Association of short-term exposure to personal ozone with heart rate during sleep and potential predisposing factors in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease

Wenlou Zhang, Boqi Chen, Zhaoyong Chen, Xuechao Ji, Jindong Wang, Yahong Chen, Xinbiao Guo, Furong DengChinese 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Ozone ($O_3$) pollution is a significant environmental factor threatening global cardiovascular health. However, the early cardiovascular effects of $O_3$ exposure remain poorly understood. Given that individuals spend approximately one-third of their lives sleeping, and elevated nocturnal heart rate is a critical risk factor for cardiovascular disease and mortality, this study investigated the link between personal $O_3$ exposure and sleep heart rate. Using a repeated-measure design, 46 patients with stable Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) were monitored for 24-hour personal $O_3$ exposure and nocturnal heart rate. Linear mixed-effects models revealed that even minutes of $O_3$ exposure significantly increased sleep heart rate, with the strongest effect at a lag of 0–8 hours (3.28 bpm increase per 19.6 $\mu g/m^3$ $O_3$ rise). An exposure-response threshold was identified at 33 $\mu g/m^3$. Patients with poorer baseline health—including lower lung function, more severe respiratory symptoms, and poor sleep quality—exhibited greater susceptibility. These findings suggest that short-term $O_3$ exposure is a vital risk factor for nocturnal tachycardia in COPD patients, even at levels below current air quality standards.

Introduction

While global efforts have successfully reduced particulate matter ($PM_{2.5}$) levels in many regions, ozone ($O_3$) pollution has emerged as a growing environmental challenge. Ozone is a well-documented respiratory irritant, but its systemic effects, particularly on the cardiovascular system during vulnerable periods like sleep, are less characterized.

Sleep is essential for cardiovascular recovery and autonomic regulation. An elevated heart rate during sleep is not merely a physiological response; it is a sentinel marker for cardiovascular morbidity and mortality. Patients with Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) are at heightened risk due to chronic systemic inflammation and compromised pulmonary function. This study aims to quantify the association between real-time personal ozone exposure and nocturnal heart rate in COPD patients and identify factors that increase individual susceptibility.

Methods

The researchers utilized a repeated-measure study design to account for individual variability, following 46 stable COPD patients in Beijing between 2021 and 2023.

  • Monitoring: Personal $O_3$ exposure was tracked using portable monitors, while nocturnal heart rate was recorded minute-by-minute using ring-style pulse oximeters.
  • Health Metrics: Comprehensive assessments included lung function ($FEV_1$), respiratory symptoms (SGRQ and CAT scales), comorbidities, and sleep quality (PSQI).
  • Statistical Analysis: Linear mixed-effects (LME) models assessed the relationship between $O_3$ and heart rate across various lag periods (0 to 12 hours). Interaction models were employed to evaluate how baseline health status modified these effects.

Results

The Impact of Ozone on Nocturnal Heart Rate

The study found a significant, near-immediate association between ozone exposure and increased heart rate during sleep. The cumulative effect peaked within a 0–8 hour lag window. Specifically, for every interquartile range (19.6 $\mu g/m^3$) increase in $O_3$ concentration, the average sleep heart rate rose by 3.28 beats per minute (bpm) (95% CI: 3.12–3.44).

Threshold Effects and Air Quality Standards

A non-linear exposure-response analysis identified a critical threshold of 33 $\mu g/m^3$. Above this concentration, the increase in heart rate became markedly more pronounced. Notably, this threshold is substantially lower than the current Chinese Grade I air quality standard of 100 $\mu g/m^3$ (8-hour average), suggesting that existing guidelines may not sufficiently protect vulnerable populations.

Vulnerability and Predisposing Factors

The study highlighted that the cardiovascular impact of ozone is not uniform. Patients with poorer baseline health metrics were significantly more susceptible to ozone-induced heart rate increases.

Association between ozone exposure and heart rate changes stratified by health status indicators.

As shown in the figure above, patients with higher SGRQ scores (indicating worse quality of life), more severe respiratory symptoms, greater activity limitation, and poorer psychosocial status experienced significantly higher heart rate elevations across almost all lag periods compared to their healthier counterparts. Furthermore, patients with existing cardiovascular comorbidities saw nearly double the heart rate increase (5.99 bpm) compared to those without.

Discussion and Conclusion

These findings underscore the role of short-term ozone exposure as a potent stressor for the cardiovascular system in COPD patients. The immediate nature of the heart rate response suggests an impact on the autonomic nervous system. The heightened sensitivity of patients with poor sleep quality (PSQI > 5) further emphasizes the complex interplay between environmental stressors and physiological recovery.

Limitations

The study's cohort was relatively small and predominantly male, which may limit the generalizability of the findings to broader populations. Additionally, while personal monitoring was used, the high proportion of time spent indoors suggests a need for further research into the infiltration of ambient ozone into indoor living spaces.

Conclusion

Current air quality standards may underestimate the cardiovascular risks posed by ozone to susceptible groups. Nocturnal heart rate monitoring could serve as an effective tool for the early detection of environmental health impacts. These results provide a scientific basis for more stringent air quality management and targeted health interventions for COPD patients.

Summary updated

Abstract

臭氧(Ozone, O3)污染是当前威胁全球人群心血管健康的重要环境因素,然而,O3暴露的早期心血管效应仍不清楚. 人的一生中约1/3的时间在睡眠中度过,研究表明,睡眠期间心率增加是心血管疾病和死亡的关键危险因素. 本研究采用重复测量研究设计,对46名稳定期慢性阻塞性肺疾病(简称慢阻肺)患者开展定期随访,每次随访期间对研究对象的24 h个体O3暴露以及睡眠期间心率进行实时监测,同时收集研究对象的肺功能、呼吸道症状、合并症和睡眠质量信息.采用线性混合效应模型分析个体O3短期暴露与睡眠期间心率的关联,采用交互作用模型探讨潜在的易感因素. 分析结果显示,数分钟的个体O3暴露即与患者睡眠期间心率升高显著相关,在滞后0~8 h效应达到最强,O3浓度每升高19.6 μg/m3,睡眠期间心率增加3.28 (95%CI: 3.12~3.44)次/min. 暴露—反应关系显示,O3浓度超过33 μg/m3时,睡眠期间心率呈现明显的增加趋势. 具有较差的健康状态(包括肺功能更低、呼吸道症状更重、活动受限、不良心理精神状态、合并心血管疾病以及睡眠质量较差)的患者睡眠期间心率更容易受到O3的影响. 上述结果表明O3短期暴露是慢阻肺患者睡眠期间心率加快的重要危险因素,即使在明显低于我国现行空气质量标准的浓度下,仍可观察到O3的不良心血管影响. 本研究可为易感人群心血管疾病的早期防控提供重要科学依据.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2024association,
  author = {Wenlou Zhang and Boqi Chen and Zhaoyong Chen and Xuechao Ji and Jindong Wang and Yahong Chen and Xinbiao Guo and Furong Deng},
  title = {{Association of short-term exposure to personal ozone with heart rate during sleep and potential predisposing factors in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease}},
  booktitle = {Chinese},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1360/tb-2024-0078},
}
Figure