Asymmetric Orbital-Lattice Interactions in Ultrathin Correlated Oxide Films

J. Chakhalian, James M. Rondinelli, Jian Liu, Benjamin Gray, M. Kareev, E. J. Moon, Narayan Prasai, J. L. Cohn, M. Varela, I‐Cheng Tung, Michael J. Bedzyk, S. G. Altendorf, F. Strigari, B. Da̧browski, L. H. Tjeng, Philip J. Ryan, J. W. FreelandPhysical 2011 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: Using resonant x-ray spectroscopies combined with density functional calculations, we find an asymmetric biaxial strain-induced d-orbital response in ultrathin films of the correlated metal LaNiO3 which are not accessible in the bulk. The sign of the misfit strain governs the stability of an octahedral "breathing" distortion, which, in turn, produces an emergent charge-ordered ground state with an altered ligand-hole density and bond covalency. Control of this new mechanism opens a pathway to rational orbital engineering, providing a platform for artificially designed Mott materials.

Introduction

In the field of complex oxides, the ability to tune electronic properties via structural manipulation is a cornerstone of quantum materials research. A primary tool for this is "epitaxial strain," where growing a thin film on a substrate with a different lattice constant forces the film's atoms into new configurations. Traditionally, this has been understood through the Symmetric Strain-Induced Orbital Polarization (SIOP) model. This model predicts that compressive and tensile strains should produce equal and opposite effects on electron orbital occupancy.

However, recent studies of ultrathin films have revealed behaviors that defy this simple symmetry. This research investigates Lanthanum Nickelate ($LaNiO_3$), a correlated metal that serves as a prototypical system for exploring these deviations. The authors demonstrate that the direction of strain—compressive versus tensile—triggers fundamentally different physical responses, uncovering a hidden "breathing" distortion that enables the creation of novel electronic phases.

Experimental Methods

To probe these effects, the research team synthesized 10-unit-cell (uc) thick films of $LaNiO_3$ (LNO) using Pulsed Laser Deposition (PLD). By selecting substrates such as $LaAlO_3$ (LAO), $SrLaGaO_4$ (SLGO), $SrTiO_3$ (STO), and $GdScO_3$ (GSO), they achieved a strain range from -1.1% (compressive) to +3.6% (tensile).

The electronic and structural properties were characterized using a suite of advanced techniques:

  • Synchrotron Spectroscopy: Ni L-edge and O K-edge X-ray Absorption Spectroscopy (XAS) and X-ray Linear Dichroism (XLD) were used to map orbital occupancy and bond covalency.
  • Transport Measurements: Hall coefficient ($R_H$) and Thermoelectric Power (TEP) measurements provided insight into charge carrier dynamics.
  • Theoretical Modeling: Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations (LSDA+U) were employed to simulate the atomic structures and validate the stability of observed distortions.

The Asymmetry of Strain and the Breathing Distortion

The core discovery of this work is the breakdown of the SIOP model under tensile strain. While compressive strain (on LAO) behaves as expected—maintaining the metallic state and following standard orbital splitting rules—tensile strain (on STO) induces a symmetry-breaking structural change.

Ni L-edge XAS and XLD spectra for LNO films under different strain states, illustrating the asymmetric orbital response and the 'breathing' distortion schematic.

As shown in Figure 1, the XLD signal, which measures orbital polarization, nearly vanishes for films under tensile strain on STO. This is a "smoking gun" for a structural transition that overrides simple orbital splitting. Instead of the $NiO_6$ octahedra simply flattening or elongating, they undergo a "breathing" distortion. In this state, the octahedra disproportionate: half shrink while the other half expand. This structural instability, latent in the bulk material, is stabilized and amplified in the ultrathin film limit.

Emergent Electronic States and Transport Properties

This breathing distortion has profound consequences for the material's electronic ground state. The structural disproportionation leads to charge ordering, where different Nickel sites (Ni1 and Ni2) adopt different effective charges. This process opens a small energy gap (~0.10 eV), effectively transforming the metallic LNO into a semiconductor.

Transport properties of 10uc LNO films, showing the Hall coefficient and thermopower as a function of lattice mismatch and temperature.

Transport data in Figure 2 confirms this transition. Under compressive strain, the material remains metallic with a high carrier density. However, as the lattice mismatch moves into the tensile regime, the Hall coefficient ($1/R_H$) drops significantly, and the thermopower ($S$) exhibits a distinct temperature dependence compared to the metallic bulk and compressive films. Furthermore, O K-edge spectroscopy revealed that strain directly modulates the ligand-hole density at a rate of 100 meV per percent of lattice misfit, providing a precise knob for controlling bond covalency.

Conclusion and Outlook

This study demonstrates that the thin-film environment can be used to access "latent" structural instabilities that are inaccessible in bulk crystals. By breaking the symmetry of the strain response, researchers have uncovered a new mechanism for orbital engineering: the stabilization of octahedral breathing distortions.

These findings suggest that asymmetric orbital-lattice interactions may be a universal feature in correlated oxides. Leveraging this mechanism offers a pathway to design "Mott transistors" and other quantum electronic devices that rely on precisely triggered phase transitions. Future research will likely focus on the thickness dependence of these effects and their application to other transition metal oxide families.

Summary updated

Abstract

Using resonant x-ray spectroscopies combined with density functional calculations, we find an asymmetric biaxial strain-induced d-orbital response in ultrathin films of the correlated metal LaNiO3 which are not accessible in the bulk. The sign of the misfit strain governs the stability of an octahedral "breathing" distortion, which, in turn, produces an emergent charge-ordered ground state with an altered ligand-hole density and bond covalency. Control of this new mechanism opens a pathway to rational orbital engineering, providing a platform for artificially designed Mott materials.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chakhalian2011asymmetric,
  author = {J. Chakhalian and James M. Rondinelli and Jian Liu and Benjamin Gray and M. Kareev and E. J. Moon and Narayan Prasai and J. L. Cohn and M. Varela and I‐Cheng Tung and Michael J. Bedzyk and S. G. Altendorf and F. Strigari and B. Da̧browski and L. H. Tjeng and Philip J. Ryan and J. W. Freeland},
  title = {{Asymmetric Orbital-Lattice Interactions in Ultrathin Correlated Oxide Films}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.107.116805},
}
Figure