Associations between childhood family emotional health, fronto-limbic grey matter volume, and saliva 5mC in young adulthood

Jr Pfeiffer, Angela C. Bustamante, Grace S. Kim, Don Armstrong, Christopher Chen, Karestan C. Koenen, Ahmad R. Hariri, Monica UddinbioRxiv 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Poor family emotional health (FEH) during childhood is prevalent and impactful, likely conferring similar neurodevelopmental risks as other adverse social environments. However, the mechanisms by which poor FEH are biologically embedded remain unclear. This exploratory study examined whether variability in DNA methylation (DNAm) and fronto-limbic grey matter volume represent pathways through which FEH becomes biologically embedded. Self-reported childhood FEH was nominally associated with right hemisphere hippocampus ($b=10.4, p=0.005$), left hemisphere amygdala ($b=5.3, p=0.009$), and right hemisphere amygdala ($b=5.8, p=0.016$) volumes. Childhood FEH was also associated with 49 DNAm modules. After limiting analyses to probes correlated between saliva and brain, saliva-derived DNAm modules partially mediated the association between FEH and right hippocampal volume (Burlywood module) and fully mediated the FEH and right amygdala volume relationship (Pink4 module). These modules were enriched with genes involved in immune, CNS, and metabolic functions, suggesting that FEH-associated epigenetic signatures could function as proxies of altered fronto-limbic grey matter volume.

Introduction: The "Ghosts" of Childhood

It has long been established that adverse social environments (ASEs) during childhood, such as poverty or trauma, can reshape the developing brain. However, "Family Emotional Health" (FEH)—a broader measure of the emotional climate at home, including caregiver mental illness and household stability—is less studied but equally impactful. This study explores how the "ghosts" of a difficult childhood become biologically embedded in our bodies, specifically investigating the intersection of saliva-based DNA methylation and brain imaging.

The Problem of Biological Embedding

The central question of this research is: How does a social experience turn into a physical change in the brain? This process, known as "biological embedding," is hypothesized to be mediated by epigenetics. Specifically, DNA methylation (DNAm)—where chemical tags are added to DNA to regulate gene expression—may act as the bridge between early-life stress and structural brain changes. This paper investigates whether these epigenetic "signatures" can be identified in saliva samples and if they correlate with structural changes in the brain's emotional processing centers, the fronto-limbic system.

Methodology

The researchers employed a multi-modal approach combining neuroimaging, epigenetics, and advanced statistics using data from the Duke Neurogenetics Study (DNS), involving 98 university-age volunteers.

  1. Neuroimaging: Structural MRI was used to measure the volume of fronto-limbic regions, including the hippocampus (memory and stress regulation), the amygdala (threat detection), and the prefrontal cortex (executive control).
  2. Epigenetics: DNA methylation was measured at over 850,000 sites (CpG probes) across the genome using saliva samples.
  3. Data Reduction (WGCNA): To manage the high dimensionality of the data, Weighted Gene Co-expression Network Analysis (WGCNA) was used to group related probes into "modules."
  4. Cross-Tissue Correlation: Crucially, the researchers filtered the data using the ImageCpG data repository to focus only on DNAm probes known to be correlated between saliva and brain tissue. This ensured that the saliva markers served as valid proxies for central nervous system (CNS) processes.
  5. Mediation Analysis: A three-step model tested whether childhood FEH predicted specific DNAm modules, and whether those modules in turn predicted brain volume.

Key Insights and Results

Structural Brain Changes

Higher (better) childhood FEH was significantly associated with larger volumes in the right hippocampus ($b=10.4, p=0.005$) and both the left and right amygdala. Quantitatively, poor childhood FEH explained an 8.9% difference in left amygdala volume and an 8.4% difference in the right.

Epigenetic Mediation

The study identified specific molecular pathways that link the home environment to these brain structures:

  • The "Burlywood" Module: Linked to immune and CNS development, this module partially mediated the link between FEH and right hippocampal volume.
  • The "Pink4" Module: Linked to synapse development and cytoskeleton organization, this module fully mediated the relationship between FEH and right amygdala volume. This signature accounted for an additional 2.5% of the volumetric difference in the right amygdala.

The Neuroimmune Connection

The DNAm modules associated with brain changes were enriched for genes involved in immune function and MAPK signaling. This supports the "neuroimmune network hypothesis," suggesting that early life stress may trigger systemic inflammation that eventually alters brain structure.

Discussion and Significance

One of the most significant findings is the validation of peripheral tissue (saliva) as a window into CNS health. By focusing on brain-correlated probes, the authors found a molecular "echo" of childhood stress in saliva that matches structural changes in the brain. Furthermore, the study noted hemisphere specificity; for instance, the Pink4 module mediated the relationship for the right amygdala but not the left, highlighting the importance of lateralization in trauma research.

Limitations and Future Directions

As an exploratory study with 98 participants, the findings are considered nominal and require replication in larger cohorts. The cross-sectional design prevents definitive causal conclusions—it remains possible that the observed DNAm changes and brain volumes are influenced by factors not captured here. Additionally, the university-student sample may have higher socioeconomic status than the general population, potentially masking more severe effects of poor FEH.

Future research should utilize longitudinal designs to track these epigenetic marks and brain changes from childhood through adulthood, and explore other neuroimaging metrics such as cortical thickness or surface area.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background Poor family emotional health (FEH) during childhood is prevalent and impactful, and likely confers similar neurodevelopmental risks as other adverse social environments. Pointed FEH study efforts are underdeveloped, and the mechanisms by which poor FEH are biologically embedded are unclear. The current exploratory study examined whether variability in DNA methylation (DNAm) and fronto-limbic grey matter volume may represent pathways through which FEH may become biologically embedded. Results Self-reported childhood FEH was nominally associated with right hemisphere hippocampus (b=10.4, p=0.005), left hemisphere amygdala (b=5.3, p=0.009), and right hemisphere amygdala (b=5.8, p=0.016) volumes. Childhood FEH was also nominally associated with 49 DNAm MEs (p range =3×10 −6 to 0.047). After limiting analyses to probes correlated between saliva and brain, saliva-derived DNAm MEs partially mediated the association between FEH and right hippocampal volume (Burlywood ME indirect effect b=-111, p=0.014), and fully mediated the FEH and right amygdala volume relationship (Pink4 ME indirect effect b=-48, p=0.026). Modules were enriched with probes falling in genes with immune, CNS, and metabolic functions. Conclusions Findings extend work highlighting neurodevelopmental variability associated with adverse social environment exposure during childhood by specifically implicating poor FEH, while informing a mechanism of biological embedding. FEH-associated epigenetic signatures could function as proxies of altered fronto-limbic grey matter volume associated with poor childhood FEH and inform further investigation into primarily affected tissues such as endocrine, immune, and CNS cell types.
BibTeX
@misc{pfeiffer2020associations,
  author = {JR Pfeiffer and Angela C. Bustamante and Grace S. Kim and Don Armstrong and Christopher Chen and Karestan C. Koenen and Ahmad R. Hariri and Monica Uddin},
  title = {{Associations between childhood family emotional health, fronto-limbic grey matter volume, and saliva 5mC in young adulthood}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.10.26.355347},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure