Association of Non-Pharmaceutical Interventions to Reduce the Spread of SARS-CoV-2 With Anxiety and Depressive Symptoms: A Multi-National Study of 43 Countries

Kira E. Riehm, Elena Badillo Goicoechea, Frances Wang, Esther Kim, Luke R. Aldridge, Carly P. Lupton-Smith, Rachel Presskreischer, Ting‐Hsuan Chang, Sarah LaRocca, Frauke Kreuter, Elizabeth A. StuartInternational Journal of Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated the link between COVID-19 non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) and mental health outcomes (anxiety and depression) across 43 countries. It found that while stricter NPIs were associated with increased odds of these symptoms, the effects were small, and importantly, these associations varied significantly by gender and, to a lesser extent, age.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The COVID-19 pandemic necessitated widespread implementation of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) like lockdowns and social distancing to curb virus transmission. While the effectiveness of these measures in reducing infection rates is well-documented, their potential negative consequences on population mental health have been a growing concern. Existing research on this topic was limited, often focusing on single countries, specific NPIs (like stay-at-home orders), and lacking a comprehensive analysis of how these effects might differ across demographic groups. This paper aims to fill this gap by examining the association between various NPIs and anxiety/depressive symptoms on a large, multi-national scale, specifically investigating the moderating roles of gender and age.

Methods

The researchers employed a large-scale, multi-national survey dataset combined with time-varying NPI data. They used logistic regression models to analyze the associations between NPI stringency and individual NPIs with anxiety and depressive symptoms. Key to their approach was the inclusion of interaction terms to specifically test for moderation by gender and age. They also controlled for various country-level (e.g., COVID-19 case rates) and individual-level (e.g., age group, urbanicity) covariates to isolate the effects of NPIs. Sensitivity analyses were conducted to check the robustness of their findings.

Datasets

  • COVID-19 Trends and Impact Surveys (CTIS): A daily, cross-sectional survey conducted via Facebook, collecting data from over 16 million adults across 43 countries between April and December 2020. This dataset provided self-reported measures of anxiety and depressive symptoms, along with demographic information.
  • Oxford COVID-19 Government Response Tracker (OxCGRT): This dataset provided time-varying, national-level data on government responses to the COVID-19 pandemic, including an overall stringency index and data on seven specific "containment and closure" NPIs.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • NPIs and Mental Health: A Double-Edged Sword: The study confirms that while NPIs are crucial for public health, they are not without their mental health costs. This highlights the need for a balanced approach in public health policy.
  • Gendered Impact of NPIs: The most striking finding is the significant difference in how NPIs affect men and women. Certain restrictions, like school and public event closures, had a more pronounced association with anxiety and depression in women, suggesting that gendered societal roles and responsibilities play a critical part.
  • Age Differences are Less Pronounced: While age did show some moderating effects, particularly for stay-at-home requirements, the differences were less pronounced than those observed by gender. This suggests that while age is a factor, gender might be a more critical lens for understanding NPI impacts on mental health.
  • Small but Potentially Significant Effect Sizes: The study emphasizes that the effect sizes for the association between NPIs and mental health symptoms were generally small. However, given the population-wide application of these interventions, even small effects can translate to significant public health consequences.

Key Results

  • A 10-point increase in the overall NPI stringency index was associated with a 1.4% increase in the odds of reporting anxiety symptoms and a 2.7% increase in the odds of reporting depressive symptoms.
  • Women reported higher odds of anxiety and depressive symptoms compared to men, as did individuals living in urban areas.
  • Gender-specific associations:
    • School closures, cancellation of public events, restrictions on gathering sizes, and internal movement restrictions were more strongly associated with anxiety and depressive symptoms in females.
  • Stay-at-home requirements and international travel controls showed stronger associations with anxiety and depressive symptoms in males.
  • Workplace closures were not significantly associated with either anxiety or depressive symptoms for either gender.
  • Age-specific associations:
    • For anxiety symptoms, restrictions on gathering sizes and stay-at-home requirements showed significant interactions with age.
  • For depressive symptoms, school closures, cancellation of public events, stay-at-home requirements, and restrictions on internal movement showed significant interactions with age.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Causality: The study acknowledges that its results should not be interpreted as indicating a causal link between NPIs and mental health. The simultaneous implementation of multiple NPIs makes isolating individual effects difficult.
  • Unmeasured Confounding: The possibility of unmeasured confounding at both country and individual levels cannot be ruled out.
  • Adherence and Heterogeneity: The stringency index does not capture actual adherence to NPIs or the heterogeneity of implementation at regional or local levels.
  • Sample Representativeness: While weighting was used, the extent to which the Facebook user sample represents the general population on unmeasured characteristics remains unknown.
  • Lack of Pre-Pandemic Data: The study could not compare mental health trends to pre-pandemic levels within each country.

Future work could focus on exploring the specific mechanisms behind the observed gender and age differences, investigating the long-term mental health impacts of NPIs, and developing more nuanced measures of NPI implementation and adherence. The authors suggest that governments should prepare to address the mental health consequences of NPIs with both universal and targeted interventions for vulnerable groups.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Objectives:</b> To examine the association of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) with anxiety and depressive symptoms among adults and determine if these associations varied by gender and age. <b>Methods:</b> We combined survey data from 16,177,184 adults from 43 countries who participated in the daily COVID-19 Trends and Impact Survey <i>via</i> Facebook with time-varying NPI data from the Oxford COVID-19 Government Response Tracker between 24 April 2020 and 20 December 2020. Using logistic regression models, we examined the association of [1] overall NPI stringency and [2] seven individual NPIs (school closures, workplace closures, cancellation of public events, restrictions on the size of gatherings, stay-at-home requirements, restrictions on internal movement, and international travel controls) with anxiety and depressive symptoms. <b>Results:</b> More stringent implementation of NPIs was associated with a higher odds of anxiety and depressive symptoms, albeit with very small effect sizes. Individual NPIs had heterogeneous associations with anxiety and depressive symptoms by gender and age. <b>Conclusion:</b> Governments worldwide should be prepared to address the possible mental health consequences of stringent NPI implementation with both universal and targeted interventions for vulnerable groups.
BibTeX
@article{riehm2022association,
  author = {Kira E. Riehm and Elena Badillo Goicoechea and Frances Wang and Esther Kim and Luke R. Aldridge and Carly P. Lupton-Smith and Rachel Presskreischer and Ting‐Hsuan Chang and Sarah LaRocca and Frauke Kreuter and Elizabeth A. Stuart},
  title = {{Association of Non-Pharmaceutical Interventions to Reduce the Spread of SARS-CoV-2 With Anxiety and Depressive Symptoms: A Multi-National Study of 43 Countries}},
  journal = {International Journal of Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/ijph.2022.1604430},
}
Figure