Abstract
We found no association between mRFEI and sodium intake. The association between mRFEI and potassium intake and the sodium-potassium ratio varied by region. National strategies to reduce sodium in the food supply may be most effective to reduce sodium intake. Strategies aimed at the local level should consider regional context and neighborhood characteristics.
Introduction
High sodium and low potassium intakes are primary drivers of hypertension and cardiovascular disease. While previous research has linked "food deserts" and retail environments to general diet quality (such as fruit and vegetable consumption), it remained unclear if the local mix of food vendors specifically influences these two critical electrolytes. Public health practitioners often advocate for "neighborhood-level" interventions—like bringing supermarkets into underserved areas—to improve health. This study tests the validity of that approach for sodium and potassium, asking if simply changing the types of stores available can move the needle on these specific nutritional markers.
Methods
The researchers employed a cross-sectional analysis using a "modified Retail Food Environment Index" (mRFEI). This metric represents the percentage of "healthful" food vendors (supermarkets, large grocery stores, produce markets) relative to the total number of vendors (including convenience stores and fast-food outlets) within a 0.5-mile buffer of a census tract.
The study integrated three major data streams: NHANES (2005–2008) for dietary recall and demographics; business databases (2008–2009) to map food retailers; and US Census/ACS (2005–2009) for neighborhood-level covariates such as poverty rates and racial composition.
Linear regression assessed the relationship between mRFEI and nutrient intake, using the National Cancer Institute (NCI) method to estimate "usual intake." Models were stratified into South and non-South regions due to significant geographic differences in dietary patterns.
Results
The most striking insight is that sodium intake is decoupled from the local retail environment. Because high-sodium processed foods are prevalent in both "healthful" supermarkets and convenience stores, living near a supermarket provides no inherent protection against high salt consumption. No significant association was found between mRFEI and sodium intake in any region ($P > .05$).
Regional divergence was observed for potassium. In the non-South, a better retail environment correlated with higher potassium intake ($P_{trend} = .005$). In the South, the relationship was initially reversed ($P_{trend} < .001$), suggesting that regional dietary traditions or "microenvironments" within stores might play a larger role than store type alone. On average, US adults consume ~3,600 mg of sodium (well above the <2,300 mg recommendation) and ~2,800 mg of potassium (well below the >4,700 mg recommendation).
Discussion and Conclusion
When neighborhood characteristics like poverty levels and racial makeup were added to the models, the associations between the food environment and diet often diminished. This suggests that socioeconomic barriers are more powerful determinants of diet than the mere physical presence of a store.
Furthermore, the study's assumptions—such as people shopping only in their own census tract—may not reflect actual consumer behavior. The authors suggest that national-level strategies, such as working with the food industry to reduce sodium in the general food supply, may be more effective than local retail interventions. Future research should focus on "microenvironments" (shelf placement and pricing within stores) and individual shopping behaviors to better understand these nutritional drivers.
Summary updated