Associations between Community Cohesion and Subjective Wellbeing of the Elderly in Guangzhou, China—A Cross-Sectional Study Based on the Structural Equation Model

Shulin Lai, Yuquan Zhou, Yuan YuanInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how community cohesion impacts the subjective well-being of elderly individuals in Guangzhou, China, using Structural Equation Modeling. It reveals that environmental satisfaction, interaction, and belonging are key drivers of well-being, with mental health acting as a crucial mediator, while physical health plays a less direct role. The findings highlight significant differences in these associations based on the socioeconomic status of the communities, suggesting tailored urban planning approaches.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As global populations age, understanding how to support the well-being of older adults is paramount. In China, rapid aging presents unique challenges, and with retirement and physical limitations, neighborhoods become central to the elderly's daily lives. While community cohesion is recognized as vital for well-being, most existing research is Western-centric and often focuses on single dimensions of cohesion (like interaction). This paper addresses this gap by examining the multifaceted nature of community cohesion (interaction, environmental satisfaction, belonging, and participation) and its complex relationship with subjective well-being among the elderly in a Chinese context, specifically exploring how socioeconomic differences between communities might alter these associations.

Methods

The researchers employed a cross-sectional survey design, collecting data from 969 elderly individuals (aged 60+) across 20 communities in Guangzhou. The core analytical technique was Structural Equation Modeling (SEM), a statistical method ideal for testing complex relationships between observed and latent variables. SEM allowed them to simultaneously examine the direct and indirect associations between the four dimensions of community cohesion, mental/physical health, and subjective well-being. To account for socioeconomic disparities, they used K-means clustering to classify communities into high and low Socio-Economic Status Index (SESI) groups and then conducted multigroup analysis to compare the SEM results between these groups, identifying significant differences in the strength of associations.

Datasets

The study utilized data from a questionnaire survey administered to 969 elderly individuals in Guangzhou between December 2018 and April 2019. The survey covered demographic information, four dimensions of community cohesion (interaction, belonging, participation, environmental satisfaction), mental health, physical health, and subjective well-being. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the focus was on analyzing existing community structures and individual perceptions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Mental Health as the Key Mediator: The study strongly suggests that mental health is the primary pathway through which community cohesion influences subjective well-being. This highlights the importance of psychological resilience and emotional support within communities.
  • Physical Health's Limited Direct Role: Surprisingly, physical health did not show a significant direct association with subjective well-being in this elderly population. This might be due to the strong influence of family support in Chinese culture, which could buffer the impact of physical limitations on happiness.
  • Community Participation's Nuance: While community cohesion is generally beneficial, "community participation" as defined in this study (e.g., attending activities) showed no significant direct link to subjective well-being, mental health, or physical health. This suggests that the quality or type of participation might be more critical than mere involvement.
  • Socioeconomic Stratification Matters: The strength of the relationships between community cohesion dimensions and well-being varies significantly between high-SESI and low-SESI communities, indicating that a one-size-fits-all approach to community planning is insufficient.

Key Results

  • Community Cohesion Dimensions: Community environmental satisfaction, interaction, and belonging were all significantly associated with subjective well-being. Community participation, however, did not show a significant direct association.
  • Mediating Effects: Mental health significantly mediated the relationship between community cohesion and subjective well-being. Physical health did not act as a significant mediator.
  • High-SESI vs. Low-SESI Communities:
    • In high-SESI communities, community belonging and participation were strongly linked to environmental satisfaction and interaction, respectively. Community interaction had a stronger link to subjective well-being.
  • In low-SESI communities, community interaction, belonging, and participation were more broadly linked to environmental satisfaction, interaction, and belonging. Community environmental satisfaction had a stronger association with subjective well-being.
  • Overall Model Fit: The SEM model demonstrated a good fit to the data, validating the proposed relationships.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Cross-Sectional Design: The study cannot establish causality, only associations. Future longitudinal research is needed to confirm causal pathways.
  • Single Indicators: Using single indicators for subjective well-being and community participation might lead to bias. Future studies could employ more comprehensive scales (e.g., "Satisfaction with Life Scale") and explore political decision-making aspects of participation.
  • Reciprocal Relationships: The study did not account for reciprocal relationships (e.g., how well-being might influence community engagement). Future research could explore these dynamic interactions.
  • Objective vs. Subjective Measures: The reliance on subjective questionnaire data could be complemented by objective measures in future work.

The authors suggest that future research should explore these reciprocal relationships and potentially integrate objective measures to provide a more holistic understanding of community cohesion and well-being. They also emphasize the need for urban and rural planning practices to consider these nuanced findings.

Summary updated

Abstract

Population aging has become one of the most prominent population trends in China and worldwide. Given the retirement and physical limitation of the elderly, the neighborhood has gradually become the center of their daily lives and communication. Community cohesion plays an essential role in improving the elderly's subjective wellbeing. However, most present studies on the concept and relationship between different dimensions of community cohesion are mainly in western countries. Meanwhile, most of the studies on the relationship between community cohesion and subjective wellbeing only focused on one aspect of community cohesion such as community interaction. To address this research gap, this study sampled 20 communities in Guangzhou, conducted a questionnaire survey on 969 elderly people, and explored the relationship between four aspects of community cohesion (community interaction, environmental satisfaction, belonging, and participation) and their associations with subjective wellbeing using the Structural Equation Model (SEM). In addition, we performed multi-group analysis to study the association differences among older individuals in communities with different socioeconomic types. We found that: (1) The conceptual relationship between different aspects of community cohesion among older adults is significant; (2) Community environmental satisfaction, interaction, and belonging associate with the elderly's subjective wellbeing, whereas there is no significant association between community participation and subjective wellbeing; (3) Mental health is an important mediating factor connecting community cohesion and subjective wellbeing, whereas physical health is not. (4) The association pattern of older adults in communities with different socio-economic status are identical, whereas the association strengths are different. In high Socio-Economic Status Index (SESI) communities (communities where older adults with relatively high socioeconomic attributes gather, such as high income and education level), community belonging and participation are significantly associated with community environmental satisfaction and interaction, respectively. In low SESI communities (communities in which older adults with relatively low socioeconomic attributes gather, such as low income and education level), community interaction, belonging, and participation considerably link to community environmental satisfaction, interaction, and belonging, respectively. Regarding the association between community cohesion and subjective wellbeing, community interaction has stronger linkage with the elderly's subjective wellbeing of in high-SESI aging community than low-SESI aging community. While community environmental satisfaction has stronger association with the elderly's subjective wellbeing of the elderly in low-SESI aging community than high-SESI aging community. Therefore, it is sensible for community planning to focus on community environment improvement and vibrant community activities organization.
BibTeX
@article{lai2021associations,
  author = {Shulin Lai and Yuquan Zhou and Yuan Yuan},
  title = {{Associations between Community Cohesion and Subjective Wellbeing of the Elderly in Guangzhou, China—A Cross-Sectional Study Based on the Structural Equation Model}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph18030953},
}
Figure