Association Between the Attention Network Test, Neuropsychological Measures, and Disability in Post-Acute Traumatic Brain Injury

Abhishek Jaywant, Emily Blunt, Keith Jamison, Nayoung Kim, Arindam RoyChoudhury, Nicholas D. Schiff, Amy Kuceyeski, Kristen Dams-O’Connor, Sudhin A. ShahNeurotrauma 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the construct validity of the Attention Network Test (ANT) in individuals with moderate to severe traumatic brain injury (TBI). The ANT showed a significant association with measures of processing speed and executive function, but not memory, supporting its utility as a measure of attention and executive function in TBI research.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traumatic brain injury (TBI) often leads to persistent and disabling cognitive impairments, particularly affecting attention, processing speed, executive functions, and memory. While assessing these deficits is crucial for research and clinical trials, especially for evaluating new interventions, there's a need for reliable and valid cognitive measures that are sensitive to underlying neural changes. The Attention Network Test (ANT) is a promising behavioral measure that assesses distinct attentional networks (alerting, orienting, and executive) and has shown associations with specific brain regions. However, its clinical utility in TBI populations has been limited by a lack of established construct validity, meaning its relationship with established neuropsychological measures of cognitive function in TBI patients was not well understood. This paper aims to bridge this gap by examining how ANT performance relates to a comprehensive neuropsychological battery and global functional outcomes in individuals recovering from TBI.

Methods

The researchers recruited 48 adults who had sustained a complicated mild to severe TBI within the last six months. Participants underwent a comprehensive neuropsychological assessment battery designed to evaluate attention, processing speed, executive function, and memory. Key measures included the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale-IV (WAIS-IV) subtests, Trail Making Test (TMT-A and TMT-B), Stroop Color-Word Test, and the California Verbal Learning Test-Second Edition (CVLT-II).

The Attention Network Test (ANT) was administered to assess the three attentional networks: alerting, orienting, and executive. Network scores were calculated based on reaction time differences between specific trial conditions. To analyze the neuropsychological data, a principal component analysis (PCA) was performed to identify underlying cognitive constructs. This analysis yielded two main components: one representing processing speed and executive function, and another representing working and episodic memory.

Multivariate linear regression models were then used to examine the associations between ANT network scores (alerting, orienting, executive, and mean reaction time) and these two principal cognitive components, controlling for age, gender, education, and cause of injury. A similar model, using ordinal logistic regression, was employed to assess the relationship between ANT scores and global function as measured by the Glasgow Outcome Scale-Extended (GOSE).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized data collected from 48 participants with TBI.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • ANT's Construct Validity in TBI: The study provides strong evidence that the ANT has good construct validity in individuals with TBI, particularly in the post-acute phase of recovery. This means the ANT is measuring what it's intended to measure – attention and executive functions – in this population.
  • Executive Function Link: The ANT's executive network score and overall mean reaction time were significantly associated with the cognitive component representing processing speed and executive function. This aligns with the known role of these brain regions in executive control and conflict resolution, which the ANT's executive task directly probes.
  • Memory Disconnect: Crucially, the ANT did not predict the cognitive component related to memory. This finding is important because it suggests the ANT is specific to attention and executive functions and doesn't inadvertently capture memory deficits, further bolstering its validity as a targeted measure.
  • Global Function Association: While the overall ANT performance showed a weak association with global disability (GOSE), the ANT executive network score did show a significant, albeit counterintuitive, association: a stronger executive network was linked to greater disability. This warrants further investigation.
  • Potential for Clinical Trials: Given its established link to neural substrates and now its demonstrated construct validity in TBI, the ANT is proposed as a valuable outcome measure for future clinical trials, especially those targeting attention and executive function interventions.

Key Results

  • The ANT executive network score and mean reaction time significantly predicted the principal component of processing speed and executive function (R²=0.67, p<0.001).
  • The ANT did not predict the principal component of working and episodic memory (R²=0.34, p=0.18).
  • The ANT executive network score weakly but significantly predicted global function as measured by the GOSE (odds ratio = 1.02, p=0.01), with a stronger executive network associated with greater disability.
  • In participants with complicated mild TBI, the ANT executive network and mean reaction time were significant predictors of the processing speed/executive function component.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Injury Severity Bias: The sample was predominantly composed of individuals with complicated mild TBI. Exploratory analyses suggested results were driven by this subgroup, and the findings for moderate-severe TBI were less conclusive due to a small sample size. Future research should focus on larger, more diverse samples across the TBI severity spectrum.
  • Limited Executive Function Measures: The neuropsychological battery included a limited number of executive function measures. Including a broader range of executive tasks might reveal stronger associations with the ANT executive network.
  • Cross-Sectional Design: The study was cross-sectional, limiting the ability to track recovery trajectories. Longitudinal studies are needed to understand how ANT performance evolves over time and its relationship with long-term disability.
  • Small Sample Size: Despite finding significant associations, the relatively small sample size (N=45) means that larger studies are needed to confirm these findings and increase statistical power.
  • Unexplained Disability Association: The counterintuitive finding that a stronger ANT executive network was associated with greater disability needs further investigation. Factors not assessed in this study, such as neuropsychiatric symptoms (depression, anxiety), may play a moderating role.

Future work should focus on longitudinal studies, larger and more diverse TBI populations, and exploring the ecological validity of the ANT by linking it to real-world functional outcomes and activities of daily living. The ANT's potential for identifying injury pathology, guiding neurostimulation targets, and serving as a relevant cognitive endpoint in clinical trials is highlighted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cognitive impairment after traumatic brain injury (TBI) is persistent and disabling. Assessing cognitive function in a reliable and valid manner, using measures that are sensitive to the integrity of underlying neural substrates, is crucial in clinical research. The Attention Network Test (ANT) is one such assessment measure that has demonstrated associations with neural regions involved in attention; however, clinical utility of the ANT is limited because its relationship with neuropsychological measures of cognitive function (i.e., its construct validity) has not yet been established in TBI. We evaluated the association between the ANT and 1) a neuropsychological battery assessing executive function and memory and 2) global function assessed by the Glasgow Outcome Scale-Extended (GOSE). Forty-eight adults with complicated mild-severe TBI were evaluated ∼5 months post-injury. Using principal component analysis and multi-variate linear regression adjusted for age, gender, education, and cause of injury, we found that ANT reaction time and executive network scores predicted a principal component assessing processing speed and executive function. Conversely, the ANT did not predict a principal component assessing memory. The ANT was weakly associated with the GOSE. Among persons with TBI during the post-acute phase of recovery, the ANT has good construct validity as evidenced by its associations with neuropsychological measures of processing speed and executive function, but not memory. Given that ANT networks are known to relate to specific neuroanatomical regions, the ANT may be a useful outcome measure for evaluating novel therapeutics targeting attention and executive functions after TBI.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jaywant2023association,
  author = {Abhishek Jaywant and Emily Blunt and Keith Jamison and Nayoung Kim and Arindam RoyChoudhury and Nicholas D. Schiff and Amy Kuceyeski and Kristen Dams-O’Connor and Sudhin A. Shah},
  title = {{Association Between the Attention Network Test, Neuropsychological Measures, and Disability in Post-Acute Traumatic Brain Injury}},
  booktitle = {Neurotrauma},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1089/neur.2022.0068},
}
Figure