicators of pain. Using a threshold pain score of ≥5% based on these two behaviors successfully isolated the allodynia group. Additionally, there was no statistical relationship between locomotor recovery (measured by the BBB score) and the development of pain, further indicating that motor and sensory recoveries are independent processes.

Conclusion

This refined behavioral mapping provides a standardized approach to studying SCI-induced allodynia. By focusing on brain-mediated responses and precise dermatomal mapping, researchers can now better investigate the functional hyperexcitability that leads to chronic pain. This model allows for the comparison of "injured-with-pain" groups against "injured-without-pain" groups, providing a powerful tool to hunt for the specific receptors or neural circuits that turn a spinal injury into a lifetime of chronic pain.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The rat mid-thoracic contusion model has been used to study at-level tactile allodynia after spinal cord injury (SCI), one of the more common types of allodynia. An important advantage of this model is that not all animals develop allodynia and, therefore, it could be used to more clearly examine mechanisms that are strictly related to pain development separately from mechanisms related to the injury itself. However, how to separate those that develop allodynia from those that do not is unclear. The aims of the current study were to identify where allodynia and spasticity develop and use this information to identify metrics that separate animals that develop allodynia from those that do not in order study difference in their behavior. To accomplish these aims, a standardized grid was used to localize pain on the dorsal trunk and map it to thoracic dermatomes, providing for the development of a pain score that relied on supraspinal responses and separated subgroups of animals. Similar to human studies, the development of allodynia often occurred with the development of spasticity or hyperreflexia. Moreover, the time course and prevalence of pain phenotypes (at-, above-, or below level) produced by this model were similar to that observed in humans who have sustained an SCI. However, the amount of spared spinal matter in the injured cord did not explain the development of allodynia, as was previously reported. This approach can be used to study the mechanism underlying the development of allodynia separately from mechanisms related to the injury alone.
BibTeX
@misc{blumenthal2020at,
  author = {Gary H. Blumenthal and Bharadwaj Nandakumar and Ashley K. Schnider and Megan Ryan Detloff and J. Ricard and John R. Bethea and Karen A. Moxon},
  title = {{At-level allodynia after mid-thoracic contusion in the rat}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.08.10.240499},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure