Association of the barriers of pharmaceutical care perceived by clinical pharmacists and occupational stress in tertiary hospitals of China

Yu Zhang, Yuankai Huang, Xiaoyu XiFrontiers in Public Health 2024 · DOI

This study investigates how specific workplace obstacles—ranging from clunky software to a lack of continuing education—drive occupational stress for clinical pharmacists in China. By surveying over 600 professionals across 311 hospitals, the researchers identify "resource" and "self-improvement" gaps as the primary culprits, providing a data-driven roadmap for improving both healthcare provider well-being and patient safety.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While doctors and nurses are frequently the focus of occupational stress studies, clinical pharmacists—the gatekeepers of rational drug use—often fly under the research radar. In China, the clinical pharmacy system is still maturing, and pharmacists face a unique set of pressures.

The authors use Person-Environment (P-E) Fit Theory to frame the problem: stress isn't just about a heavy workload; it’s the result of a "mismatch" between what a professional needs to do their job (supplies/demands) and what the hospital environment actually provides. This paper seeks to quantify which specific "barriers to care" (like poor IT systems or lack of physical space) are most strongly associated with high stress levels.

Methods

The researchers employed a robust multi-stage stratified sampling method to ensure a representative look at tertiary hospitals across all 31 provincial administrative regions in mainland China.

Key technical aspects include:

  • The Instruments: They used the standardized Brief Job Stress Questionnaire (BJSQ) to measure stress. Crucially, they developed a new 18-item scale specifically to measure perceived barriers to pharmaceutical care in the Chinese context.
  • Validation: The new scale was refined using Exploratory Factor Analysis (EFA) and Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) to group 18 items into four dimensions: Resources, Cooperation, Leadership Support/Rights, and Self-improvement.
  • Analysis: Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) regression was used to find the association between these barriers and stress scores, while controlling for variables like age, sex, and technical title.

Datasets

The study relies on a primary dataset generated from a field-based questionnaire survey conducted between July and August 2019.

  • Sample Size: 625 clinical pharmacists.
  • Scope: 311 tertiary (top-tier) hospitals.
  • Response Rate: A high 84%, lending significant weight to the findings.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Resource" Bottleneck: The strongest predictor of stress was the "Resource" dimension. This isn't just about money; it’s about the tools of the trade. Pharmacists reported that electronic systems are often designed for billing and administration rather than clinical decision support, leading to a "mismatch" that spikes stress.
  • The Seniority Paradox: Unlike some fields where experience leads to a "cushier" role, senior clinical pharmacists in China reported higher stress. This is likely because they are tasked with the most complex clinical consultations and difficult cases.
  • Specialty Pressure Cookers: Pharmacists working in Neurology and ICU environments showed significantly higher stress levels. These fields require a higher level of medical knowledge and involve managing critically ill patients with complex, individualized drug regimens.
  • What Didn't Matter (Surprisingly): Barriers related to "Cooperation" (e.g., communication with doctors) and "Leadership Support" did not show a statistically significant link to stress in the final model. The authors suggest this might be because pharmacists in these settings already perceive themselves as having low "discourse power," so they may have lower expectations for these factors.

Key Results

  • Resource Barriers: Strongly associated with increased stress ($p = 0.00$, $coef = 10.70$).
  • Self-Improvement Barriers: Also a significant stressor ($p = 0.01$, $coef = 6.71$), highlighting that a lack of time or access to quality continuing education makes pharmacists feel ill-equipped for their evolving roles.
  • Demographics: Being married was associated with lower stress ($p = 0.02$), suggesting a "buffer" effect from social/family support.
  • Hospital Type: Working in specialized hospitals was associated with lower stress compared to general hospitals ($p = 0.03$), likely due to a more focused and predictable scope of practice.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Causality: As a cross-sectional survey, the study shows associations, not necessarily direct cause-and-effect.
  • Sampling Bias: While stratified, the final stage of sampling was "by convenience," which might introduce some bias.
  • Self-Reporting: The data relies on the subjective perceptions of the pharmacists.

Future Work: The authors suggest that hospitals should prioritize "removing the friction" by upgrading clinical IT systems and establishing standardized service procedures. They also call for universities to better integrate computer network technology into pharmacy curricula and for hospitals to provide dedicated "protected time" for continuing education to bridge the self-improvement gap.

Summary updated

Abstract

By removing barriers to pharmacists' resources and self-improvement, it is possible to better meet the work needs of clinical pharmacists and may effectively reduce occupational stress, thereby improving the quality of pharmaceutical services.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2024association,
  author = {Yu Zhang and Yuankai Huang and Xiaoyu Xi},
  title = {{Association of the barriers of pharmaceutical care perceived by clinical pharmacists and occupational stress in tertiary hospitals of China}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Public Health},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fpubh.2024.1342565},
}
Figure