Association of shared decision making with inpatient satisfaction: a cross-sectional study

Huiwen Luo, Guohua Liu, Jing Lu, Di XueBMC Medical Informatics Decis. Mak 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the impact of shared decision-making (SDM) on patient satisfaction in Chinese tertiary hospitals. It finds that while overall SDM is relatively high, information about treatment alternatives is less frequently discussed. Crucially, higher levels of SDM are strongly associated with increased patient satisfaction across various aspects of care, particularly concerning medical expenses.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Ensuring high-quality patient care involves not only effective medical treatment but also patient engagement and satisfaction. Shared decision-making (SDM) is a model where physicians and patients collaborate to make healthcare choices, aiming to align treatments with patient values and preferences. While SDM is recognized as a cornerstone of patient-centered care, its specific impact on inpatient satisfaction, especially in diverse healthcare systems like China's, remains an area needing deeper exploration. This paper addresses the question of how prevalent SDM is in Chinese public tertiary hospitals and, more importantly, whether it translates into higher patient satisfaction with different facets of their hospital experience, including physician services, medical expenses, and treatment outcomes.

Methods

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional survey of 2585 inpatients across 47 public tertiary hospitals in Shanghai. They employed a validated SDM scale, assessing four key aspects: patients' information preference, active involvement in SDM, perceived physician encouragement for SDM, and informed consent. Patient satisfaction was measured across four dimensions: facilities and equipment, physician services, nonphysician services, and medical care process and effectiveness. To analyze the data, they used t-tests and linear regression models to examine factors influencing SDM and two-level regression models to account for the hierarchical structure of the data (individuals nested within hospitals). This approach allowed them to assess the association between SDM and patient satisfaction while controlling for various patient and hospital characteristics.

Datasets

The study utilized data from a cross-sectional inpatient survey conducted in Shanghai, China, in July and August 2018. The dataset comprised 2585 inpatients from 47 public tertiary hospitals. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • SDM is prevalent, but information gaps exist: While overall SDM rates are high, a notable finding is the lower rate of patients feeling fully informed about treatment alternatives. This suggests a potential area for improvement in physician communication.
  • Surgery patients benefit more from SDM: Inpatients who underwent surgery reported higher levels of SDM, possibly due to the higher stakes and complexity of such decisions, leading to a greater perceived need for collaborative decision-making.
  • SDM significantly boosts patient satisfaction, especially for medical expenses: The study highlights a strong positive correlation between high levels of SDM and patient satisfaction across all measured domains. The most striking impact was observed in satisfaction with medical expenses, suggesting that informed decision-making can alleviate financial anxieties.
  • Hospital type matters for satisfaction: A significant portion of the variance in overall inpatient satisfaction was attributed to hospital type, with specialty hospitals showing lower satisfaction compared to general hospitals. This points to the need for hospital-level strategies to enhance patient experience.

Key Results

  • Overall SDM: Positive response rates (PRR) for overall SDM were 95.30%, with high positive response rates (HPRR) at 87.86%.
  • Informed Consent Gap: The HPRR for "My physician informed me of different treatment alternatives" was the lowest among all SDM items at 80.09%.
  • Surgery Impact: Inpatients who underwent surgery had higher HPRRs for information preference, perceived physician encouragement, and overall SDM.
  • Satisfaction Boost: Inpatients with a high level of overall SDM reported significantly higher adjusted satisfaction rates: 96.50% for physician services, 68.44% for medical expenses, 89.50% for treatment outcomes, and 92.60% for overall inpatient care, compared to those without high SDM (71.77%, 35.19%, 57.30%, and 67.49%, respectively).
  • Medical Expenses & Informed Consent: The greatest differences in satisfaction between high-SDM and low-SDM groups were observed for medical expenses and informed consent.
  • Hospital Type Variance: 46.22% of the variance in overall inpatient satisfaction was attributed to hospital type (general vs. specialty).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Geographic Scope: The study was conducted solely in Shanghai, a highly developed area, limiting the generalizability of findings to hospitals in other regions of China.
  • Inpatient Status: Participants were surveyed while still hospitalized, which might introduce selection bias. However, they note that satisfaction rates for discharged patients in a contemporaneous survey did not differ significantly.
  • Confounding Factors: While socioeconomic factors were considered, other potential confounders influencing SDM and satisfaction were not fully accounted for.
  • SDM Measure Validity: The authors note that the SDM measure used did not have high construct validity, which could affect the results.

Future work could focus on addressing the information gap regarding treatment alternatives, exploring the reasons for lower satisfaction in specialty hospitals, and developing hospital-level interventions to promote SDM and enhance patient satisfaction, particularly in areas like informed consent for high-risk or expensive treatments.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{luo2021association,
  author = {Huiwen Luo and Guohua Liu and Jing Lu and Di Xue},
  title = {{Association of shared decision making with inpatient satisfaction: a cross-sectional study}},
  journal = {BMC Medical Informatics Decis. Mak.},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1186/s12911-021-01385-1},
}
Figure