Associations Between Gross Motor Coordination and Executive Functions: Considering the Sex Difference in Chinese Middle-Aged School Children

Shijie Liu, Sitong Chen, Yujun CaiFrontiers in Psychology 2022 · DOI

This study explores the "exercise benefits intelligence" hypothesis by examining the link between gross motor coordination (GMC) and executive functions (EF) in a cohort of 364 Chinese school children. The researchers found that better physical coordination—specifically the ability to move sideways efficiently—correlates with faster cognitive reaction times in tasks involving inhibition and working memory, with these associations being significantly more pronounced in girls than in boys.

TL;DR

Better physical coordination isn't just about sports; it’s linked to faster thinking. This study of 9–10-year-olds shows that children with superior gross motor skills—especially girls—demonstrate quicker reaction times in complex cognitive tasks, suggesting a deep developmental overlap between the "moving" and "thinking" parts of the brain.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Developmental psychologists have long suspected that motor and cognitive processes are intertwined, particularly during the "critical window" of primary school age. However, the existing literature is a bit of a mess: some studies find strong links, others find none, and many use different assessment tools or age groups that make comparisons difficult.

Furthermore, there is a distinct lack of data on Chinese children in this specific age range (9–10 years). This paper seeks to clarify whether gross motor coordination (GMC) actually predicts executive functions (EF)—the "air traffic control" system of the brain—and whether these relationships differ based on biological sex.

Methods

The researchers recruited 364 healthy children from two public schools in Shanghai. They used a dual-pronged assessment approach:

  1. Gross Motor Coordination (GMC): Measured using the KTK (Körperkoordinationtest für Kinder), a standardized German tool consisting of four subtests: jumping sideways, moving sideways on platforms, hopping for height, and walking backward on balance beams.
  2. Executive Functions (EF): Measured via three computer-based tasks:
  3. Flanker Task: Measures inhibition (the ability to ignore distractions).
  4. 1-back Task: Measures working memory (holding and updating information).
  5. More-odd Shifting Task: Measures cognitive flexibility (switching between different rules).

The team then used Pearson correlations and multiple linear regression to analyze the data, controlling for variables like BMI and gender.

Datasets

The study utilized a primary dataset of 364 Chinese children (196 boys, 168 girls) with an average age of 9.55 years. While the KTK and EF tasks are standard benchmarks, this specific cohort provides a unique look at a demographic that is underrepresented in Western-centric developmental research.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Moving Sideways" MVP: Of all the motor tests, "Moving Sideways" (MS) was the strongest predictor of cognitive performance. The authors suggest this is because MS requires complex cooperation between upper and lower limbs, spatial orientation, and balance—demanding more "cognitive load" than a simple jump or hop.
  • Speed Over Accuracy: Interestingly, motor coordination was linked to reaction time but not necessarily accuracy. This suggests that better-coordinated children process information more efficiently, even if they don't necessarily get more answers "right" than their peers.
  • The Gender Gap: The association between GMC and EF was "more substantial" in girls. While boys outperformed girls in strength-based motor tasks (like hopping), girls showed a tighter coupling between their physical coordination and their cognitive processing speeds.
  • Automation vs. Effort: The study found no link between GMC and cognitive flexibility. The authors hypothesize that by age 10, some motor tasks become "automated." Only the motor tasks that remain challenging and require active neural "pre-activation" seem to correlate with high-level executive function.

Key Results

  • Inhibition & Memory: GMC showed a weak-to-moderate negative correlation with reaction times in inhibition and working memory ($r = -0.181$ to $-0.233$). In this context, a negative correlation is good—it means higher coordination scores equal lower (faster) reaction times.
  • Predictive Power: Regression analysis showed that the "Moving Sideways" test and the overall Motor Quotient (MQ) contributed significantly to the variance in reaction times for both working memory (10.6% and 4.9% respectively) and inhibition.
  • Sex Differences: Gender was a significant factor in the relationship between GMC and reaction times for inhibition ($\beta = -0.153, p < 0.05$) and working memory ($\beta = -0.345, p < 0.01$).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several hurdles:

  • Causality: Because this was a cross-sectional study (a snapshot in time), they cannot prove that better motor skills cause better thinking—only that they are related.
  • Aerobic Fitness: The study didn't measure cardiovascular fitness, which is a known "mediator" that could influence both motor and cognitive scores.
  • Narrow Age Range: The results are specific to 9–10-year-olds. Future research should look at longitudinal data to see how this relationship evolves as children enter puberty.

Ultimately, the paper argues for a more holistic approach to physical education, suggesting that complex coordination exercises (like those found in the MS test) might be more beneficial for cognitive development than simple, repetitive movements.

Summary updated

Abstract

Considering that motor and cognitive processes are intertwined and inhibit or help each other throughout life and that primary school age is one of the most critical stages of children's cognitive and motor development, this study aimed to investigate the relationship between executive functions and gross motor skills in Chinese children aged 9-10 years, as well as gender differences. The flanker task, the 1-back task, the more-odd shifting task, and the test of gross motor coordination (Körperkoordinationtest für Kinder) were used to collect data on executive functions and gross motor coordination. The results were as follows. First, there was a weak association between gross motor coordination and the inhibition reaction time in the congruent test and the reaction time of working memory (<i>r</i> = -0.181 to -0.233), but no association was found between gross motor coordination and cognitive flexibility. Second, a weak-to-moderate correlation was presented between the move sideways test and the inhibition reaction time in the congruent test and the reaction time in the refreshing test of the working memory (<i>r</i> = -0.211 to -0.330). Finally, gender influenced on the relationship between gross motor coordination and the reaction time of both inhibition (β<sub>Gender</sub> = -0.153, <i>p</i> < 0.05) and working memory (β<sub>Gender</sub> = -0.345, <i>p</i> < 0.01). To conclude, our results suggest that children with better motor coordination skills require less reaction time, especially girls, and this association was more substantial than in boys. The finding supports the current assertion that there are commonalities between gross motor coordination and cognitive control by showing the relationship between gross motor coordination and complex cognitive processes (executive function) in preadolescent children.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2022associations,
  author = {Shijie Liu and Sitong Chen and Yujun Cai},
  title = {{Associations Between Gross Motor Coordination and Executive Functions: Considering the Sex Difference in Chinese Middle-Aged School Children}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2022.875256},
}
Figure