Association of MRS-Based Vertebral Bone Marrow Fat Fraction with Bone Strength in a Human In Vitro Model

Dimitrios C. Karampinos, Stefan Ruschke, Olga Gordijenko, Eduardo Grande García, Hendrik Kooijman, Rainer Burgkart, Ernst J. Rummeny, Jan S. Bauer, Thomas BaumJournal of Osteoporosis 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the link between bone marrow fat content and bone strength using human vertebral samples. They found a significant negative correlation between bone marrow fat fraction and both bone mineral density (BMD) and biomechanical failure load, suggesting that increased fat in the bone marrow is associated with weaker bones. This work provides direct ex vivo validation for the role of bone marrow adiposity in bone health and fracture risk.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Osteoporosis is a major health concern characterized by reduced bone strength, leading to increased fracture risk. While bone mineral density (BMD) is a primary predictor of bone strength, it doesn't capture the full picture, as bone microstructure also plays a crucial role. Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) offers a non-ionizing way to assess bone health. Recent research has highlighted the growing importance of bone marrow adiposity (fat content) in bone loss pathophysiology. It's known that bone marrow fat increases with age and is associated with decreased BMD. However, a direct, in-vitro investigation into how bone marrow fat content relates to actual bone strength and microstructural parameters was lacking. This paper aims to bridge this gap by directly correlating MRS-measured bone marrow fat fraction with MDCT-derived BMD and microstructure, and crucially, with biomechanical failure load in human vertebral specimens.

Methods

The researchers used a multimodality approach on ten human vertebral specimens harvested from cadavers.

  • Bone Marrow Fat Fraction: Single-voxel Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy (MRS) was employed using a stimulated echo acquisition mode (STEAM) sequence. Multiple echo times (TEs) were used to account for T2 relaxation effects, and a constrained fitting approach was applied to accurately derive the proton density fat fraction, distinguishing it from signal-weighted measures.
  • Bone Mineral Density (BMD) and Microstructure: Multidetector Computed Tomography (MDCT) was used to acquire high-resolution images of the vertebrae. Trabecular BMD was calculated by converting pixel attenuations to Hounsfield Units (HU) calibrated against a phantom. Trabecular bone microstructure parameters, including bone volume divided by total volume (BV/TV), trabecular number (TbN), and fractal dimension (FD), were derived from binarized MDCT images using established methods.
  • Biomechanical Testing: The embedded vertebrae underwent uniaxial compression testing to determine their failure load (FL). This was normalized by the cross-sectional area to account for variations in specimen size.

Datasets

The study utilized ten human vertebral specimens (thoracic vertebrae T5-T10) harvested from four fresh human cadavers. These specimens served as the dataset for the in-vitro analysis. No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing techniques were applied to this specific ex vivo model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Direct Validation of Bone Marrow Fat's Role in Strength: This study provides the first direct ex vivo validation of the negative association between bone marrow fat content and biomechanical bone strength. This moves beyond correlational studies based on indirect measures.
  • MRS as a Promising Tool: The study demonstrates the utility of single-voxel MRS, with appropriate T2 correction and fitting strategies, for accurately quantifying bone marrow fat in vertebral bodies. This technique holds promise for in vivo osteoporosis assessment.
  • Interplay of Fat, BMD, and Microstructure: The findings reinforce the interconnectedness of bone marrow fat, BMD, and trabecular microstructure. The negative correlation with BMD is consistent with prior research, but extending this to direct biomechanical strength is a significant step.
  • Beyond BMD: The results underscore that bone marrow fat content may offer complementary information to BMD for predicting bone strength and fracture risk, potentially capturing aspects of bone quality not fully represented by BMD alone.

Key Results

  • Significant negative correlations were observed between MRS-based fat fraction and MDCT-based parameters:
  • Fat fraction and BMD: r = -0.72, P = 0.045
    • Fat fraction and normalized failure load (biomechanical strength): r = -0.77, P = 0.013
  • Trends towards statistical significance were found for correlations between fat fraction and trabecular microstructure parameters (BV/TV, TbN, FD), though not reaching the P < 0.05 threshold.
  • Normalized failure load showed strong positive correlations with BMD (r = 0.90) and trabecular microstructure parameters.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size: The study acknowledges its relatively small sample size (n=10), which may have limited statistical power to detect significant correlations for all trabecular microstructure parameters.
  • Spatial Resolution of MDCT: The MDCT-based trabecular microstructure measurements, while correlated with higher-resolution methods, may not fully capture the true trabecular structure due to resolution limitations.
  • Intact Vertebra Limitations: The imaging-derived measurements do not account for the contribution of endplates, cortical shell, and posterior elements to overall vertebral strength.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that larger-scale studies are needed to further understand whether bone marrow fat content can become a predictor of bone strength, potentially after correcting for BMD effects. They also highlight the need for future research to explore the mechanisms underlying the observed associations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Bone marrow adiposity has recently gained attention due to its association with bone loss pathophysiology. In this study, ten vertebrae were harvested from fresh human cadavers. Trabecular BMD and microstructure parameters were extracted from MDCT. Bone marrow fat fractions were determined using single-voxel MRS. Failure load (FL) values were assessed by destructive biomechanical testing. Significant correlations (P < 0.05) were observed between MRS-based fat fraction and MDCT-based parameters (up to r = -0.72) and MRS-based fat fraction and FL (r = -0.77). These findings underline the importance of the bone marrow in the pathophysiology and imaging diagnostics of osteoporosis.
BibTeX
@article{karampinos2015association,
  author = {Dimitrios C. Karampinos and Stefan Ruschke and Olga Gordijenko and Eduardo Grande García and Hendrik Kooijman and Rainer Burgkart and Ernst J. Rummeny and Jan S. Bauer and Thomas Baum},
  title = {{Association of MRS-Based Vertebral Bone Marrow Fat Fraction with Bone Strength in a Human In Vitro Model}},
  journal = {Journal of Osteoporosis},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1155/2015/152349},
}
Figure