Associations between maternal urinary iodine assessment, dietary iodine intakes and neurodevelopmental outcomes in the child: a systematic review

Anna M. Monaghan, Maria S. Mulhern, Emeir M. McSorley, Jj Strain, Matthew S. Dyer, Edwin van Wijngaarden, Alison J. YeatesThyroid 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This systematic review highlights that pregnant women are often mildly to moderately iodine deficient, which is linked to neurodevelopmental issues in their children. While both urinary iodine levels and dietary intake are important indicators, dietary intake, particularly from milk, appears to show a stronger association with cognitive outcomes than urinary measurements alone.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Iodine is a critical mineral for fetal neurodevelopment, and deficiency during pregnancy can lead to adverse outcomes in offspring. While urinary iodine concentration (UIC) and iodine-to-creatinine ratio (ICr) are common biomarkers for assessing iodine status, and dietary intake surveys capture longer-term consumption, few studies have systematically combined both measures to understand their impact on child neurodevelopment. This paper addresses the need for a comprehensive review that integrates these different assessment methods to provide a clearer picture of the relationship between maternal iodine status and offspring neurodevelopmental outcomes.

Methods

This study employed a systematic review following the PRISMA guidelines. Researchers searched three electronic databases (EMBASE, MedLine, Web of Science) for studies published between January 1970 and March 2021. Eligible studies included those that assessed maternal iodine status through urinary iodine (UIC and/or ICr) and/or dietary intake during pregnancy, and also measured neurodevelopmental outcomes in the children. Quality assessment of the included studies was performed using the Newcastle Ottawa Scale. Data extracted included study design, sample size, country, gestational age, child age at testing, cognitive tests used, and the reported associations between iodine assessment and cognitive outcomes.

Datasets

Not applicable. This paper is a systematic review of existing research and does not introduce new datasets or benchmarks.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dietary Intake as a Stronger Predictor: The review suggests that dietary iodine intake might be a more sensitive indicator of associations with cognitive outcomes than urinary iodine measurements alone, especially for longer-term effects.
  • Milk as a Key Source: Dairy products, particularly milk, were consistently identified as the primary dietary source of iodine in the reviewed studies.
  • Heterogeneity in Cognitive Assessment: The wide variety of cognitive tests used across studies makes direct comparisons challenging, highlighting the need for standardized assessment methods in future research.
  • Mild Deficiency Still Matters: Even mild to moderate iodine deficiency during pregnancy, as indicated by urinary iodine levels, is associated with potential neurodevelopmental implications in offspring.
  • Importance of Combined Assessment: The review underscores the value of using both urinary iodine and dietary intake assessments to gain a more robust understanding of iodine status and its impact.

Key Results

  • Prevalence of Deficiency: The majority of studies classified pregnant women as mild-to-moderately iodine deficient based on urinary iodine measurements (< 150 µg/L).
  • Associations Found:
    • Five out of twelve studies reported an association between maternal urinary iodine levels and child cognitive outcomes, with higher iodine generally linked to better outcomes.
  • Four out of five studies investigating dietary iodine intake reported a negative association, where lower intake was linked to adverse neurodevelopmental outcomes.
  • No Association in Many Studies: A significant number of studies (seven out of twelve for urinary iodine, and one out of five for dietary intake) did not find a significant association between iodine status and cognitive outcomes. This could be due to various factors, including the type of cognitive tests used or the specific iodine status of the study population.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Initial Screening: The initial screening of abstracts was conducted by a single reviewer, which could introduce bias.
  • Study Design: The review primarily included prospective cohort/longitudinal studies, excluding other designs like Randomized Control Trials (RCTs), which limits the ability to establish cause-and-effect relationships.
  • Urinary Iodine Measurement Limitations: Both UIC and ICr have limitations. UIC reflects recent intake but has high day-to-day variability and doesn't account for urine dilution, while ICr is better for accounting for dilution but still has limitations. A consensus on the best method is still needed.
  • Dietary Assessment Limitations: Food Frequency Questionnaires (FFQs), commonly used, rely on participant recall and can be subject to memory lapses and misreporting. The paper notes the inability to compare FFQs with other methods like 24-hour recalls due to their absence in the reviewed studies.
  • Cognitive Testing Heterogeneity: The diverse range of cognitive tests and age groups assessed across studies makes it difficult to draw definitive conclusions about specific neurodevelopmental domains.

Future work should focus on:

  • Standardized Assessments: Developing and using standardized cognitive tests and consistent age ranges for assessment to allow for better comparison across studies.
  • Combined Measurement Emphasis: Prioritizing studies that combine both urinary iodine assessment and detailed dietary intake measurements.
  • Longer-Term Markers: Exploring longer-term markers of thyroid function (e.g., TSH, T4) and preconception iodine status.
  • Dietary Education and Policy: Promoting public health strategies to increase iodine awareness and knowledge, particularly for women of childbearing age, and encouraging the consumption of iodine-rich foods like milk and dairy.
  • Goitrogen Impact: Investigating the role of goitrogens in the diet, which can affect iodine availability.

Summary updated

Abstract

The majority of studies classified pregnant women to be mild-moderately iodine deficient based on urinary iodine assessment (UIC and/or ICr) and/or dietary intakes, with subsequent offspring neurodevelopment implications identified. Although a considerable number of studies did not report an adverse association with neurodevelopmental outcomes, these findings are still supportive of ensuring adequate dietary iodine intakes and urinary iodine monitoring throughout pregnancy due to the important role iodine plays within foetal neurodevelopment. This review suggests that dietary intake data may indicate a stronger association with cognitive outcomes than urinary iodine measurements alone. The strength of this review distinguishes results based on cognitive outcome per urinary iodine assessment strategy (UIC and/or ICr) with dietary data. Future work is needed respecting the usefulness of urinary iodine assessment (UIC and/or ICr) as an indicator of deficiency whilst also taking account of dietary intakes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{monaghan2021associations,
  author = {Anna M. Monaghan and Maria S. Mulhern and Emeir M. McSorley and JJ Strain and Matthew S. Dyer and Edwin van Wijngaarden and Alison J. Yeates},
  title = {{Associations between maternal urinary iodine assessment, dietary iodine intakes and neurodevelopmental outcomes in the child: a systematic review}},
  booktitle = {Thyroid},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1186/s13044-021-00105-1},
}
Figure